- 2004 term United States Supreme Court opinions of Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Concurrence
width=25px
Concurrence/dissent
white-space: nowrap |Total =
21
-
colspan=2 | Bench opinions = 21
colspan=2 | Opinions relating to orders = 0
colspan=2 | In-chambers opinions = 0
-
white-space: nowrap colspan=2 valign=top | Unanimous decisions: 3
colspan=2 valign=top | Most joined by: Breyer (15)
colspan=2 valign=top | Least joined by: Thomas (6)
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Rehnquist, Stevens, O'Connor, Kennedy, Souter, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Scalia filed a dissent.
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Stevens, Souter
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Stevens
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Unanimous
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top | U.S. Const. amend. IV
width=20% valign=top | Souter
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Ginsburg filed one of two dissents from Stevens' 6-2 decision upholding the constitutionality of a search for illegal drugs conducted without cause by a sniffing police dog during a traffic stop. Ginsburg wrote that the Court's decision "clears the way for suspicionless, dog-accompanied drug sweeps of parked cars along sidewalks and in parking lots. ... Nor would motorists have constitutional grounds for complaint should police with dogs, stationed at long traffic lights, circle cars waiting for the red signal to turn green."
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Thomas, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Rehnquist, Kennedy, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Souter, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Stevens, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy, Souter, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Rehnquist filed a dissent.
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Rehnquist, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy, Souter, Thomas, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Stevens filed a dissent.
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Unanimous
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Breyer; Scalia, Souter (in part)
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top |
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Scalia (in part)
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top | Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act
width=20% valign=top | Unanimous
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top | Americans with Disabilities Act
width=20% valign=top | Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top |
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Ginsburg filed one of two dissents from O'Connor's 5-4 decision.
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Stevens, O'Connor, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Ginsburg filed one of two dissents from Kennedy's 5-4 decision.
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Stevens, O'Connor, Kennedy, Souter, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Thomas filed a dissent.
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top |
width=20% valign=top | Rehnquist, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, Breyer
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Souter filed a dissent.
-
align=right valign=top
valign=top | Copyright
width=20% valign=top | Rehnquist, Kennedy
-
bgcolor=#EEEEEE colspan=3 valign=top | Ginsburg joined in Souter's unanimous opinion and filed a separate concurrence.
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.