The Uneasy Case for Copyright
- The Uneasy Case for Copyright
"The Uneasy Case for Copyright: A Study of Copyright in Books, Photocopies, and Computer Programs" was an article in the "Harvard Law Review" by future United States Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer in 1970, while he was still a legal academic. The article was a challenge to copyright expansionism, which was just entering its modern phase, and was still largely unquestioned in the United States.fact|date=October 2008 It became one of the most widely cited skeptical examinations of copyright.fact|date=October 2008
In this piece, Breyer made several points:
* That the only defensible justification of copyright is a consequentialist economic balance between maximizing the distribution of works and encouraging their production.
* That there is significant historical, logical, and anecdotal evidence which shows that exclusive rights will provide only limited increases in the volume of literary production, particularly within certain sections of the book market.
* That there was limited justification for contemporary expansions in the scope and duration of copyright.
There was a formal reply by law student Barry W. Tyerman in the "UCLA Law Review", and a rejoinder by Breyer, but the article appears to have had little impact on copyright policy in the lead up to the Copyright Act of 1976.
In their mathematical law and economics article "An Economic Analysis of Copyright Law" (1989), William Landes and Richard Posner systematically analysed each of Breyer's arguments and concluded that "they do not make a persuasive case for eliminating copyright protection." In particular they noted that many of his arguments rested on imperfect copying technology, an argument which weakens with technological innovation.
References
*
*
*
*
Wikimedia Foundation.
2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Copyright in Historical Perspective — nopyright in Historical Perspective is an influential work of copyright scholarship by Lyman Ray Patterson. The book traces the history of Anglo Saxon copyright from the outgoing 15th century to the late 19th century. Starting with William Caxton … Wikipedia
Street Performer Protocol — The Street Performer Protocol (SPP) is a way of encouraging the creation of creative works in the public domain, described by the cryptographers John Kelsey and Bruce Schneier [ [http://schneier.com/paper street performer.html The Street… … Wikipedia
Droit d'auteur — Propriété intellectuelle Propriété littéraire et artistique Droit d auteur et copyright Droits voisins Propriété industrielle Créations utilitaires: Brevet Secret industriel et … Wikipédia en Français
intellectual-property law — Introduction the legal regulations governing an individual s or an organization s right to control the use or dissemination of ideas or information. Various systems of legal rules exist that empower persons and organizations to exercise… … Universalium
Stephen Breyer — Infobox Judge name = Stephen Gerald Breyer imagesize = caption = office = Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court termstart = August 3, 1994 termend = nominator = Bill Clinton appointer = predecessor = Harry A. Blackmun successor =… … Wikipedia
List of minor characters in the Matrix series — Many of the characters listed here have names reflecting certain aspects of them, such as their status, personality or role. Contents 1 Apoc 2 Captain Ballard 3 Bane/Smith 3.1 Bane … Wikipedia
Street Performer Protocol — Das Street Performer Protocol (SPP, englisch für „Straßenkünstlerprotokoll“) ist eine Methode, die Schaffung schöpferischer Werke zu fördern, welche gemeinfrei öffentlich zugänglich gemacht werden. Entwickelt wurde es von den Kryptologen John… … Deutsch Wikipedia
Dormant Commerce Clause — The Dormant Commerce Clause, also known as the Negative Commerce Clause, is a legal doctrine that courts in the United States have inferred from the Commerce Clause in Article I of the United States Constitution. The Commerce Clause expressly… … Wikipedia
Western painting — The history of Western painting represents a continuous, though disrupted, tradition from Antiquity. [Art of the Western World: From Ancient Greece to Post Modernism (Paperback)by Bruce Cole, Simon and Shuster, 1981,… … Wikipedia
History of painting — The history of painting reaches back in time to artifacts from pre historic humans, and spans all cultures. The history of painting represents a continuous, though disrupted, tradition from Antiquity. Across cultures, and spanning continents and… … Wikipedia
