- Genetic discrimination
Genetic discrimination occurs when people are treated differently by their
employeror insurance companybecause they have a gene mutationthat causes or increases the risk of an inherited disorder. People who undergo genetic testingmay be at risk for genetic discrimination.
The results of a genetic test are normally included in a person's
medical records. When a person applies for life, disability, or health insurance, in some countries the insurance company may ask to look at these records before making a decision about coverage. An employer may also have the right to look at an employee's medical records. As a result, genetic test results could affect a person's insurance coverage or employment. People making decisions about genetic testing should be aware that when test results are placed in their medical records, the results might not be kept private.
Fear of discrimination is a concern among people considering
genetic testing. Several countries have laws that help protect people against genetic discrimination; however, genetic testing is a fast-growing field and these laws don't cover every situation.
Public Concern Against Discrimination
In 1993, the Ethical, Legal and Social Implications (ELSI) Working Group of the Human Genome Project issued a report titled "Genetic Information and Health Insurance". The report recommended that people be eligible for health insurance no matter what is known about their past, present or future health status. Two years later, the ELSI Working Group and the National Action Plan on Breast Cancer (NAPBC) jointly developed guidelines to assist federal and state agencies in preventing genetic discrimination in health insurance.
Further, the ELSI Working Group and NAPBC recommended that health insurers be prohibited from using genetic information or an individual's request for genetic services to deny or limit health insurance coverage, establish differential rates or have access to an individual's genetic information without that individual's written authorization. Written authorization, the groups said, should be required for each separate disclosure and should specify the recipient of the disclosed information.
Next, the National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI) and the
United States Department of Energy, acting through the ELSI Working Group, cosponsored a series of workshops in the mid-1990s on genetic discrimination in health insurance and the workplace. The findings and recommendations of the workshop participants were published in Science: (Genetic Information and the Workplace: Legislative Approaches and Policy Challenges [sciencemag.org] ) magazine, the monthly journal of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.
In 2008, the New York Times reported that some individuals avoid genetic testing out of fear it will impede their ability to purchase insurance or find a job. They also reported that evidence of actual discrimination was rare. [Amy Harmon, [http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/24/health/24dna.html?_r=2&scp=5&sq=Genetic&st=nyt&oref=slogin&oref=slogin "Insurance Fears Lead Many to Shun DNA Tests,"]
The New York Times, February 24, 2008]
Use of Genetic Information by Health Insurers
Health insurers do not currently require applicants for coverage to undergo genetic testing. Employer-sponsored group coverage is underwritten on a group basis, rather than an individual basis. Thus, the future use of genetic information in medical underwriting is a significant potential issue only for the individual health insurance market. However, the cost of covering diagnostic genetic tests and genetic treatments is likely to be an issue for all forms of health insurance. When insurers encounter genetic information, it is subject to the same confidentiality protections as any other sensitive health information. [ [http://www.actuary.org/pdf/health/geneticmono.pdf "Genetic Information and Medical Expense Insurance,"]
American Academy of Actuaries, June 2000] Because of their long-term nature, genetic information is a potentially much more significant issue for individually purchased Disability insuranceand Long term care insurance. [ [http://www.actuary.org/pdf/health/genetic_25apr02.pdf "The Use Of Genetic Information In Disability Income And Long-Term Care Insurance,"] American Academy of Actuaries, Spring 2002]
Laws Against Discrimination
Those recommendations, and earlier ones issued by the
ELSIWorking Group and NAPBC led, in part, to new legislation and policies at both the federal and state levels. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act(HIPAA) of 1996 provided the first federal protections against genetic discrimination in health insurance. The act prohibited health insurers from excluding individuals from group coverage due to past or present medical problems, including genetic predisposition to certain diseases. It limited exclusions from group plans for preexisting conditions to 12 months and prohibited such exclusions for people who had been covered previously for that condition for 12 months or more. And the law specifically stated that genetic information in the absence of a current diagnosis of illness did not constitute a preexisting condition.
The next step in addressing the issue of genetic discrimination was taken by President
Bill Clinton. The President had earlier supported proposed legislation that would have banned all health plans - group or individual - from denying coverage or raising premiums on the basis of genetic information. When the legislation failed to pass Congress, President Clinton issued an executive order ( Executive Order 13145 to Prohibit Discrimination in Federal Employment Based on Genetic Information) in February 2000 prohibiting agencies of the federal government from obtaining genetic information about their employees or job applicants and from using genetic information in hiring and promotion decisions.
There continues to be a high degree of interest in these topics in state legislatures. More than one hundred bills were introduced in state legislatures in 2000 alone. Some would inaugurate protection from genetic discrimination while others would modify or clarify existing legislation.
Legislation in the
United Statescalled the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Actprohibits group health plans and health insurers from denying coverage to a healthy individual or charging that person higher premiums based solely on a genetic predispositionto developing a disease in the future. The legislation also bars employers from using individuals’ genetic information when making hiring, firing, job placement, or promotiondecisions. [http://www.genome.gov/Pages/PolicyEthics/GeneticDiscrimination/SAPonHR493.pdf Statement of Administration policy] , Executive Office of the President, Office of Management and Budget, 27 April 2007] It was signed into law by the President on May 21 2008.cite news | url=http://blog.wired.com/wiredscience/2008/05/the-genetic-inf.html | title=Genetic Discrimination by Insurers, Employers Becomes a Crime | author=Keim, Brandon | work=Wired.com | date= May 21 2008| accessdate=2008-05-28] [ [http://www.kaisernetwork.org/daily_reports/rep_index.cfm?DR_ID=52305 "Administration News | President Bush Signs Genetic Nondiscrimination Legislation Into Law,"] Kaiser Daily Health Policy Report, Kaiser Family Foundation, May 22, 2008]
Gattaca-- A film about Genetic discrimination
Human Genome Project
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act
National Human Genome Research Institute
BBC Newscite web | title= US Blocks Genetic Discrimination | first=BBC News | authorlink=BBC News | date= 25 April 2008| url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/7366264.stm
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.