The Science of God

The Science of God

"The Science of God" is a book by Alister McGrath summarising his three-volume "A Scientific Theology".

ections

Introduction

1. Prolegomena

2. Nature

3. Reality

In this section McGrath suggests "inter alia" that "one approach to the failure of the Enlightenment is to argue for a communitarian approach to knowledge" [Citing Richard Rorty] but "there are a number of difficulties with this approach." He discusses George Lindbeck's coherentist approach as "inadequate" and needing to be supplemented. He criticises the (naive) foundationalism of Descartes and Frege, suggesting that this "has now been rejected by virtually every major epistemologist and philosopher of science ... the belief that foundationalism is philosophically indefensible is the closest thing to a philosophical consensus that there has heen for a long time". [ p99, he cites the later Wittgenstein, Karl Popper, W. E. Sallars and W.V.O. Quine] He commends the work of Alasdair MacIntyre and suggests that Roger Penrose in Shadows of the Mind "argued that the most satisfactory explanation of the beauty and structure of mathematics is that they were somehow given by God". [p 116] He thinks John Milbank is unquestionably right ... to affirm the importance of the Christian tradition in the theological enterprise" whilst suggesting that Milbank, mistakenly, refuses to engage with other traditions, tends to marginalise the role of scripture, and objects strongly to dialogue between traditions. [pp 123-125]

In Chapter 9 "The Foundations of realism in the Natural Sciences" he commends Polkinghorne's critical realist approach, as against idealism, positivism, instrumentalism and post-modernism, and in Ch 10 "Critical Realism: engaging with a stratified reality" he specifically commends and explores the critical realism of Roy Bhaskar, continuing to cite Polkinghorne. He especially likes the concept of "stratified reality ... the word must be regarded as differentiated and stratified. Each individual science deals with a different stratum of this reality". [p 146] In Ch 11 sketches "The Contours of a Scientific Theology" which he says:
# takes the form of a coherent response to an existing reality
# is an "a posteriori" discipline
# takes account of the unique character of its object
# offers an explanation of reality [p 153]

4. Theory

McGrath suggests that "theories, whether scientific or theological ... are constructed in response to an encounter with existing reality". [p 171]

In "Chapter 12: The Legitimacy of Theory within a Scientific Theology", he suggests that "the driving force behind theory is ...an intellectual curiosity ... the relentless human yearning to see the 'big picture'". [p 172, he calls this an 'eros of the mind' (Augustine of Hippo)] He cites Irenaeus, Heidegger and Habermas and Wlad Godzich and suggests that there is a progression::observation -> theory -> worldview

He prefers to use the term "doctrine" as "a theory which is the accepted teaching of the Church".

Conclusion

Reviews and comments

In this unusual book, based on his more academic trilogy "A Scientific Theology", the author discusses in some detail how systematic theology should be conducted in the light of an understanding of the natural sciences. While "resolutely evangelical in orientation", his approach has been commended by a variety of both Protestant and Roman Catholic theologians. [ [http://www.cis.org.uk/resources/books/book_recommendations.shtml scroll for title] ]

Publication information

# Paperback: 256 pages
# Publisher: Continuum International Publishing Group Ltd. (29 April 2004)
# Language: English
# ISBN-13: 978-0567083531

Notes and References


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • The Story of God — is a three part video series produced by Dangerous Films featuring physician, Professor and British Lord Robert Winston. It first aired on 4, 11 and 18 December 2005 on BBC One. It was rebroadcast by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation in May… …   Wikipedia

  • The Hammer of God — infobox Book | name = The Hammer of God title orig = translator = image caption = author = Arthur C. Clarke illustrator = cover artist = Stephen Youll country = Great Britain language = English series = genre = Science fiction novel publisher =… …   Wikipedia

  • The Forge of God — infobox Book | name = The Forge of God title orig = translator = image caption = Cover of first edition (hardcover) author = Greg Bear illustrator = cover artist = country = United States language = English series = The Forge of God series genre …   Wikipedia

  • The Death of God — Infobox Single Name = The Death of God Artist = Roy Harper from Album = B side = The Death of God (Short Version) Released = April 2005 Format = CD Recorded = 2005 Genre = Folk, Rock Length = Track 1. 13:18 Track 2. 2:58 Label = Science Friction… …   Wikipedia

  • The Sword of God — Infobox Album Name = The Sword of God Type = studio Longtype = Artist = Quasi Released = 2001 Recorded = Genre = Indie rock Length = 52:54 Label = Touch Go Producer = Quasi Reviews = *Allmusic Rating|4.0|5… …   Wikipedia

  • The Mote in God's Eye —   …   Wikipedia

  • The Science of Getting Rich — is a book written by the New Thought Movement writer Wallace D. Wattles; it was published in 1910 by Elizabeth Towne. The book is still in print after almost 100 years. It was a major inspiration for Rhonda Byrne s bestselling book and film and… …   Wikipedia

  • The Scourge of God (novel) — Infobox Book name = The Scourge of God title orig = translator = image caption = author = S. M. Stirling illustrator = cover artist = country = United States language = English series = The Emberverse series genre = Science fiction novel… …   Wikipedia

  • The Science of Good and Evil — Infobox Book name = The Science of Good and Evil: Why People Cheat, Gossip, Care, Share, and Follow the Golden Rule author = Michael Shermer publisher = Henry Holt and Company release date = 2004 media type = Print (hardcover and paperback) pages …   Wikipedia

  • The Science of Discworld III: Darwin's Watch — Terry Pratchett The Discworld series 3rd science book Outline Characters Unseen University Staff …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”