Ordination of women in the Anglican Diocese of Sydney

The ordination of women in the Anglican Diocese of Sydney, as presbyters and bishops but not as deacons, is rejected.

Diocesan position

One of the differences between Sydney and the majority of other Anglican dioceses in Australia has been its unwillingness to allow the ordination of women to the priesthood (itself a term infrequently used in the diocese) or presbyterate. This issue is an indicator of Sydney's difference in ecclesiology and theology to most other dioceses within the Anglican Communion.

For many Anglicans outside Evangelical churches and even for many Sydney Anglicans within Evangelical churches, the central act of worship is the celebration of the Eucharist. Within the Anglican Communion the Eucharist can only be presided over by an ordained priest (presbyter). For many who have opposed the ordination of women the sex of the priest who presides at the Eucharist has been a major issue. But in the Sydney diocese the sex of the person who presides at the Eucharist is of less significance than the matter of headship in the church and in the preaching and teaching which is central to Evangelical ministry.

Interpretations of the teachings of Paul

The reason for Sydney's strong opposition towards the ordination of women to the presbyterate is based partly upon their interpretation of the teachings of the Apostle Paul in respect to the understanding of the Greek word kephale (κεφαλη) mentioned in Ephesians 5:23, as well as the prohibition given to female teachers in 1 Timothy 2:11 and the roles of men and women outlined in his first letter to the Corinthians.

The diocese has, however, ordained women as deacons since 1989.^[1] Women who are ordained as priests outside the diocese, such as the Revd Sue Pain who returned to Sydney to take up the position of assistant at St James', King Street, are acknowledged by the diocese as a deacons rather than priests.^[2] In 1994 Archbishop Goodhew appointed a deacon, the Revd Dianne Nicolios, as archdeacon in charge of women's ministries.

Legal action

In 1992 a then member of the standing committee of the diocesan synod, Laurie Scandrett, joined with the Revd Dalba Primmer (the then Rector of St John's Bega in the Diocese of Canberra and Goulburn) and the Revd David Robarts (then the incumbent of Christ Church, Brunswick in the Diocese of Melbourne) in a court action (Scandrett v Dowling (1992) 27 NSWLR 483) to prevent the Bishop of Canberra and Goulburn from ordaining women as presbyters. The action failed in the New South Wales Court of Appeal although it delayed the ordination by several months.

Continuing disagreement

Sydney's stand on this issue has been a source of bitterness for a significant minority within the diocese, as indicated by the bulletins of the Movement for the Ordination of Women, as well as an occasional cause of tension between Sydney and the Diocese of Melbourne.^{[citation needed]} However, a number of prominent Sydney Anglicans who are supportive of the ordination of women have ministered or are currently ministering in Melbourne — for example Archbishop Peter Watson (retired December 2006)^[3], Bishop Stephen Hale and Archdeacon Dianne Nicolios.

References

1. ^ http://www.sydneyanglicans.net/portal/historyofsydneydiocese.pdf
2. ^ The Revd Lu Piper: "The situation was akin to becoming an apprentice plumber and staying an apprentice for the rest of your life no matter how good your qualification...." as quoted by Julia Baird, SMH 27 May 2002
3. ^ Dr Philip Freier enthroned as 10th Archbishop of Melbourne