Myra (painting)

1995 depiction of Myra Hindley by the Young British Artist Marcus Harvey

Myra is a large painting created by Marcus Harvey in 1995. It became notorious when it was exhibited at the Sensation exhibition of Young British Artists at the Royal Academy of Art in London from 8 September to 28 December 1997.

Painting

The work measures 9 by 11 feet (2.7 by 3.4 m). At first sight, it resembles a greatly magnified version of a black and white photograph printed in a newspaper, similar to the works of Chuck Close. It was made using casts of an infant's hand to build up a mosaic of black, grey and white handprints, creating a reproduction of the iconic police photograph of a hard-faced Myra Hindley with bouffant peroxide blonde hair taken after her arrest in 1965 (although often reported to have been taken around the time of the trial of the Moors murders in 1966). The photograph is widely recognised in Britain, having been published in British newspapers in the decades after Hindley's conviction.^[1] Harvey has said, "The whole point of the painting is the photograph. That photograph. The iconic power that has come to it as a result of years of obsessive media reproduction."^[2] The painting consciously juxtaposes, as Jennifer Friedlander describes it, the tiny handprints of an "innocent child" and the "depraved world of adults", writ large on a gigantic canvas.^[3]

Harvey has also commented: "I know enough to know that she probably didn't do any of the murders, that she was just in a relationship where she was probably too attached to the man who was doing it to extricate herself. That her life was probably too dull and boring to throw the relationship away ... I don't believe that's 30-years-worth of reputation as one of the most vile and notorious murderers in British criminal history."^[4]

Harvey's agent bought the work, and sold it to Charles Saatchi for £11,000. Saatchi later sold it for an estimated £100,000.^[5] It is now owned by US commodities trader Frank Gallipoli.^[6]

Sensation exhibition

The painting was included in the controversial Sensation exhibition of Young British Artists at the Royal Academy of Art in London in 1997. Norman Rosenthal, the Secretary of the Royal Academy, described it as the single most important painting in the show – "a very, very cathartic picture ... It is an incredibly serious and sober work of art that needs to be seen."^[4] However, it provoked angry press and public comment before the exhibition opened, including the ironic comment in an editorial in The Sun: "Myra Hindley is to be hung in the Royal Academy. Sadly it is only a painting of her".^[7]

Four members of the Royal Academy – Craigie Aitchison, Gillian Ayres, Michael Sandle and John Ward – resigned in protest at its inclusion in the exhibition.^[8][9] The Metropolitan Police Clubs and Vice Unit visited the exhibition before it opened, but could find insufficient evidence to bring a prosecution in respect of any of the exhibits under the Obscene Publications Act.^[10]

Winnie Johnson (mother of Keith Bennett, one of Hindley's victims, whose body remains missing) asked for the portrait to be excluded from the exhibition to protect her feelings. She joined a protest group, Mothers Against Murder and Aggression, that picketed the show's first day on 18 September.^[11] The charity Kidscape accused the Royal Academy of "sick exploitation of dead children" in an effort to attract paying visitors to address its financial deficit.^[12].

Windows at Burlington House, where the Academy is based, were smashed. The painting was vandalised twice, by two different artists, on the opening day of the exhibition, 18 September 1997. In the first attack, Peter Fisher smuggled blue and red Indian ink into the exhibition, concealed inside two camera film cases; he threw the ink over the painting and smeared it in. After witnessing the first attack, Jacques Rolé left the exhibition to buy six eggs from Fortnum & Mason, on the other side of Piccadilly close to the Royal Academy, and threw three or four at the painting before being stopped by an off-duty police officer.^[13][14]

The painting was removed to be restored, and was rehung after two weeks behind a protective perspex screen. Security guards stood nearby while the exhibition was open to the public.^[15]

Hindley wrote from prison to ask for her portrait to be removed from the exhibition, reasoning that such action was necessary because the work was "a sole disregard not only for the emotional pain and trauma that would inevitably be experienced by the families of the Moors victims but also the families of any child victim."^[16][17] Despite all the protests, the painting continued to hang at the exhibition. The exhibition drew approximately 300,000 visitors, significantly more than usual, but less than the 813,000 visitors attracted to the Royal Academy's Monet exhibition in 1999.^[18]

The reaction to Harvey's painting in London has been compared to that received by Andy Warhol's 36-feet-square mural Thirteen Most Wanted Men, which comprised large copies of photographs from a "most wanted" booklet published by the New York Police Department, and was installed in the New York State Pavilion at the 1964 World's Fair. After protests by sponsors, Warhol's work was quickly painted over.^[4][19] The reaction to the potent mixture of the sacred and the profane parallels that to Andres Serrano's prize-winning 1987 photograph Piss Christ in Washington DC in 1989 and in Melbourne in 1997, and Chris Ofili's Turner Prize-winning painting The Holy Virgin Mary in New York in 1999.

Later impact

The work was shown when the Sensation show went on tour, at the Berlin Hamburger Bahnhof museum from 30 September 1998 to 30 January 1999, and at the Brooklyn Museum of Art from 2 October 1999 to 9 January 2000, and later at the Saatchi Gallery at County Hall in central London.

Harvey's painting remained almost unknown in the US, and caused little reaction when the exhibition opened in New York in 1999. Chris Ofili's The Holy Virgin Mary attracted greater opprobrium: it was called "sick" and "disgusting" by New York mayor Rudolph Giuliani, and white paint was thrown over it.^[13]

Harvey's painting made a controversial brief appearance in a promotional video for the 2012 Olympic Games in 2008.^[20]

References

1. ^ "Image that for 36 years fixed a killer in the public mind", The Guardian, 16 November 2002
2. ^ White Cube: Marcus Harvey
3. ^ "Feminine look: sexuation, spectatorship, subversion", Jennifer Friedlander, SUNY Press, 2008, ISBN 0791472957, p.80, 88
4. ^ ^{a b c} White Cube: Marcus Harvey, The Hand That Rocked the Academy by Gordon Burn, The Guardian, 6 September 1997
5. ^ "Myra, Margaret and me", The Guardian, 21 February 2009
6. ^ Where did all the Sensation art go?, 2 October 2006
7. ^ "Judging the image: art, value, law", Alison Young ,"Judging the Image: Art, Value, Law". Routledge, January, 2005. p. 34. ISBN 0-4153-0183-1
8. ^ Young, p.34
9. ^ Stallabrass, p.313
10. ^ Young, p.35
11. ^ Alberge, Dalya (19 September 1997), "Attacks force Hindley portrait to be moved", The Times 
12. ^ Quoted in Friedlander, p.85
13. ^ ^{a b} Art crimes: Myra
14. ^ High Art Lite: British Art in the 1990s, Julian Stallabrass, Verso, 2001, ISBN 1859843182, p.201-210
15. ^ "Sensation sparks New York storm", BBC, 23 September 1999.
16. ^ Lyall, Sarah (20 September 1997), "Art That Tweaks British Propriety", New York Times, http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A0CEEDD1F38F933A1575AC0A961958260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=all 
17. ^ Young, p.34.
18. ^ Stallabrass, p.201
19. ^ Andy Warhol Chronology: April 22, 1964: World's Fair opens with Warhol's Most Wanted Men mural painted silver
20. ^ Myra Hindley painting taints London 2012 celebrations, The Times, 25 August 2008, 2012 Hindley image use condemned, BBC News, 25 August 2008