Discontinuous-constituent phrase structure grammar

Discontinuous-constituent Phrase Structure Grammar (DCPSG) (distinct from Discontinuous Phrase Structure Grammar/DPSG) is a formalism for describing discontinuous phrase structures in natural language, such as verb phrases in VSO languages. The formalism was introduced in the slightly more constrained form of Discontinuous-constituent Phrase Structure Grammar with Subscripts and Deletes (DCPSGsd) in Harman (1963)^[1]. DCPSGs describe a superset of the context-free languages, by means of rewrite rules that permit a limited amount of wrapping, similar to that found in Head grammar.

Description

Rewrite rules of a DCPSG are identical to those of a CFG, with the addition of a meta-symbol, denoted here as an underscore. DCPSG rules therefore have the general form $X \to \alpha$ where α is a string of terminal symbols and/or non-terminal symbols and at most one underscore.

The rewrite semantics of DCPSG are identical as those of a CFG when the rule being used does not contain an underscore: given a rule $X \to \alpha$, an occurrence of X may be rewritten as α.

For rules with an underscore, the rewrite semantics are slightly different: given a rule $X \to \alpha \_ \beta$, an occurrence of X can be rewritten as α, with β being inserted immediately after the next non-terminal that is introduced at the same time. Using strict left-most productions, β is simply inserted immediately after the non-terminal that follows X prior to the rewrite.

Example

We can characterize the gross sentence structure of a VSO language such as Irish with the following rules (substituting English words for Irish words, and using subscripts solely for demonstration of discontinuity):

$S \to VP\ NP_{subj}$

$VP \to ITV ~|~ TV \ \_ \ NP_{obj}$

$NP \to John ~|~ Susan ~|~ ...$

$ITV \to ran ~|~ danced ~|~ ...$

$TV \to saw ~|~ met ~|~ ...$

A derivation for the sentence saw John Susan, where John is the subject, and Susan is the direct object forming a VP with saw is:

$S \to VP\ NP_{subj} \to TV\ NP_{subj} NP_{obj} \to saw\ NP_{subj}\ NP_{obj} \to saw\ John\ NP_{obj} \to saw\ John\ Mary$

References

1. ^ Harman, Gilbert H. 1963. Generative Grammars without Transformation Rules: A Defense of Phrase Structure. Language 39(4), 597-616.