Paul Kammerer

Paul Kammerer

Infobox Scientist
name = PAGENAME
box_width =


image_width =150px
caption = PAGENAME
birth_date = August 17, 1880
birth_place = Vienna
death_date = September 23, 1926
death_place = Puchberg am Schneeberg
residence =
citizenship =
nationality = Austrian
ethnicity =
field =
work_institutions =
alma_mater =
doctoral_advisor =
doctoral_students =
known_for = Lamarckian theory of inheritance
author_abbrev_bot =
author_abbrev_zoo =
influences =
influenced =
prizes =
religion =
footnotes =

Paul Kammerer (August 17, 1880 in Vienna – September 23, 1926 in Puchberg am Schneeberg) was a renowned Austrian biologist who studied and advocated the discredited Lamarckian theory of inheritance – the notion that organisms may pass to their offspring characteristics they have acquired in their lifetime. He began his academic career at the Vienna Academy studying music but graduated with a degree in biology.

Work

Like many of his generation, Kammerer undertook numerous experiments, largely involving interfering with the breeding and development of amphibians. He interested himself in the Lamarckian doctrine of acquired characteristics and eventually reported that a Midwife toad was exhibiting a black pad on its foot - an acquired characteristic brought about by adaptation to environment.

Claims arose that the result of the experiment had been falsified. The most notable of these claims was made by Dr. G. K. Noble, Curator of Reptiles at the American Museum of Natural History, in the scientific journal "Nature". ["Nature", August 7 1926] He reported that the black pad actually had a far more mundane explanation: it had simply been injected there with Indian ink. Six weeks later, Kammerer committed suicide.

Aftermath

Interest in Kammerer revived in 1971, when he became the subject of a book by Arthur Koestler, "The Case of the Midwife Toad". Koestler surmised that Kammerer's experiments on the midwife toad may have been tampered with by a Nazi sympathizer at the University of Vienna. Certainly, as Koestler writes, "the "Hakenkreuzler", the swastika-wearers, as the [Austrian] Nazis of the early days were called, were growing in power. One of the centers of ferment was the University of Vienna [ [http://www.univie.ac.at/archiv/tour/19.htm University 1938-1945 ] ] where, on the traditional Saturday morning student parades, bloody battles were fought. Kammerer was known by his public lectures and newspaper articles as an ardent pacifist and Socialist; it was also known that he was going to build an institute in Soviet Russia. An act of sabotage in the laboratory would have been ... in keeping with the climate of those days."

Also, the toad had been brought to England by Kammerer to be displayed during lectures not long before, as a specimen of an acquired characteristic. During this visit it had been handled by eminent pro-Darwinian zoologists, all of whom detested the possibility of Lamarckianism being valid. None of the irregularities discovered by Noble were detected at the time, and since Noble claimed the injected ink was rather conspicuous this suggests that the "act of sabotage" had been committed shortly before Noble's visit to Vienna, when Kammerer was no longer working at the institute.

As a consequence of the fraud, interest in Lamarckian inheritance diminished except in the Soviet Union where it was championed by Lysenko. The orthodox view among the biological establishment remains that acquired characteristics cannot be inherited.

This is in the face of much other laboratory work of Kammerer's over several years with, for example, sea squirts and salamanders where just such inheritance was demonstrated. Many biologists from all over Europe visited him in Vienna and photographs and reports of his work were widely available. Kammerer himself regarded the possible inheritance of a pad on the foot of a male midwife toad as of relatively minor significance in the argument for Lamarckian inheritance. He approved the inspection of the specimen which was found to have been fraudulently tampered with, and expressed great astonishment when the fraud was made known to him.

eriality theory

Kammerer's other passion was collecting coincidences. He published a book with the title "Das Gesetz der Serie" ("The Law of the Series"; never translated into English) in which he recounted 100 or so anecdotes of coincidences that had led him to formulate his theory of Seriality.

He postulated that all events are connected by waves of Seriality. These forces would cause what we would perceive as just the peaks, or groupings and coincidences. Kammerer was known to, for example, make notes in public parks of what numbers of people were passing by, how many carried umbrellas, etc. In reviewing the book, Albert Einstein called the idea of Seriality "Interesting, and by no means absurd." Fact|date=June 2008

Koestler reported that when researching his biography of the coincidence collector, Kammerer, he himself was subjected to "a meteor shower" of coincidences. It was as if Kammerer's ghost were grinning down at him saying, "I told you so!" Fact|date=June 2008

Notes

*cite journal
quotes = no
last=Gliboff
first=Sander
authorlink=
year=2005
month=Dec
title="Protoplasm...is soft wax in our hands": Paul Kammerer and the art of biological transformation
journal=Endeavour
volume=29
issue=4
pages=162–7
publisher =
location =
issn =
pmid = 16271762
doi = 10.1016/j.endeavour.2005.10.001
bibcode =
oclc =
id =
url =
language =
format =
accessdate =
laysummary =
laysource =
laydate =
quote =

*cite journal
quotes = no
last=Sermonti
first=G
authorlink=
year=
month=
title=Epigenetic heredity. In praise of Paul Kammerer
journal=Riv. Biol.
volume=93
issue=1
pages=5–12
publisher =
location =
issn =
pmid = 10901054
bibcode =
oclc =
id =
url =
language =
format =
accessdate =
laysummary =
laysource =
laydate =
quote =

*cite journal
quotes = no
last=Lachman
first=E
authorlink=
year=1976
month=Mar
title=Famous scientific hoaxes
journal=The Journal of the Oklahoma State Medical Association
volume=69
issue=3
pages=87–90
publisher =
location =
issn =
pmid = 775032
bibcode =
oclc =
id =
url =
language =
format =
accessdate =
laysummary =
laysource =
laydate =
quote =

*cite journal
quotes = no
last=Meinecke
first=G
authorlink=
year=1973
month=Sep
title= [The tragedy about Paul Kammerer. A scientific psychological example]
journal=Die Medizinische Welt
volume=24
issue=38
pages=1462–6
publisher =
location =
issn =
pmid = 4587964
bibcode =
oclc =
id =
url =
language =
format =
accessdate =
laysummary =
laysource =
laydate =
quote =

*cite journal
quotes = no
last=Hirschmüller
first=A
authorlink=
year=1991
month=
title=Not Available
journal=Medizinhistorisches Journal
volume=26
issue=1-2
pages=26–77
publisher =
location =
issn =
pmid = 11612737
bibcode =
oclc =
id =
url =
language =
format =
accessdate =
laysummary =
laysource =
laydate =
quote =

References

Arthur Koestler, "The Case of the Midwife Toad", London: Hutchinson, 1971.

External links

* [http://www.nndb.com/people/265/000057094/ NNDB on Paul Kammerer]
* [http://home.nycap.rr.com/useless/kammerer/ Useless Stuff on Paul Kammerer]
* [http://www.museumofhoaxes.com/hoax/Hoaxipedia/Case_of_the_Midwife_Toad/ The Case of the Midwife Toad]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Paul Kammerer — (* 17. August 1880 in Wien; † 23. September 1926 in Puchberg am Schneeberg) war ein österreichischer Biologe, der durch seine Versuche mit Geburtshelferkröten, mit denen er die Vererbung erworbener Eigenschaften beweis …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Paul Kammerer — Pour les articles homonymes, voir Kammerer. Paul Kammerer (1880 1923). Photographie conservée à la bibliothèque du Congrès des États Unis. Paul Kammerer, né le …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Kammerer — ist ein Familienname. Bekannte Namensträger Anton Kammerer (1862–1884), österreichischer Anarchist, Deserteur und Raubmörder Axel Kammerer (* 1964), deutscher Eishockeyspieler, Trainer Carl Kammerer, Mitgründer des Wiener Unternehmens Starke… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Kammerer — may refer to:* Zoltán Kammerer * Maxim Kammerer * Paul Kammerer * Carl Kammerer * 112233 Kammerer …   Wikipedia

  • Kammerer — Cette page d’homonymie répertorie les différents sujets et articles partageant un même nom. Anton Kammerer était un anarchiste autrichien. Axel Kammerer est un joueur de Hockey sur glace allemand né en 1964, actuellement entraineur. Voir la page… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Paul Bargeton — est un diplomate français élevé à la dignité d ambassadeur de France en 1947, né le 11 mars 1882 à Chambéry et mort le 18 janvier 1963. Son nom a été donné à une place de la commune de Mézy sur Seine, dont il fut maire. Sommaire 1 Famille 2… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Paul Moder — (1933) Paul Moder (* 1. Oktober 1896 in Neheim; † 8. Februar 1942 bei Maly Kalinez/Oblast Nowgorod) war ein deutscher Politiker (NSDAP), Freikorps und SS Führer. Ab 1932 war er Reichstagsabgeordneter, nach der „Machtergreifung …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Paul Sniderman — Paul Sniderman, Ph.D., an American political scientist, is the Fairleigh S. Dickinson Jr. Professor of Public Policy at Stanford University. [ [http://politicalscience.stanford.edu/faculty/sniderman.html Staff page at Stanford University] He is… …   Wikipedia

  • Paul Fugger — Paul Graf Fugger (auch: Paul Graf Fugger Kirchberg Weißenhorn) (* 13. Oktober 1637 in Augsburg; † 27. April 1701 in München war Reichshofrat und kurbayerischer Obersthofmeister. Paul Graf Fugger war das 15. Kind von Otto Heinrich (genannt… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Paul Graf Fugger — (auch: Paul Graf Fugger Kirchberg Weißenhorn) (* 13. Oktober 1637 in Augsburg; † 27. April 1701 in München war Reichshofrat und kurbayerischer Obersthofmeister. Paul Graf Fugger war das 15. Kind von Otto Heinrich (genannt Ottheinrich) Graf Fugger …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”