Murdoch v. Murdoch

Murdoch v. Murdoch
Murdoch v. Murdoch
Supreme Court of Canada.jpg

Supreme Court of Canada

Hearing:
Judgment:
Full case name: '
Citations: [1975] 1 S.C.R. 423
Court membership
Reasons given

Murdoch v. Murdoch [1975] 1 S.C.R. 423 was controversial decision by the Supreme Court of Canada where the Court denied an abused farm wife any interest in the family farm.[1] This case is most notable for the public outcry it created at the time and for what many believe is Bora Laskin's most famous dissenting opinion.[citation needed]

Irene Murdoch, the wife of an Albertan farmer, submitted a claim for half the interest in the family ranch that was registered under the husband's name. The question put before the Court was whether there was an implied trust on behalf of the wife for all her years of labour on the farm.

The Court upheld the trial judge's finding that the wife's labour was not beyond what was normally expected of a ranch wife[2] and that since there was no financial contribution thus based on the English case of Gissing v. Gissing [1971] A.C. 886 there could be no resulting trust.[citation needed]

In dissent, Laskin J. claimed that the Court did not need to examine intent in order to find a trust; rather a constructive trust based in equity could be found.

Laskin's dissent proved to be among his most famous. Many scholars, himself included, believed that his dissent was a major factor in his unexpected promotion to Chief Justice several years later.[citation needed]

Canadian feminists publicized the case across the country. In 1973, Irene Murdoch was paid her claim. It is thought that the case helped bring changes to family law in Canada.[1]

  1. ^ a b Cranny, Michael; Moles, Garvin (2001). Counterpoints: Exploring Canadian Issues. Toronto, Ontario: Pearson Education Canada Inc.. pp. 178. 
  2. ^ "Murdoch v. Murdoch and family property law in Canada". http://section15.ca/features/reviews/2006/07/07/murdoch/. Retrieved 11 March 2011. 

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Murdoch University — Established 1975 Type Public Chancellor Terry Budge Vice Chan …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch Mysteries — Created by based on characters from novels by Maureen Jennings Developed by Cal Coons Alexandra Zarowny …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch Stewart, Duke of Albany — Murdoch Stewart Muireadhach Sdíbhard Duke of Albany, Earl of Menteith and Fife Detail from the seal of Murdoch Stewart Duke of Albany …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch, Western Australia — Murdoch Perth, Western Australia …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch — ist der Familienname folgender Personen: Alexi Murdoch (* 1973), schottischer Singer Songwriter Bob Murdoch (* 1947), kanadischer Eishockeyspieler und trainer Bobby Murdoch (1944–2001), schottischer Fußballspieler Colin Murdoch (1929–2008),… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Murdoch railway station, Perth — Murdoch Station is a railway station located in Murdoch, Western Australia. Situated in the Kwinana Freeway median strip, and perpendicular to South Street interchange, it also features integrated bus services on the concourse level; this level… …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch Cameron — (March 31, 1847 – April 28, 1930) was Regius Professor of Midwifery at the University of Glasgow from 1894 to 1926. He was a pioneer of the Caesarean section under modern antiseptic conditions, becoming world famous after the success of his first …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch Nisbet — (died 1559) was a notary public in the diocese of Glasgow who created one of the earliest Scots translations of the Bible.[1] Living in the parish of Loudoun, Ayrshire, Nisbet s work as a notary public brought him into contact with local… …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch Park 'n' Ride — Southern Area Street …   Wikipedia

  • Murdoch, 2. Herzog von Albany — Murdoch Stewart (* 1362; † 24. Mai 1425 auf Castle Hill, Stirling ), war seit 1420 der 2. Duke of Albany, Earl of Fife und Earl of Menteith. Leben Murdoch war ein Sohn von Robert Stewart, 1. Herzog von Albany und dessen erster Frau Margaret… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”