Godfrey McCulloch

Sir Godfrey McCulloch, 2nd Baronet (c. 1640 - 26 March 1697) (also lived under the alias "Mr. Johnstoune") was a Scottish baronet and politician who was executed for murder. In 1678 he served as a representative in the Convention of Estates (Scottish Parliament). In 1684, he shot William Gordon in the leg, partly as a result of a long-standing feud (rising from a land dispute) between his family and the Gordon family. Gordon later died of the infection caused by the wound. McCulloch was found guilty and sentenced to death. Although he initially escaped to France, he was captured when he returned to Edinburgh in 1697 and beheaded. McCulloch had been living in Scotland since 1694 under the alias "Mr. Johnstoune". He was the last man to be executed on the Maiden. Following his death, much of his family immigrated to America, and Cardoness Castle, which had been owned by the family since c. 1470, was abandoned.

There is also a legend (quoted by Sir Walter Scott, a distant relation) that McCulloch was in fact saved from execution by a gnome whom he had done a favour for earlier in life, and that he was never seen again. Another story tells that after his beheading, his headless body ran 100 yards down the Royal Mile. Given his sensational trial and the number of witnesses present, either story is unlikely at best.