Village files

Village files were documents based on "a card index system, with detailed data on every Arab village in Palestine". Gathered by the SHAI, they were the "basis of Haganah and Palmah operations" during the 1948 Palestine war.Ian Black and Benny Morris, "Israel's Secret Wars: A History of Israel's Intelligence Services", 2004, p.129, ISBN 0802132863]

Origins

The suggestion for these files came from Luria Ben-Zion, an historian from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, who wrote in 1940 to the Jewish National Fund (JNF) that "This would greatly help the redemption of the land". Yossef Weitz, the head of the JNF settlement department immediately suggested that they be turned into a "national project". Yitzhak Ben-Zvi suggested that, apart from topographically recording the layout of the villages, the project should also include exposing the "Hebraic origins" of each village.cite book |author= Ilan Pappé |title=The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine |publisher=Oneworld Publications |location=Oxford, England |year=2006 |pages=17-22 |isbn=1-85168-467-0 |oclc= |doi=]

According to PappéIn the early 1940s topographers, (aerial) photographers and Orientalists worked on the files. Moshe Pasternak, who joined a data collection operation in 1940 said:

:"We had to study the basic structure of the Arab village. This means the structure and how best to attack it. In the military schools, I had been taught how to attack a modern European city, not a primitive village in the Near East. We could not compare it [an Arab village] to a Polish, or an Austrian one. The Arab village, unlike the European ones, was built topographically on hills. That meant we had to find out how best to approach the village from above or enter it from below. We had to train our 'Arabists' [the Orientalists who operated a network of collaborators] how best to work with informants."

According to Gil Eyal, the information was rather gathered between 1945 and 1947 when between 600 and 1000 villages were "surveyed by scouts and informers as well as aerial reconnaissance".

Purposes

According to Pappé later the files were updated and much more details of the inhabitants were added. Towards the end of the Mandatory period more military information was added, like the number of guards and the number and quality of arms in a village, next to the already present information on how best to attack a village. The final update in 1947 focussed on creating lists of ‘wanted’ persons in each village. The main criteria for inclusion were participation in actions against the British and the Zionists, and affiliation with a Palestinian political party or leader. Typically 20 to 30 out of 1500 inhabitants were on the lists.

According to Pappé in the late 1940s these files contained 'precise details […] about the topographic location of each village, its access roads, quality of land, water springs, main sources of income, its sociopolitical composition, religious affiliations, names of its mukhtars, its relationship with other villages, the age of individual men (sixteen to fifty),' an index of hostility based on the level of the village’s participation in the revolt of 1936, and a list of everyone who had been involved in the revolt with particular attention for those who had allegedly killed Jews.

According to Gil EyalGil Eyal, "The Disenchantment of the Orient - Expertise in Arab Affairs and the Israeli", Stanford University Press, 2006, p.85. ISBN 9780804754033.] the 'village files' gathered three types of information :
* They "answered the need of combat intelligence [reporting] the number of men in the village, the number of weapons, the topography and so on";
* Other items had to do with the needs of "hasbara", the research of traces of ancient Jews in the villages;
* "Another interest was buying land from the villagers and settling it".Gil Eyal emphasizes that "the bulk of information in the files reflected the needs and point of view of the emerging Arabist expertise. (...) The Arabists could use this information to interpret the events in the village, but more importantly they could use it to act against the village and use this when needed". He points out it were used after 1948, eg during retaliation operations, but doesn't make any reference to a use during the 1948 Palestine War.

Uses

According to Ilan Pappé, during the 1948 war, after the occupation of a village, if possible, the people on the list were identified, usually by an informer wearing a cloth sack over his head, and often shot on the spot.

Gil Eyal refers to the use of the 'village files' by Israeli military governors after the 1948 War. According to him, they used them in the areas conquered by Israel in order to control the mukhtars and the Arab villagers [Gil Eyal, "The Disenchantment of the Orient - Expertise in Arab Affairs and the Israeli", Stanford University Press, 2006, p.158. ISBN 9780804754033.] .

According to Ian Black and Benny Morris the 'village files' were also used in the 1950s by Aman, Israel's military intelligence service, as the basis of their "intelligence on potential targets in the West Bank and the Gaza strip.". Gil Eyal also refers to this use [Gil Eyal, "The Disenchantment of the Orient - Expertise in Arab Affairs and the Israeli", Stanford University Press, 2006, p.110. ISBN 9780804754033.] .

Controversy

Walid Khalidi used 'village files' as a source for his book : 'All That Remains : The Palestinian Villages Occupied and Depopulated in 1948'. In 'Fabricating Israeli History', Efraim Karsh reports critics made to Walid Khalidi who referred to these sources without having compulsed them directly but through a secondary source 'Village Statistics - 1945' which he considers is "of doubtful reliability". [Efraim Karsh, "Fabricating Israeli History: The New Historians", Routledge, 2000, p.12, ISBN 97807146-50111.] .

ee also

* Intelligence (information gathering)
* Causes of the 1948 Palestinian exodus

References

External links

* Ilan Pappé, [http://71.18.226.238/final/en/journals/printer.php?aid=7175|"The ethnic cleansing of Palestine"] , Journal of Palestine Studies, issue 141, Fall 2006.