Eliza Anderson (sidewheeler)

The steamship "Eliza Anderson" operated from 1858 to 1898 mainly on Puget Sound, the Strait of Georgia, and the Fraser River but also for short periods in Alaska.Newell, Gordon R., ed., "H.W. McCurdy Marine History of the Pacific Northwest", at 14, 15, 40, 130, 265, and 369, Superior Publishing, Seattle, WA 1966] .She was generally known as the "Old Anderson." and was considered slow and underpowered even for the time. Even so, it was said of her that “no steamboat ever went slower and made money faster.” She played a role in the Underground Railroad and had a desperate last voyage to Alaska as part of the Klondike Gold Rush.

Construction

"Eliza Anderson" was launched on November 27, 1858, at Portland, Oregon for the Columbia River Steam Navigation Company. She was a sidewheeler driven by a low pressure boiler generating steam for a single cylinder walking-beam steam engine She was built entirely of wood, measuring 197' long, 25.5 feet on the beam, and rated at 276 tons capacity.Newell, Gordon R., "Ships of the Inland Sea", at 22-27, Binford and Mort, Portland, OR (2nd Ed. 1960)]

Fraser River and Puget Sound service

Allowed to run in Canadian territory

After her trial run on the lower Willamette and Columbia rivers, she was sold to a consortium of John T. Bradford, some Canadian stockholders and three brothers, Tom, John T. and George S. Wright, who were early steamboat operators in the Pacific Northwest. Under Capt. J.G. Hustler [Carey states she was taken across the Columbia Bar by Captain Wells. This may be a conflict in the sources. Carey, "Sound of Steamers", at 55] , she was brought around to Victoria, arriving in March 1859. Because of the Fraser River Gold Rush, there was a shortage of steamboats in British Columbia in 1858-1859. This had a number of effects on the Canadian west coast, perhaps the most important of which was the establishment of British Columbia as a separate colony from Vancouver Island. For the American steamboats, they benefitted by decision of Canadian governor James Douglas to grant “sufferances” to them to allow them to work on the Victoria to Fraser River route at a levy of $12 per run.Hacking, Norman R. and Lamb, W. Kaye, "The Princess Story – A Century and a Half of West Coast Shipping", Mitchell Press, Vancouver, BC 1974]

Initial work on Fraser River

"Eliza Anderson" arrived just at the right time, making her first run to Fort Langley on the Fraser river, just one day after her arrival at Victoria from the Columbia River. From Fort Langley, the sternwheeler "Enterprise", under Capt. Tom Wright (1828-1906), took or at least endeavored to take, goldseekers up to the head of navigation at Yale By March 30, "Eliza Anderson" had completed two round-trip to Fort Langley, and returned to Victoria carrying $40,000 in gold dust.

By May, 1859, three vessels were operating in competition on the Fort Langley route, the "Eliza Anderson", the "Beaver", and the "Governor Douglas". "Enterprise"’s captain, Tom Wright, thought he could do better by moving "Enterprise" down to the Chehalis River. In June, 1859, Captain Wright brought "Enterprise" down to Victoria, and arranged in July to have "Eliza Anderson" tow the sternwheeler around to Grays Harbor, where the Chehalis River flows into the Pacific. Shortly after setting out, "Enterprise" developed mechanical problems and both vessels were forced to turn back to Esquimalt to await the arrival of new parts for the "Enterprise" from San Francisco. Returning to Victoria, "Eliza Anderson" picked up a load of miners bound for Olympia arriving there for the first time on July 9, 1859.

Extension of service into Puget Sound

Once she arrived in Olympia, her owners put her on the Olympia -Victoria mail run during the month of August, 1859. This was arranged by her agent, John H. Scranton, who had the mail contract. Scranton was also the agent for the steamer "Julia", the first sternwheeler to operate on Puget Sound. Scranton seems to have been an interesting character, as he was openly referred to in Olympia's newspaper as “Crazy Jack” and “Commodore Scranton.” [http://www.secstate.wa.gov/history/newspapers.aspx "Pioneer Democrat", Olympia, Washington Terr., July 15, 1859] (available in DjVU format from the Washington Secretary of State historic documents website)]

In September 1859 Scranton arranged to have "Julia" take over from the "Anderson" place on the Olympia-Victoria mail run, which resulted in the "Anderson"’s being returned to the Fraser River route. In mid-September, 1859, a wedding was held on the "Anderson" just off Queenborough, one of the early settlements on the Fraser River, between Carrie A. Gray, from Hope, British Columbia, and Jacob Kamm, a one of the earliest, and later most successful steamboat men. The couple were already sufficiently noteworthy to warrant a 13-gun salute following the ceremony.

At that time "Anderson" was fighting one of her many fare wars, this one with the Canadian steamboat "Otter". Fares were driven down from 50 cents per passenger and 50 cents per ton of freight. The "Otter"’s owners, who had before advertised rates at $10 per passenger and $12 a ton, were forced to pull "Otter" off the Fraser run, at least temporarily. With "Otter" gone, fares shot back up to $6 per passenger and $6 per ton. "Beaver" and "Labouchere" made some runs on this route, but neither did well at carrying passengers.

"Julia", then running the mail, was a shallow-draft riverine vessel not fit to cross the Strait of Juan de Fuca during the winter. On November 1, 1859, she was taken off the Olympia-Victoria mail run, and shortly thereafter she was replaced by the "Anderson", with Capt. Tom Wright (returned from the Chehalis river) as her new master. In December 1859 Captain Wright set the "Anderson"’s schedule at one trip to Olympia and one trip to the Fraser River every week. Every Monday at 7:00 a.m., the "Anderson" left Olympia bound for Victoria. On Tuesday, she left Victoria for New Westminster, on the Fraser River, and returned to Victoria on Wednesday. On Thursday at 3:00 a.m. she’d steam back to Olympia, laying over there to repeat the journey at the start of the next week.

'On the route down Puget Sound, the "Anderson" stopped at Steilacoom, Seattle, Port Townsend and way ports. Fares on this run were $20 a person, freight $5 to $10 a ton, and cattle could be shipped at $15 a head. The "Anderson" also benefited from the $36,000 per year mail contract. [Another source gives the value of the mail contract as $12,000 per year, at least in 1866. Carey, "Sound of Steamers", at 65] The "Anderson" ran on the Victoria run until 1870 when she was replaced by the "Olympia". "Anderson" continued to serve until 1877 as a reserve boat.

Underground Railroad and the Charles Mitchell case

While the events leading up to the Civil War were far away from Puget Sound, they affected the people in the Northwest just the same. The "Anderson" played her role in these events, including the underground railroad. On September 24, 1860, a young black man named Charles Mitchell, aged 14 years, hid on board the "Anderson", seeking passage to Canada to escape slavery. [http://www.theolympian.com/living/story/366865.html Goodnow, Cecelia, "Displays cast Northwest light on Lincoln's time, "Daily Olympian on-line", February 22, 2008] Accessed 2008-02-29] He’d been working on the vessel, and another older black man working on the "Anderson" as a “temporary steward” had helped him find a hiding place on the steamer. He was discovered either at Steilacoom or Seattle, and was not held right away, because he promised to work off his passage. It happened that acting territorial governor McGill and his family were also on the "Anderson". Mitchell confided to McGill’s son that he intended to desert the ship in Victoria, and the son told the father. Governor McGill then told the ships officers, and when they were just four miles out of Victoria, they seized Mitchell and held him in “close confinement” [http://www.secstate.wa.gov/history/newspapers.aspx ”Fugitive Slave Case”, "Pioneer Democrat", Olympia, Washington Terr., September 28, 1860] (available in DjVU format from the Washington Secretary of State historic documents website)]

Once in Victoria, word got out that Mitchell was being held against his will aboard the "Anderson". A group of protesters composed of both white and black citizens of Victoria marched down to the dock. A lawyer presented a petition for a writ of habeas corpus to Chief Justice Cameron, who granted the writ. Armed with the writ, sheriff Naylor and a police constable boarded the "Anderson", presented the writ to the officer in charge, and demanded that Mitchell be released to them. The officer in charge told them he didn’t think he could do anything until Captain Fleming returned to the vessel. When Captain Fleming returned, he in turn deferred to Governor McGill. What happened next is not entirely clear, but McGill went ashore and either acquiesced in the assertion of the Canadian court’s writ over the vessel, or, as the "Pioneer Democrat" later insisted, protested vociferously against it. Either way, Mitchell was removed from the vessel by the Canadian authorities and became a free man. This was none to the liking of Olympia’s newspaper at the time, the "Pioneer Democrat", which in an article quite free with racially derogatory terms, stated that war would have been justified to prevent Mitchell’s release:

Mitchell had been born in Maryland (a slave state) the son of a white man named Mitchell and an enslaved woman. His mother died and he came to be enslaved by James Tilton, who later was appointed as the territorial surveyor of the Washington Territory. Although in theory the Washington Territory was free soil, the Territorial legislature had declared that after the Dred Scott Decision, the federal government could not bar slavery in the territory. Curiously, although the "Pioneer Democrat" denounced the action of the Canadian court, blaming the situation on “sharp dressed” black people and misguided whites, the "Pioneer Democrat" also denied that he was a slave, claiming that he was some type of ward, even though the title of their article used the words “fugitive slave” and the protest by Captain Fleming that it printed described Mitchell as Tilton’s “property.”

Operations on the mail route

News of Lincoln’s election

In the early 1860s, there was no telegraph in Puget Sound, and mail carried by steamboat was the fastest way of transmitting news. Thus, on November 27, 1860, the "Anderson" brought to Port Townsend news that Abraham Lincoln had been elected president of the United States on November 4, 1860, even though the news had reached Olympia on November 22. [ [http://www.historylink.org/essays/output.cfm?file_id=901 Lange, Greg, “News of Abraham Lincoln's November 6 election reaches Olympia on November 22, 1860", HistoryLink.org, Feb 22, 1999] Accessed 2008-02-28]

Fare wars continue

The "Anderson"’s next challenge on the Olympia-Victoria route came from "Enterprise", a sidewheeler under the command of Captain Jones. "Enterprise" had been built in California in 1861, intended for the San Francisco - Stockton run. Her owners brought her north to compete with the "Eliza Anderson". The Wrights bested them, by lowering the fare to Victoria to fifty cents, with free meals. This drove "Enterprise" off the run after six months, and in February 1862, Captain W.A. Mowat paid $60,000 to buy her for the Hudson’s Bay Company. The Anderson’s owners bought the Enterprise’s walking-beam engine and used it to repower their boat. Another would-be competitor, the "Josie McNear", similarly faltered in her efforts to compete with the "Anderson".

Floating financial agency

D.B. Finch, once the purser on the vanquished "Enterprise", shifted over to the "Anderson", and later became a part-owner and master. Captain Finch had a head for figures, and became one of leading bankers in the Washington Territory, conducting finance at every landing called at by the Anderson. Counties in those days were poorly funded, and paid their bills not in cash money, but “warrants”, that is to say, paper promises to pay. Finch bought these up for 20 cents on the dollar (he paid more for better quality debts) and eventually collected most of the principal and interest from them

Cassiar Gold Rush

When things were winding down for the Anderson on the Olympia-Victoria route, she was tied up to Percival Dock in Olympia for some time, until the Cassiar Gold Rush in northern British Columbia seemed to offer a chance to make money. She was then was fixed up sufficiently to make voyages as far north as Wrangell, Alaska. When the Cassiar rush gave out, the "Anderson" was returned to Seattle, where she lay between 1877 and 1883, eventually sinking at her moorings.

Return to service 1883 to early 1890s

In 1883, Captain Wright raised the "Anderson", pumped her out, cleaned her up a bit, and put her on the run from Seattle to New Westminster, British Columbia, with Captain E.W. Holmes as her master and O.O. Denny her chief engineer. By this time, the Oregon Railway and Navigation Company was making its bid to monopolize all water and rail transport in the state of Oregon and the Washington Territory. This brought on a rate war with the monopoly’s newer sidewheeler, "George E. Starr", under Captain George Roberts. In April 1884, "Anderson" was run hard on the Victoria run against the Oregon company’s "Olympian", a huge and expensive-to-run sidewheeler.

"Anderson" ran fares down to $1.00 and was beating both "Olympian" and "Geo. E. Starr" until she was seized by the customs collector, Captain H.F. Beecher (youngest child of the famous abolitionist minister Henry Ward Beecher) on charges of bringing in immigrants contrary to the Chinese Exclusion Act. Eventually Captain Wright was able to clear himself of these charges, but with the "Anderson" having been off the route so long, the competitors had captured all the business. It was said that this broke Captain Wright’s heart and his finances. In October, 1886, Captain Wright sold "Anderson" to the Puget Sound and Alaska Steamship Company, which ran her hard under Capt. J.W. Tarte on the Victoria route again. As late as 1888 she engaged in a steamboat race with another old vessel, the sidewheel steam tug "Goliah"."Eliza Anderson" last ran on Puget Sound under the Northwestern Steamship Company, which was managed by Capt. D.B. Jackson.

"Floating Coffins" to Alaska

The "Anderson" had been acquired by Daniel Bachhelder Jackson (1833-1895) who was organizing the Washington Steamboat Company. [http://books.google.com/books?id=nbupvBGRpwEC&pg=PA762&lpg=PA762&dq=%22eliza+anderson%22+steamship&source=web&ots=uL5sXKc3A4&sig=4v0SLEnmcFFRvUU6wXNKBOil71Y&hl=en Bagley, Clarence, B., "History of Seattle from the Earliest Settlement to the Present Time" (Vol. II), at 762-63, S.J. Clarke Publishing, Chicago IL 1916] ] Starting in about 1890, "Eliza Anderson" was laid up on the Duwamish River [One source says she was laid up on the Snohomish River, see Lewis & Dryden at 77] during the financial crises of the early 1890s, and would have rotted away there except for the discovery of gold in the Yukon Territory. Gold seekers were willing to book passage on just about anything that floated, and the owners of various dubious craft seized their chance. By this time, "Anderson" had been tied up for quite some time, and had been functioning not as a steamboat but a roadhouse and gambling hall.Berton, Pierre, "Klondike Fever – The Life and Death of the Last Great Gold Rush", at 141-145, Carroll & Graf Publishers, New York, NY (1958) ISBN 0-7867-1317-8]

The expedition is organized

A flotilla of dubious vessels, since described as “floating coffins,” was organized, consisting of "Eliza Anderson" traveling in company with the old (built 1877) steam tug "Richard Holyoke" towing, astoundingly, three craft behind her, the sternwheeler "W.K. Merwin", the hulk of the old sidewheeler "Politkosky" (once a Russian gunboat, now a coal barge), and "William J. Bryant", a yachting schooner owned by a wealthy playboy named John Hansen.. "Merwin", built in 1883 had been laid up from 1894 to 1896 with the "Eliza". The Moran shipyard in Seattle finished quick overhaul on the "Anderson" and she was back in the water on July 31, 1897, and she was somehow able to meet the approval of hulls and boilers inspectors Bryant and Cherry. [http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=9C0DE4DD1330E333A25752C1A96F9C94669ED7CF&oref=slogin “Steamer Reported Lost – Believed that the Eliza Anderson has gone down with a party of gold hunters”, "New York Times", September 11, 1897 (dateline: Seattle, WA 9-10-1897] Accessed: 2008-02-28]

The voyage begins

On August 10, 1897, she began her voyage to Alaska under Capt. Thomas Powers, with about 40 passengers, including a few women and children. The plan was to take the entire fleet up to St. Michael, the only port anywhere near the mouth of the Yukon River, abandon the "Anderson" there, and then take the "Merwin" up the Yukon to the gold fields. "Merwin" herself had her funnel and paddlewheel unshipped for transit and the boat been completely boarded up for the sea voyage. Even so the company still managed to find 16 people willing to book passage on "Merwin". Many considered the ship inspectors’ assessment of the "Anderson" as overly optimistic:

Overloaded and underequipped

The trip north was from the start a near fiasco. "Anderson"’s owners had oversold her tickets, and the passengers, finding much less space aboard then they’d been promised, were only prevented from throwing the purser overboard by the personal intervention of Captain Powers. Shortly after departure, it was found she was missing a large variety of basic sea-going equipment, such as a compass. Fights broke out among the passengers and crew. When the "Eliza Anderson" arrived at Connox, British Columbia, incompetent coal loading by her crew caused the steamer to veer out of control into the ship "Glory of the Seas" sustaining minor damage to one of her paddle guards.

Finally the fleet reached Kodiak Alaska, still a very long sea journey from St. Michael. There, as the "Anderson" took on coal, five passengers got off and refused to reboard, convinced the "Anderson" would sink on the way. The little fleet ran into a gale near Kodiak Island and the "Merwin"’s tow line parted. "Merwin", and the 16 unlucky souls aboard her, were only recovered with difficulty by the "Holyoke". "Holyoke", "Merwin" and "Bryant" became separated from the "Anderson", and when they arrived at Dutch Harbor, they reported her missing. The revenue cutter "Corwin" went out to look for the missing sidewheeler.

Running out of coal in middle of storm

The "Anderson" it turned out had run out of coal in the middle of the storm. Her lazy crew had not fully coaled the ship at Kodiak and had simply hidden the sacks that they were supposed to haul on board and heave into the coal bins. The crew and passengers were forced to burn the wooden coal bunkers, and eventually the cabin furniture and even the cabin partitions. Passengers were writing notes to loved ones and tossing them overboard in bottles, of which there was an ample supply since most of the boat’s stock of whisky had been consumed in an effort to keep up morale.

”Ghost helmsman” takes the wheel

Just as Captain Powers had given the order to abandon ship (which would have been difficult to execute as the lifeboats had been swept away), the tale goes that a tall ghostly white-haired bearded figure clad in foul weather gear entered the pilot house, took the wheel and steered the ship to safety. Some of the more superstitious said the spectre was the ghost of Captain Tom Wright. The Seattle Post-Intelligencer printed the story as coming from “an old sailor”:It would require an exceptional level of credulity to believe this tale, as Capt. Tom Wright, whose “ghost” supposedly appeared on the "Anderson" in 1897, was still very much alive and did not die until 1906. Still the story made the rounds among the superstitious and stuck around for a long time.

afety reached on Kodiak Island

Ghost helmsman or not, the ship was forced to run for shelter on Kodiak Island. Fortuitously, she found an unused cannery on the island, complete with 75 tons of coal. (Here is where the “Ghost Helmsman” mysteriously vanished.) This supply was quickly seized upon by the "Anderson"’s company, and with it the boat was somehow able to stagger on to Dutch Harbor.

Abandonment and final loss

At Dutch Harbor, following a steam pipe explosion and collision with a dock, the "Anderson" was abandoned by her passengers, who shifted over to a steam schooner to reach the mouth of the Yukon River. "Anderson" stayed moored at Dutch Harbor until March 1898 when a storm washed her up on a beach where she gradually disintegrated. Of her fate, the Seattle Post-Intelligencer wrote, on March 31, 1898:

Mystery of the Ghost Helmsman solved

In 1956, Thomas Wiedeman, Sr., who had been on board the "Anderson" during her last Alaska trip, wrote in an article that in 1953, he’d been introduced to Joe Braddock of San Francisco, who had been a crewman on the "Corwin" when the revenue cutter had set out in 1897 to search for the missing "Anderson". Braddock told Wiedeman that in the course of the search, he’d questioned two brothers, Erik and Olaf Heestad on Kodiak Island. They’d been operating the cannery near the "Anderson" had sought safety. When "Anderson" left Kodiak after coaling, Erik had stowed himself away on board, hoping to get to Dutch Harbor to ask an uncle for a loan to restart their business. Afraid of discovery and arrest, he hid until the "Anderson" was in such terrible straits that it appeared only he could save the ship. Once they reached safety, his brother Olaf rowed out from shore and took him off the ship. They remained at their out-of-the-way cabin until the "Anderson" finally coaled and left for Dutch Harbor.

External links

University of Washington on-line image collections

* [http://content.lib.washington.edu/cdm4/item_viewer.php?CISOROOT=/transportation&CISOPTR=321&CISOBOX=1&REC=11 "Eliza Anderson", probably in Alaska in 1897] The "Anderson" appears to be operational in this photograph. There is a tarpulin rigged over the walking beam engine, consistent with efforts to protect operational machinery, and several people are visible on deck. A make-shift dock has been built out to the vessel. This photograph also shows one of the weak points of sidewheelers, which is that they needed improved landings or docks, and could not simply close up to a beach as s sternwheeler could.
* [http://content.lib.washington.edu/cdm4/item_viewer.php?CISOROOT=/transportation&CISOPTR=377&CISOBOX=1&REC=17 "Eliza Anderson" at a pier, possibly in Seattle] This photograph shows well the auxiliary sail rig of the "Anderson". There appear to be furled sails on the forestay and foremast. The image also shows the later version of "Anderson" when her passenger deck had been extended all the way to her bow.

Oregon universities multi-site test collection

* [http://fluffy.library.oregonstate.edu/contentdm/search/itemviewer.php?id=WAUUcurtis1860&cparam= "Eliza Anderson" at Yesler Wharf in Seattle] This is a good clear photograph showing details of the ship from the starboard bow. Extra flags are flying as well as the national colors from the stern, indicating that possibly an excursion cruise was pending.

Notes