Fallacy of misplaced concreteness
- Fallacy of misplaced concreteness
In the philosophy of Alfred North Whitehead, one commits the fallacy of misplaced concreteness when one mistakes an abstract belief, opinion or concept about the way things are for a physical or 'concrete' reality.
Whitehead proposed the fallacy in a discussion of the relation of spatial and temporal location of objects. Whitehead rejects the notion that a concrete physical object in the universe can be described simply in spatial or temporal extension. Rather, the object must be described as a field located in both space and time.
:"...among the primary elements of nature as apprehended in our immediate experience, there is no element whatever which possesses this character of simple location. ... [Instead,] I hold that by a process of constructive abstraction we can arrive at abstractions which are the simply located bits of material, and at other abstractions which are the minds included in the scientific scheme. Accordingly, the real error is an example of what I have termed: The Fallacy of Misplaced Concreteness." Whitehead (1997), p. 58.
:" [The Fallacy] is merely the accidental error of mistaking the abstract for the concrete... This fallacy is the occasion of great confusion in philosophy." Whitehead (1997), p. 52.
Also Whitehead (1925), Part III.
The Victorian fantasy "Flatland" makes an analogous point; just as humans cannot perceive of a line that has width but no breadth, they also cannot perceive an object that has spatial but not temporal position (or vice versa).
References
*Alfred North Whitehead 1925 (1919). "An Enquiry concerning the Principles of Natural Knowledge" 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press.
*--------, 1997 (1925). "Science and the Modern World". Free Press (Simon & Schuster). ISBN 0-684-83639-4
External links
*Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:
**" [http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/whitehead/ Alfred North Whitehead] " -- by A.D. Irvine.
**" [http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/femapproach-prag-cont/ Intersections Between Pragmatist and Continental Feminism] " -- by Shannon Sullivan. Section 3 defines the fallacy and shows how it can contribute to a critical understanding of technology and gender.
Wikimedia Foundation.
2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
fallacy of misplaced concreteness — See reification … Dictionary of sociology
Fallacy — In logic and rhetoric, a fallacy is usually incorrect argumentation in reasoning resulting in a misconception or presumption. By accident or design, fallacies may exploit emotional triggers in the listener or interlocutor (appeal to emotion), or… … Wikipedia
Reification (fallacy) — Contents 1 Etymology 2 Theory 3 Difference between reification and hypostatisation … Wikipedia
Prozess und Realität — Der Essay Prozess und Realität ist ein zuerst 1929 in New York unter dem Originaltitel Process and Reality: An Essay in Cosmology erschienenes Werk des britischen Philosophen und Mathematikers Alfred North Whitehead (1861–1947). Es ist… … Deutsch Wikipedia
List of philosophy topics (D-H) — DDaDai Zhen Pierre d Ailly Jean Le Rond d Alembert John Damascene Damascius John of Damascus Peter Damian Danish philosophy Dante Alighieri Arthur Danto Arthur C. Danto Arthur Coleman Danto dao Daodejing Daoism Daoist philosophy Charles Darwin… … Wikipedia
Borden Parker Bowne — Borden Parker Bowen was born on 14 January, 1847, near Leonardville, NJ, and died in Boston on 1 April, 1910. He was one of six children of upright parents raised in rural New Jersey, near what is today called Atlantic Highlands. Notably, the… … Wikipedia
Alfred N. Whitehead — Alfred North Whitehead Alfred North Whitehead OM (* 15. Februar 1861 in Ramsgate; † 30. Dezember 1947 in Cambridge (Massachusetts)) war ein britischer Philosoph und Mathematiker. Bekannt wurde Alfred Whitehead durch das Sta … Deutsch Wikipedia
Alfred North Whitehead — OM (* 15. Februar 1861 in Ramsgate; † 30. Dezember 1947 in Cambridge (Massachusetts)) war ein britischer Philosoph und Mathematiker. Bekannt wurde Alfred Whitehead durch das Standardwerk „Principia Mathematica“ über Logik, das er zusammen mit… … Deutsch Wikipedia
Alfred Whitehead — Alfred North Whitehead Alfred North Whitehead OM (* 15. Februar 1861 in Ramsgate; † 30. Dezember 1947 in Cambridge (Massachusetts)) war ein britischer Philosoph und Mathematiker. Bekannt wurde Alfred Whitehead durch das Sta … Deutsch Wikipedia
Alfred North Whitehead — Infobox Philosopher region = Western Philosophy era = 19th century philosophy 20th century philosophy color = #B0C4DE image caption = name = Alfred North Whitehead birth = birth date|1861|2|15 death = death date and age|1947|12|30|1861|2|15… … Wikipedia
