Guthrum II

Guthrum II was, according to some reconstructions, a King of East Anglia in the early tenth century.

Background

The only Viking ruler of the former Anglo-Saxon kingdom in East Anglia whose existence is beyond doubt is Guthrum, whose activities are recorded in Asser's life of King Alfred the Great of Wessex. Guthrum, who took the baptismal name Æthelstan, died in 890 after ruling East Anglia for around ten years. [Keynes, Rulers, 509; Keynes & Lapidge, "Life", pp. ?; John, "Reassessing", 75-6; Davis, "Alfred the Great to Stephen", pp. ?; ASC.]

Until the death of Guthrum, the coins of East Anglia provide an essential guide to the rulers of the kingdom. After the killing of King Æthelberht II of East Anglia in 794, only two kings—Edmund, better known as Saint Edmund the Martyr, and Guthrum—are named in near-contemporary written records, while all others are known only from the numismatic evidence provided by surviving coins. [Keynes, Rulers.] This evidence comes to an end at Guthrum's death as late East Anglian coins cease to name the king on whose orders they were minted and instead bear the name of King Edmund. [Ridyard, "Royal Saints", 214ff; Lyon, "Coinage of Edward the Elder".] From this time forward, kings are only known from the very limited written record.

It is believed that Eohric was king of East Anglia. The beginning of his reign cannot be dated. He was killed in 902 at the battle of the Holme alongside Æthelwold of Wessex, fighting against the armies of Æthelwold's cousin King Edward the Elder. The East Anglians are recorded by the "Anglo-Saxon Chronicle" as signing a peace with Edward in 906 and submitting to Edward late in 917, but on neither occasion are their leaders named by the "Chronicle". [Keynes; ASC; ...]

The Laws of Edward and Guthrum

In his translation of Johann Martin Lappenberg's "History of England under the Anglo-Saxon Kings", Benjamin Thorpe refers to King Guthrum II as having led the East Anglians in 906 when peace was made with Edward the Elder. [Lappenberg, 87.] Thorpe bases this upon one of his own earlier works, "Ancient Laws and Institutes of England" (1840). Here he printed the "Laws of Edward and Guthrum", which he presumed to be a record of the agreement in 906. He referred to the medieval historian John of Wallingford as supporting this identification, stating that Wallingford referred to a second Guthrum being active in Edward's reign. [Thorpe, "Ancient Laws", I:71, note a.] Joseph Stevenson translated Wallingford some years after Thorpe wrote, and his edition disagrees with Thorpe's reading. According to Stevenson, Wallingford's translation, wrote that the King Guthrum who had made peace with Alfred, and whose death in 890 is not disputed, had left England for Denmark and returned again in the reign of Edward's son Æthelstan. [Stevenson, pp. 535 & 545. A man named Guthrum, styled a "dux"—usually translated as ealdorman in this period—was active in the reign of Æthelstan and witnessed eleven charters in the period between 928 and 935; PASE Guthrum 2.]

In time the idea that the "Laws of Edward and Guthrum" should be dated to the reign of Edward the Elder came under scrutiny. Frederick Attenborough's "Laws of the Earliest English Kings" (1921) discussed them and referred to the work of German historian Felix Liebermann. Liebermann considered the preamble to the laws to be inauthentic and dated them to the reign of King Æthelstan. [Attenborough, p. 97.] Modern studies date them to later yet. The late Patrick Wormald wrote: "From 1568 to 1941, no one seems to have doubted that [the Laws of Edward and Guthrum] was just what it claimed to be." But, Wormald notes, since 1941, when Dorothy Whitelock published a study of the text, this is no longer the case. Rather than being seen as a contemporary record of the peace of 906, or a document from the time of Æthelstan, the "Laws" are now dated to around 1000. It is believed that they were written by Wulfstan II, Archbishop of York (died 1023). [Wormald, "Making of English Law", I:389-390; Whitelock et al, EHD, I:364; ...]

Notes

References

* Abrams, "Edward the Elder's Danelaw" in Higham & Hill
* Attenborough, "Laws of the Earliest English Kings" (rp)
* Campbell, "What is not known" in Higham & Hill
* Davis, "From Alfred the Great to Stephen"
* John, "Reassessing Anglo-Saxon England"
* Keynes, "Rulers" in Lapidge et al
* Keynes & Lapidge, "Alfred the Great"
* Lappenberg
* Lyon, "Coinage of Edward the Elder" in Higham & Hill
* PASE, Guthrum (2)
* Ridyard, "Royal Saints"
* Swanton, "ASC"
* Thorpe, "Ancient Laws" (rp)
* Wallingford, John of, in Stevenson, "Church Historians", v 2 pt 2
* Whitelock et al, "EHD"
* Wormald, "Making of English Law"