Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz

The Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz or Girls' Orchestra of Auschwitz was a female orchestra at Auschwitz concentration camp created in June 1943 by a Polish music teacher, Mrs. Zofia Czajkowska, by order of the SS. The members were prisoner girls, whose membership in the orchestra protected them from being gassed in the gas chamber and from being worked to death. Czajkowska was eventually replaced as conductor by Alma Rosé, the daughter of Gustav Mahler's sister Justine and of Arnold Rosé. Rosé had been the conductor of a women's orchestra in her hometown of Vienna. The orchestra played at the gate when the work gangs went out, and when they returned. During the final stages of the Holocaust, when the mass deportations of Jews from Eastern Europe occurred and large numbers of Jews were sent directly to the gas chambers, the orchestra played in order to put the minds of the victims at ease. The music preserved the illusion that the Jews were being transported "to the East", and allowed the SS to kill more efficiently. Fania Fénelon denies, in her book, the claim that the orchestra had to play certain specific selections, and calls this a myth. However, she records concerts for the SS, and reported that Maria Mandel was particularly fond of her rendition of Madame Butterfly.

The history of the orchestra has been told in memoirs, documentaries and one docudrama. The best known documentation is Fania Fénelon's vivid novel-memoir, "Playing for Time" (an English translation of "Sursis pour l'orchestre"). Though there is no doubting Fénelon's skill as a writer and her unsparing analysis of the concentration camp experience, many of the surviving members of the orchestra took issue with her portrayal of Alma Rosé, who appeared in Fénelon's memoir as a cruel disciplinarian and self-hating Jew who admired the Nazis and courted their favor. A recent biography of Rosé, "Alma Rosé: From Vienna to Auschwitz," by Rosé family friend Richard Newman and Karen Kirtley, strives to present a different picture of the orchestra leader. It corrects several errors in Fénelon's account (Rosé was Austrian, not German) and subtler biases: Fénelon, for instance, was never the leader of the orchestra. As a Parisian of socialist sympathies, divorced, active in the Resistance, and formerly a student of Germaine Martinelli, she was considerably more experienced and sophisticated than most of the teenaged girls in the orchestra, to whose immaturity she condescended; but there was never any doubt that Rosé was their leader. Nor, according to Newman and Kirtley, did Fénelon's and the other Jewish women's mistrust of the Christian Poles in the orchestra entirely reflect the truth: not all the Poles were anti-Semitic. But most significantly, Rosé emerges in her biography as a heroine who saved the lives of nearly all the women in her care by forcing them to work their hardest even if they were marginally talented, though her dramatic temperament and her egotism do not go unremarked.

Other potential sources of controversy were represented by Fénelon's novelistic rendering of her experience, with reconstructed conversations and thinly veiled name changes (Violette Jacquet became "Florette," Hélène Scheps and Hélène Rounder both became "Irene," Anita Lasker-Wallfisch was "Marta," and Fanny Birkenwald was "Anny"), and her frank treatment of both prostitution and lesbianism in the camps, with several alleged lesbian liaisons between orchestra members (toward which Fénelon was compassionate). Both the English and the German translations of her memoir were slightly abridged in respect to this last matter.

Rosé died in 1944 of unknown causes; poisoning was suspected by Fénelon and others, but according to Newman and Kirtley the cause was likely to be either botulism or typhus. After Rosé the orchestra was conducted haphazardly by Sonia Vinogradovna, a Russian prisoner, but in January 1945 Auschwitz was dismantled by the Nazis and the orchestra was sent to Bergen-Belsen. Two members, Lola Kroner and Julie Stroumsa, died there. The rest survived, though Ewa Stojowska was badly beaten and Fania Fénelon nearly died of typhus. Fénelon wrote that the orchestra was scheduled to be shot to death on the same day as the liberation by British troops. She was interviewed by the BBC on the day of liberation and performed "La Marseillaise" and "God Save the King."

Members of the orchestra

*Alma Rosé, conductor and violinist, Jewish, Austrian
*Zofia Czajkowska, conductor, Polish
*Esther Bejarano, accordion, Jewish, German; still plays today with the group "Coincidence" — they play songs from the Ghetto, Jewish and anti-fascist songs
*Fania Fénelon, piano and voice, Jewish, French
*Ewa Stojowska, piano and voice, Polish
*Helena Dunicz Niwinska, Polish
*Zofia Cykowiak, violin and copyist, Polish
*Anita Lasker-Wallfisch, violoncello, Jewish, German
*Hélène Scheps, violin, Jewish, Belgian
*Violette Jacquet, violin, Jewish, French, born in Romania; became a pop singer after the war
*Flora Schrijver, accordion, Jewish, Dutch
*Julie Stroumsa, violin, Jewish, Greek
*Fanny Birkenwald, mandolin, Jewish, Belgian
*Hélène Rounder, violin and copyist, Jewish, French
*Lily Máthé, violin, Jewish, Hungarian
*Eva Steiner, voice, Jewish, Hungarian
*Lola Kroner, flute, Jewish, German
*Else Felstein, violin, Jewish, Belgian
*Sonia Vinogradovna, piano, Russian
*Margot Anzenbacher (Wtrovcova), Jewish, Czech
*Lotte Lebeda, Jewish, Czech, voice
*Rachela Zelmanowicz (Olewski), Mandolin, Jewish, Poland
*Masza Pietrkowska, Mandolin, Jewish, Poland
*Hilde Grunbaum (Simha), Notes copier, Jewish, German
*Rivka Kuperberg (Bacia), Jewish, Polish
*Helen Spitzer Tichauer, mandolin, Jewish, Czech
*Ruth Bassin, piccolo, Jewish, German
*Sylvia Wagenberg, recorder, Jewish, German
*Karla Wagenberg, recorder and piccolo, Jewish, German
*Yvette Maria Assael (Lennon), accordion, piano, double bass, Jewish, Greek
*Lily Assael, Jewish, Greek

As of 2005, Esther Bejarano, Violette Jacquet, Hilde Simha, Rivka Bacia, Masza Pietrkowska, Yvette Maria Assael-Lennon and Anita Lasker-Wallfisch are known to be among the last living survivors of the girl orchestra.

Literature

*"Playing for Time":Authors: "'Fania Fénelon Marcelle Routier:ISBN 3-423-13291-4

*"Wir leben trotzdem [We live nevertheless] " :Authors: Esther Bejarano Birgit Gardner:ISBN 3-89144-353-6

*"Man nannte mich Krümmel":Author: "'Esther Bejarano

*"Alma Rosé, Vienna 1906-Auschwitz 1944 ":Authors: Richard Newman Karen Kirtley

*"Inherit the truth":Author: Anita Lasker-Wallfisch:ISBN 3-499-22670-7

*"Das Mädchenorchester von Auschwitz":Author: Gabriele Knapp

*"Asszonysors":Author: Lilla Máthé

*"Les sanglots longs des violons de la mort : Avoir dix-huit ans à Auschwitz":Author: Violette Jacquet:ISBN 2-35000-044-3

*"Tu choisiras la vie":Author: Jacques Stroumsa (mentions Julie Stroumsa):ISBN 2-204-05914-5

*"Het meisje met de accordeon : de overleving van Flora Schrijver in Auschwitz-Birkenau en Bergen-Belsen":Author: Mirjam Verheijen

Media

*Esther Bejarano :51'34 minutes in the discussion with Silke Behl. 22 January 2002 :Northwest Radio _{See Links 1}

* Radio play "The Wooden Shoes" :Transmission cut from 24 January 2002 _{See Links 2}

*Stage play "Playing For Time" available from Dramatic Publishing, written by Arthur Miller

Films

*"Esther Bejarano and the girl orchestra of Auschwitz" Christel Priemer 1992
*"Bach in Auschwitz" Michel Daeron (2000)
*"Playing for Time", Linda Yellen 1980, TV-movie based on Arthur Miller's stage adaptation; the source of much controversy for its choice of Vanessa Redgrave, a PLO sympathizer, to play Fania Fénelon; Fénelon opposed the not-very-Jewish-looking Redgrave on the grounds that she was miscast as well as being anti-Israeli. Fénelon also was critical of the film's accuracy, citing an unrealistic degree of freedom among the prisoners. Anita Lasker-Wallfisch supported Redgrave. Alma Rosé was played by Jane Alexander in a widely praised performance. The film is notable for a positive portrayal of a romantic relationship between two prisoners (played by Lenore Harris and Mady Kaplan), well ahead of its time.

External links

* [http://www.arlindo-correia.com/141203.html Numerous witness reports]
* [http://www.podium-wendel.de/Interpreten/Rose__Alma/rose__alma.html Alma Rosé]
* [http://stream.radiobremen.de/ramgen/media/rbton/nordwestradio/hoerspiel/bejarano_gespraech.rm Northwest Radio]
* [http://www.radio-bremen.de/nordwestradio/hoerspiel/wooden_shoes/index.html Radio Bremen]