Selig v. United States

Selig v. United States

"Selig v. United States", 740 F.2d 572 (1984) [Federal Income Taxation of Individuals: Cases, Problems, & Materials. 2nd Edition. by Samuel A. Donaldson, p.278-83] , is a case decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit related to the amortization of intangible property.

Conceptually, amortization is a mechanism that allows taxpayers to recover the cost of property over the life of an asset when they are precluded from taking an immediate and full deduction. Practically, this means that taxpayers may recover the cost in small amounts over time. There are two forms of such recovery: depreciation and amortization. "Selig" deals with amortization. The general rule for amortization is set forth in Section 197 [ [ TaxAlmanac - Internal Revenue Code:Sec. 197. Amortization of goodwill and certain other intangibles ] ] of the Internal Revenue Code. The "Selig" case demonstrates some of the practical problems in cost allocation prior to the enactment of Section 197.

Facts of case

Bud Selig was part of an effort to bring a new baseball franchise to Wisconsin. As part-owner of the Milwaukee Brewers, Selig negotiated to purchase an American League team that was in financial difficulty, the Seattle Pilots. The deal was contingent upon the team moving from Seattle to Milwaukee and payment of the purchase price, $10.8 million. The contract allocated the $10.8 million dollars to equipment and supplies, league membership, and player contracts (representing $10.2 million of the $10.8 million). The Brewers' financial officer decided to retain the $10.2 million allocation. Selig then amortized that cost over the players' five-year useful lives under Section 167(a) of the Internal Revenue Code. The IRS disallowed the entire $10.2 million allocation, arguing that the players' contracts had zero value. Selig paid the deficiency amount assessed by the IRS, but subsequently filed a law suit.


The key issue in this case was whether there was proper allocation of the purchase price to the franchise and the cost of the player contracts.

Procedural history

The district court held that Selig properly allocated $10.2 million of the $10.8 million purchase price of the Seattle Pilots to the value of the 149 players that he bought.
On appeal, the government argued that the $10.2 million allocation was "contrary to common sense." [Federal Income Taxation of Individuals: Cases, Problems, & Materials. 2nd Edition. by Samuel A. Donaldson, p.282] The government focused on the specific value of the allocation (i.e. $10.2 million) by attempting to prove that the players were not "worth" $10.2 million.


The players' contracts were properly valued as a whole (rather than combining individual contract values), and the franchise was not worth more than the purchase price.


At the time of the sale, Milwaukee was not a commercially successful baseball climate. As such, a baseball franchise in Milwaukee was not as valuable as franchises located elsewhere. For this reason, the court determined that the Pilots' franchise was not worth more than Selig claimed. Rather, the key inquiry was the value attributed to the players.
The purchase price of the club itself required allocating that price among all of the club's assets (e.g., equipment, players, league fees), not simply assigning a dollar value to each player (as in the free agent market). This transaction was essentially the bulk purchase of all of the Pilots' players in an arms-length transaction with no restrictions. Because this sort of bulk sale was the reality of the "club" market, the players should be valued in accordance with the market's nature.

After the case

Congress enacted Section 197 of the Internal Revenue Code to clarify disputes and provide rules for amortization (i.e. cost recovery for intangible assets).


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • United States non-interventionism — United States This article is part of the series: Politics and government of the United States …   Wikipedia

  • United States national baseball team — Infobox National baseball team Name = United States National Baseball team Country = flag|United States of America Federation = USA Baseball Confederation = COPABE Manager = Olympic apps = 3 Olympic first = 1992 Olympic best = 1 WBC apps = 1 WBC… …   Wikipedia

  • Seal of the President of the United States — Details Armiger President of the Un …   Wikipedia

  • Major professional sports leagues in the United States and Canada — Major Leagues redirects here. For other meanings of Major League or Major Leagues see Major League (disambiguation). The major professional sports leagues, or simply major leagues, in the United States and Canada are the highest professional… …   Wikipedia

  • Agreed Framework between the United States of America and the Democratic People's Republic of Korea — The Agreed Framework between the United States of America and the Democratic People s Republic of Korea was signed on October 21, 1994 between North Korea (DPRK) and the United States. The objective of the agreement was the freezing and… …   Wikipedia

  • History of baseball in the United States — National League Baltimore Orioles, 1896 Part of the Baseball series on …   Wikipedia

  • Pakistan–United States relations — Pakistan United States relations Pakistan …   Wikipedia

  • List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 234 — This is a list of all the United States Supreme Court cases from volume 234 of the United States Reports :* Tap Line Cases , ussc|234|1|1914 * United States v. Butler County R. Co. , ussc|234|29|1914 * United States v. Axman , ussc|234|36|1914 *… …   Wikipedia

  • Selig Perlman — (December 9 1888 August 14 1959) was an economist and labor historian at the University of Wisconsin Madison.Early life and educationPerlman was born in Białystok in Congress Poland (then part of Russia) in 1888. His father, Mordecai, was a… …   Wikipedia

  • Selig Starr — Rabbi Selig Starr born Zelig Starobinski (b. 15 June 1893 Yanow or Yanaveh, Poland, d. 2 November 1989) was a 20th century talmudic scholar in Poland, Chicago and Jerusalem. As the instructor of the highest level shiur at Skokie, Illinois s… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”