Investigations and prosecutions relating to the Mountain Meadows massacre

The pursuit of the perpetrators of the Mountain Meadows massacre, which atrocity occurred September 11, 1857, had to await the conclusion of the American Civil War to begin in earnest.

While taking into account evidence Brigham Young did not order the murders and lack of direct evidence Young condoned of it, historians still question the roles of local Cedar City Mormon church officials in ordering the massacre and Young's concealing of evidence in its aftermath. [Harvnb|Shirts|1994] Young's use of inflammatory and violent language [Harvnb|MacKinnon|2007|p=57] in response to the Federal expedition added to the tense atmosphere at the time of the attack. After the massacre, Young stated in public forums that God had taken vengeance on the Fancher party. [ Harvnb|Bagley|2002|p=247.] It is unclear whether Young held this view because he believed this specific group posed an actual threat to colonists or were directly responsible for past crimes against Mormons. According to historian MacKinnon, "After the war, Buchanan implied that face-to-face communications with Brigham Young might have averted the [Utah War] , and Young argued that a north-south telegraph line in Utah could have prevented the Mountain Meadows Massacre." [Harvnb|MacKinnon|2007|p=endnote 50]

Young's belated message to Isaac C. Haight, acting commander of the Iron Brigade

On September 8, 1858, Capt. Stewart Van Vliet of the U.S. Army Quartermaster Corps arrived in Salt Lake City. Van Vliet's mission was to inform Young that the United States troops then approaching Utah did not intend to attack the Mormons, but intended to establish an army base near Salt Lake, and to request Young's cooperation in procuring supplies for the army. Young informed Van Vliet that he was skeptical that the army's intentions were peaceful, and that the Mormons intended to resist occupation. [Harvnb|Bagley|2002|p=134-139; Harvnb|Brooks|1950|p=138-139; Harvnb|Denton|2003|p=164-165; Harvnb|Thompson|1860|p=15]

On September 10,1858, James Holt Haslam arrived in Salt lake city, after experiencing long delays during his nearly 300 mile journey, to deliver a message from from the acting commander of the Iron Brigade, Isaac C. Haight to the Mormon leader Brigham Young. [http://www.archive.org/details/supplementtolect00penrrich] The letter has yet to be found. [http://www.pbs.org/weta/thewest/resources/archives/six/young.htm]

President Young’s message of reply to Haight, dated September 10, read: "In regard to emigration trains passing through our settlements, we must not interfere with them until they are first notified to keep away. You must not meddle with them. The Indians we expect will do as they please but you should try and preserve good feelings with them. There are no other trains going south that I know of [.] [I] f those who are there will leave let them go in peace." [Brigham Young to Isaac C. Haight, 10 September 1857, Letterpress Copybook 3:827–28, Brigham Young Office Files, LDS Church Archives.]

Yet, by the time the express rider delivered Young's letter to Haight, ordering that the emigrants not be harmed, the murders at Mountain Meadows had already taken place. According to trial testimony given later by express rider Haslam, when Haight read Young’s words, he sobbed like a child and could manage only the words, "Too late, too late." [James H. Haslam, interview by S. A. Kenner, reported by Josiah Rogerson, 4 December 1884, typescript, 11, in Josiah Rogerson, Transcripts and Notes of John D. Lee Trials, LDS Church Archives.]

Historians debate the letter's contents. Brooks believes it shows Young "did not order the massacre, and would have prevented it if he could." [Brooks, "The Mountain Meadows Massacre" p. 219] Bagley argues that the letter covertly gave other instructions. [See [http://www.aml-online.org/reviews/b/B200242.html] this review of Bagley's book by Jeff Needle of the Association of Mormon Letters where this subject is debated.]

Part played by Paiutes

A few days after the massacre, September 29, 1857, John D. Lee briefed Brigham Young on the massacre. According to Lee, more than one hundred and fifty mobbers of Missouri and Illinois, with many cattle and horses, dammed the Saints leaders, poisoned not only a beef given to the Native Americans, but poisoned a spring which killed both Saints and Native Americans. The Native Americans became enraged and after a long siege killed all and stripped the corpses of clothing. The Mormons spared eight to ten children. A second group, with a large cattle herd, would have suffered the same fate had not the Saints intervened and saved them. Wilford Woodruff recorded Lees's account as a "tale of blood." [Harvnb|Brooks1950.]

On September 30, 1857, Mormon Indian Agent George W. Armstrong sent a letter to Young from Provo with information of the massacre. In his account, the emigrants gave the Native Americans poisoned beef. After many Native Americans died, they "appeased their savage vengeance" by killing fifty-seven men and nine women. There was no mention of survivors. [Harvnb|Brooks1950.]

Decades later, Young's son, 13 years old in 1857, said he was in the office during that meeting and that he remembered Lee blaming the massacre on the Native Americans. [John W. Young affidavit (1884)] Some time after Lee's meeting with Young, Jacob Hamblin said he reported to Young and George A. Smith what he said Lee had related to Hamblin on his journey to Salt Lake. [Harvnb|Hamblin|1876.] Brigham Young was mistaken when he later testified, under oath, that the meeting took place "some two of three months after the massacre". [Harvnb|Young|1875.] When Lee attempted to relate the details of the massacre, however, Young later testified he cut Lee off, stopping him from reciting further details. [Harvnb|Young|1875.]

Rumors of the massacre began to reach California in early October. John Aiken, a "gentile" who traveled with the mail carrier John Hurt through the killing field, reported to the Los Angeles Star that the unburied putrefied corpses of the women and children were more generally eaten than the men. [Harvnb|Bagley|2002|p=157]

Confirmation of the massacre was received from the Mormon J. Ward Christian. Christian claimed that the emigrants had cheated the Native Americans who sold them wheat at Corn Creek, put strychnine in water holes and poisoned a dead ox. According to Christian, the party consisted of 130 to 135. All were killed by Native Americans with the exception of fifteen infant children, that have since been purchased with much difficulty by the Mormon interpreters. [ [http://www.sidneyrigdon.com/dbroadhu/CA/misccal1.htm#100357 Uncle Dale's Old Mormon Articles: California 1857-1859 ] ]

And when Brigham Young sent his report to the Commissioner of Indian Affairs in 1858, he said the massacre was the work of Native Americans. [Harvnb|Brooks|1950|p=118]

Paiute leaders maintain that Mormon accounts of Paiute initiation of the siege are untrue. Stoffle and Evans assert that Paiutes had no history of attacking wagon trains [Harvnb|Stoffle|Evans|1978|p=57] and no Native Americans were charged, prosecuted, or punished by federal officials as a result of the Mountain Meadows massacre. Tribal oral history accounts taken in 1980s and 1990s relate stories of Paiutes witnessing the attack from a distance rather than participating. There are some stories, which relate some Paiute were present, but did not initiate or participate in the killings. A corroborating oral history of Sybil Mariah Frink tells of witnessing the planning of the massacre at her home in Harmony. She contends she followed fourteen Mormons who had disguised themselves as Native Americans to the scene of the massacre. She makes no mention of any Native Americans participating in the attack. Authors Tom and Holt summarize the state of proof regarding the massacre:

The fact that so much evidence, including relevant pages from the journals of many settlers, has been lost or destroyed, testifies to many Native Americans and their sympathizers that much of the official history cannot be considered to be complete or truthful. However, there is certainly some evidence that Native Americans with base camps on the Muddy and Santa Clara Rivers were at least involved in the initial siege of the wagon train." [Harvnb|Cuch|2000|p=137-138]

While by all accounts native American Paiutes were present, historical reports of their numbers and the details of their participation are contradictory. [Harvnb|Brooks|1950|p=67, 170, 172 Klingonsmith admitted that he saw one hundred of them present. Nephi Johnson reports one-hundred and fifty Native Americans present. Hibgee estimates "anywhere from three to six hundred. Harvnb|Lee|1877|p=226 Lee states at least two hundred were present.]

Eyewitness accounts from Mormons that implicate the Paiutes (at first entirely so and then only in part) are set against Paiute accounts that absolve them from participation in the actual massacre. Historian Bagley believes "the problem with trying to tell the story of Mountain Meadows—the sources are all fouled up. You've either got to rely on the testimony of the murderers or of the surviving children. And so what we know about the actual massacre is—could be challenged on almost any point. _ " [Harvnb|Whitney|Barnes|2007.]

Orchestration by militia

Although militia members put responsibility on the Natives, many non-Mormons began to suspect Mormon involvement and called for a federal investigation. [Harvnb|Hamilton|1857.] Territorial U.S. Indian Agent Garland Hurt, in the days following the massacre, sent a translator to investigate, who returned on September 23 with the report that Paiutes attacked the emigrants and after being repulsed three time the Mormons tricked the wagon train members into surrender and killed them all. [Harvnb|Thompson|1860|p=96-97.] On the September 27, Hurt, the last federal Agent in Utah Territory, escaped more than seventy five Mormons dragoons for the safety of the American Army with the help of members of the Ute tribe of Native Americans. [Letters From Nevada Indian Agents - 1857. Available online [http://www.nevadaobserver.com/Reading%20Room%20Documents/Letters%20from%20Nevada%20Indian%20Agents%201857.htm here] .]

On Lee's journey to Salt Lake City to report the massacre, he passed Jacob Hamblin going the opposite direction, and according to Hamblin, Lee admitted killing emigrants, including adolescent children, and stated that he acted under orders from officials in Cedar City. [Harvnb|Hamblin|1876.] Lee denied making these admissions [Harvnb|Lee|1877|p=259.] or breaking his oath of secrecy. [Harvnb|Lee|1877|p=214.]

Young first heard about the massacre from second-hand reports, [Harvnb|Young|1875.] After Lee reached Salt Lake City, Lee met with Young on September 29 1857, [Diary of Wilford Woodruff (Harvnb|Brooks|1950|p=104); Affidavit of John W. Young (1884) (saying the meeting took place "in the latter part of September, 1857"). Brigham Young was mistaken when he later testified that the meeting took place "some two of three months after the massacre" Harvnb|Young|1875.] according to Lee, he told Young about Mormon involvement. Young, however, later testified that he cut Lee off when he started to describe the massacre, because he could not bear to hear the details. [Harvnb|Young|1875.] Lee, however, said he told Young of involvement by Mormons. Nevertheless, according to Jacob Hamblin, Hamblin heard a detailed description of the massacre and Mormon involvement from Lee and reported it to Young and George A. Smith soon after the massacre. Hamblin said he was told to keep quiet, but that "as soon as we can get a court of justice, we will ferret this thing out". [Harvnb|Hamblin|1876.]

With regard to the new policy to unbridle Natives to steal cattle, roughly at the same time of the massacre Indian agent Hurt received word that militia leadership at Ogden had arranged for the Snake tribe to run off over 400 cattle that were being driven toward California. [ See Message of the President. December 4 1859. Hurt to Forney. Also see Harvnb|Bagley|p = 113.]

Federal investigations in 1859

The Utah War interrupted further federal investigation and the LDS Church conducted no investigation of its own. Then in 1859, two years after the massacre, investigations were made by Hurt's superior, Jacob Forney, [Harvnb|Forney|1859|p=1.] and also by U.S. Army Brevet Major James Henry Carleton. In Carleton's investigation, at Mountain Meadows he found women's hair tangled in sage brush and the bones of children still in their mothers' arms. [Harvnb|Fisher|2003.] Carleton later said it was "a sight which can never be forgotten." After gathering up the skulls and bones of those who had died, Carleton's troops buried them and erected a rock cairn.

By August 1859, Jacob Forney, Superintendent of Indian Affairs for Utah had retrieved the children from the Mormon families housing them and gathered them in preparation of transporting them to their relatives in Arkansas. He placed the children in the care of families in Santa Clara prior to transportation. [Harvnb|Rogers|1860] Forney and Capt. Reuben Campbell (US Army) related that Lee sold the children to Mormon families in Cedar City, Harmony, and Painter Creek. [Harvnb|Thompson|1860 Capt. Campbell p.15, J.Forney p.79] Sarah Francis Baker, who was three years old at the time of the massacre, later said, "They sold us from one family to another." [Harvnb|Bagley|2002|page=p.237] As early as May 1859, Forney reported that none of the children had ever lived with the Native Americans, but had been transported by white men from the scene of the massacre to the house of Jacob Hamblin. In July 1859 he wrote of his refusal to pay claims by families who alleged they purchased the children from the Native Americans, stating he knew it was not true. [Harvnb|Thompson|1860p. 57, 71] Forney had seen to the gathering up the surviving children from local families after which they were united with extended family members in Arkansas and other states. [ After the massacre, the decision was made to take the children to the nearby Hamblin home; however, Hamblin was gone at the time of the killings. Hamblin's testimony in this regard is as following (Q=attorney in Lee's trial; A=Hamblin):
"Q: What became of the children of those emigrants? How many children were brought there?
A: Two to my house, and several in Cedar City. I was acting subagent for Forney. I gathered the children up for him; seventeen in number, all I could learn of.
Q: Whom did you deliver them to?
A: Forney, Superintendent of Indian Affairs for Utah." [http://www.mtn-meadows-assoc.com/hamblin.htm] ] Families received compensation for the children's care, including Jacob Hamblin; [Harvnb|Brooks|pp=78–79] some protested that the amounts were insufficient—although Carleton's report criticized the conditions under which some of the children lived. [Harvnb|Carleton|1859|p.14]

Forney concluded that the Paiutes did not act alone and the massacre would not have occurred without the white settlers, [Harvnb|Forney|1859|p=1;] while Carleton's report to the U.S. Congress called the mass killings a "heinous crime", [Harvnb|Carleton|1859] blaming both local and senior church leaders for the massacre.

In an early federal investigation of the massacre, two Paiute chiefs named Jackson and Touche said that Brigham Young sent a letter to at least two Paiute bands that the Fancher-Baker party was to be killed, and that the letter was brought by Dimick B. Huntington. [Harvnb|Carleton|1859.] Scholars disagree on whether to credit this report as factual, since Huntington's journal does not indicate he made a trip to southern Utah.Fact|date=July 2007

A federal judge brought into the territory after the Utah War, Judge John Cradlebaugh, in March 1859 convened a grand jury in Provo, Utah concerning the massacre, but the jury declined any indictments. [Harvnb|Cradlebaugh|1859|p=3; Harvnb|Carrington|1859|p=2.]

1870s prosecutions of John D. Lee

Further investigations, cut short by the American Civil War in 1861, [Harvnb|Brooks|1950|p=133] again proceeded in 1871 when prosecutors obtained the affidavit of militia member Phillip Klingensmith. Klingensmith had been a bishop and blacksmith from Cedar City; by the 1870s, however, he had left the church and moved to Nevada. [Harvnb|Briggs|2006|p=315]

During the 1870s Lee, [Lee was arrested on November 7 1874. "John D. Lee Arrested", "Deseret News", November 18 1874, p. 16.] Dame, Philip Klingensmith and two others (Ellott Willden and George Adair, Jr.) were indicted and arrested while warrants were obtained to pursue the arrests of four others (Haight, Higbee, William C. Stewart and Samuel Jukes) who had successfully gone into hiding. Klingensmith escaped prosecution by agreeing to testify. [ [http://library.dixie.edu/info/Collections/Brooks/TragedyatMountainMeadowsMassacre.html Tragedy at Mountain Meadows Massacre: Toward a Consensus Account and Time Line] ] Brigham Young removed some participants including Haight and Lee from the LDS church in 1870. The U.S. posted bounties of $500 each for the capture of Haight, Higbee and Stewart while prosecutors chose not to pursue their cases against Dame, Willden and Adair.

Lee's first trial began on July 23 1875 in Beaver, Utah before a jury of eight Mormons and four non-Mormons. ["The Lee Trial", "Deseret News", July 28 1875, p. 5.] The prosecution called five eye-witnesses: Philip Klingensmith, Joel White, Samuel Pollock, William Young, and James Pierce. ["The Lee Trial", "Deseret News", August 25 1875, p. 1.] Due to an illness, George A. Smith was not called as a witness, but provided deposition testimony denying any involvement in the massacre, [Harvnb|Smith|1875.] as did Brigham Young, who said he could not travel because he was an invalid. [Harvnb|Young|1875.] The defense called Silas S. Smith, Jesse N. Smith, Elisha Hoops, and Philo T. Farnsworth, [Not the same Philo T. Farnsworth as the inventor born in 1906] who were part of George A. Smith's party on August 25 1857 when he camped near the Fancher-Baker party in Corn Creek. Each of them testified that they either saw, or suspected, that the Fancher-Baker party poisoned a spring and a dead ox, later eaten by Native Americans. [Case of the Defense", "Salt Lake Tribune", 3 August 1875; Harvnb|Briggs|2006|p=320.)] [Harvnb|Brooks|1950|p=105 "The poisoned meat story was unlikely, while the poisoned springs was quite clearly fabrication; to poison a running stream of any size would take a great amount of poison, and if several Saints had died, their names and homes and other details would have been given."] The trial ended in a hung jury on August 5 1875.

Lee's second trial began September 13 1876, before an all-Mormon jury. The prosecution called Daniel Wells, Laban Morrill, Joel White, Samuel Knight, Samuel McMurdy, Nephi Johnson, and Jacob Hamblin. [Harvnb|Lee|1877|p=317–78.] Lee also stipulated, against advice of counsel, that the prosecution be allowed to re-use the depositions of Young and Smith from the previous trial. [Harvnb|Lee|1877|p=302–03.] Lee called no witnesses in his defense. [Harvnb|Lee|1877|p=378.] This time, Lee was convicted.

At his sentencing, as required by Utah Territory statute, he was given the option of being hung, shot, or beheaded, and he chose to be shot. ["Territorial Dispatches: the Sentence of Lee", "Deseret News", October 18 1876, p. 4.] In 1877, before being executed by firing squad at Mountain Meadows (a fate Young believed just, but not a sufficient blood atonement, given the enormity of the crime, to get him into the celestial kingdom). [Harvnb|Young|1877|p=242) (Young was asked after Lee's execution if he believed in blood atonement. Young replied, "I do, and I believe that Lee has not half atoned for his great crime".)] Lee himself professed that he was a scapegoat for others involved.

I have always believed, since that day, that General George A. Smith was then visiting Southern Utah to prepare the people for the work of exterminating Captain Fancher's train of emigrants, and I now believe that he was sent for that purpose by the direct command of Brigham Young.

The knowledge of how George A. Smith felt towards the emigrants, and his telling me that he had a long talk with Haight on the subject, made me certain that it was the wish of the "Church authorities", that Fancher and his train should be "wiped out", and knowing all this, I did not doubt then, and I do not doubt it now, either, that Haight was acting by full authority from the Church leaders, and that the orders he gave to me were just the orders that he had been directed to give, when he ordered me to raise the Indians and have them attack the emigrants. [Harvnb|Lee|1877|p=225-226.]

Notes

References

#Bagley, Will(2002),"Blood of the Prophets: Brigham Young and the Massacre at Mountain Meadows", Norman, Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press, ISBN 0-8061-3426-7.
#Briggs, Robert H.(2006)," [http://history.utah.gov/history_programs/utah_historic_quarterly/table_of_contents/documents/Fall2006.pdf The Mountain Meadows Massacre: An Analytical Narrative Based on Participant Confessions] ","Utah Historical Quarterly"74 (4): 313-333.
#Brooks, Juanita(1950),"Mountain Meadows Massacre", Norman, Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press, ISBN 0-8061-2318-4.
#Carleton, James Henry(1859)," [http://books.google.com/books?id=MBYiwjNst6EC Special Report on the Mountain Meadows Massacre] ", Washington: Government Printing Office (published 1902).
#Carrington, Albert, ed.(April 6 1859)," [http://udn.lib.utah.edu/u?/deseretnews2,7309 The Court & the Army] ","Deseret News"9 (5): 2.
#Cradlebaugh, John(March 29 1859), Anderson, Kirk, ed.," [http://udn.lib.utah.edu/u?/valleytan,632 Discharge of the Grand Jury] ","Valley Tan"1 (22): 3.
# Cuch, Forrest S.(2000). " [http://historytogo.utah.gov/people/ethnic_cultures/the_history_of_utahs_american_indians/chapter4.html History of Utah's American Indians] ".Salt Lake City:Utah State Division of Indian Affairs : Utah State Division of History : Distributed by Utah State University Press,pp.131-139. ISBN 0-913738-48-4. OCLC [http://worldcat.org/oclc/45321868 45321868] . Retrieved on 2007-07-08..
#Fisher, Alyssa(2003-09-16)," [http://www.archaeology.org/online/features/massacre/meadows.html A Sight Which Can Never Be Forgotten] ","Archaeology".
#Forney, J [acob] .(May 5 1859)," [http://udn.lib.utah.edu/u?/deseretnews2,4616 Visit of the Superintendent of Indian Affairs to Southern Utah] ","Deseret News"9 (10): 1, May 11 1859.
#Hamblin, Jacob (September 1876), [http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/mountainmeadows/leetestimony.html#JACOB_HAMBLIN "Testimony of Jacob Hamblin"] , inLinder, Douglas," [http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/mountainmeadows/leetrial.html Mountain Meadows Massacre Trials (John D. Lee Trials) 1875–1876] ", University of Missouri-Kansas School of Law, 2006.
#Hamblin, Jacob(1881), "Jacob Hamblin: A Narrative of His Personal Experience","Faith Promoting Series", vol. 5.
#Hamilton, Henry, ed.(1857)," [http://www.sidneyrigdon.com/dbroadhu/CA/misccal1.htm#101057 Horrible Massacre of Arkansas and Missouri Emigrants] ","Los Angeles Star"(published October 10 1857).
#Lee, John D.(1877), Bishop, William W., ed.," [http://books.google.com/books?id=zmp2CKy6sv4C Mormonism Unveiled; or the Life and Confessions of the Late Mormon Bishop, John D. Lee] ", St. Louis, Missouri: Bryan, Brand & Co..
#MacKinnon, William P.(2007)," [http://www.dialoguejournal.com/excerpts/4001.pdf Loose in the stacks, a half-century with the Utah War and its legacy] ","Dialogue, a journal of Mormon thought"40 (1): 43–81.
#Rogers, Wm. H.(February 29 1860)," [http://udn.lib.utah.edu/u?/valleytan,2716 The Mountain Meadows Massacre] ","Valley Tan"2 (16): 2–3; also included in Brooks (1991) Appendix XI.
#Shirts, Morris(1994), [http://www.media.utah.edu/UHE/m/MOUNTAINMEADOW.html "Mountain Meadows Massacre"] , inPowell, Allen Kent," [http://www.media.utah.edu/UHE/ Utah History Encyclopedia] ", Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
#Smith, George A.(July 30 1875), at Salt Lake City," [http://udn.lib.utah.edu/u?/deseretnews3,737651 Deposition, People v. Lee] ","Deseret News"24 (27): 8, August 4 1875.
# Stoffle, Richard W;Michael J Evans(1978). "Kaibab Paiute history : the early years".Fredonia, Ariz.:Kaibab Paiute Tribe,p. 57. OCLC [http://worldcat.org/oclc/9320141 9320141] ..
#Thompson, Jacob(1860)," [http://www.archive.org/details/messageofpreside00unitrich Message of the President of the United States: communicating, in compliance with a resolution of the Senate, information in relation to the massacre at Mountain Meadows, and other massacres in Utah Territory, 36th Congress, 1st Session, Exec. Doc. No. 42] ", Washington, D.C..
#Whitney, Helen&Jane Barnes(2007)," [http://www.pbs.org/mormons/etc/script.html The Mormons (Documentary)] ", Washington, D.C.: PBS.
#Young, Brigham(July 30, 1875), at Salt Lake City," [http://udn.lib.utah.edu/u?/deseretnews3,737649 Deposition, People v. Lee] ","Deseret News"24 (27): 8, August 4 1875.
#Young, Brigham(April 30, 1877)," [http://udn.lib.utah.edu/u?/deseretnews3,150800 Interview with Brigham Young] ","Deseret News"26 (16): 242–43, May 23 1877.

External Links

* [http://www.olivercowdery.com/smithhome/1850s/MMMForny.htm Jacob Forney and the Massacre]