Mary Laffoy

Mary Laffoy

Mary Laffoy is a High Court judge in the Republic of Ireland.

Career

She is most notable for presiding over the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, known as the "Laffoy Commission", an inquiry into child abuse, before causing controversy by resigning as its chair.

In her letter of resignation from that Commission of 2 September 2003, Ms. Justice Laffoy outlined her belief that the actions of the Government and the Department of Education had frustrated her efforts and had slowed the commission's work.[1] The commission was then chaired in 2003-09 by Judge Ryan.

Main points contained in the resignation letter of Justice Laffoy

  • That the Government's decision to engage in a second phase of a review had effectively put the substantive work of the Commission's Investigation Committee on hold.
  • That the only clear inference to be taken from correspondence received from the Department of Education and Science was that the Government had decided that the Commission would not implement its statutory mandate.
  • That the Commission had never been properly enabled by the Government to fulfill satisfactorily the functions conferred on it by the Oireachtas.
  • That range of factors over which the Commission had no control, produced a real and pervasive sense of powerlessness, including:
    • the two-year delay on the issue of compensation for survivors of abuse eventually dealt with in the Residential Institutions Redress Act enacted in April 2002;
    • the two-year delay in the payment of legal costs of persons involved in the process eventually dealt with in the Act;
    • the Government handling of requests for the provision of adequate resources to enable the Investigation Committee to carry out its remit with reasonable expedition when the volume of allegations became known;
    • the Government decision in December 2002 to review the Commission's mandate which was to be completed in February 2003 but which has not yet been published;
    • the Government decision of December 2002 to agree in principle to the provision of additional resources was made contingent on the outcome of the review, and so had proved meaningless.
  • That the cumulative effect of those factors effectively negatived the guarantee of independence conferred on the Commission and militated against it being able to perform its statutory functions.
  • That it was not possible to deduce the nature of the functions which were likely to be conferred on the Commission post review, save that they would be substantially different from its then functions.
  • That it was not possible to predict whether the chairperson might be precluded from continuing her work on the Investigation Committee or to predict the duration of the review.
  • That the investigations which the Commission had conducted up to the time of her resignation might transpire to be redundant or incorrectly focused in the light of a future unknown mandate.
  • That to abide, without protest, the outcome of the further radical review then proposed, would be a complete abrogation of the independence which the Oireachtas intended the Commission to enjoy and would undermine the credibility of the chairperson.
  • That the ongoing uncertainty was detrimental to the interests of the persons who alleged that they suffered abuse and had the potential to give rise to unfairness and injustice toward individuals against whom allegations had been made.
  • That there was a risk that a Commission which worked first to one mandate and then to a substantially different one, would leave itself open to legal challenge.

Notes

  1. ^ Arnold B., The Irish Gulag Gill and Macmillan, Dublin 2009. Chapters 9 & 10. ISBN 9780717146147



Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse — The Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (CICA) is one of a range of measures introduced by the Irish Government to investigate the extent and effects of abuse on children from 1936 onwards. It is commonly known in Ireland as the Ryan… …   Wikipedia

  • Ryan-Bericht — Der Ryan Bericht ist das Ergebnis der öffentlichen Untersuchung in Irland zum Missbrauchsskandal der katholischen Kirche in Irland der irischen Kommission zur Aufklärung von Kindesmissbrauch unter Richter Seán Ryan. In Irland ist er bekannt als… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • September 3, 2003 — September 3, 2003= * Occupation of Iraq : Poland assumes a position in postwar Iraq. The coalition in Iraq hands over the south central part of the country to a force led by Poland. The force of Polish troops leads a multinational peacekeeping… …   Wikipedia

  • Ireland — Irelander, n. /uyeur leuhnd/, n. 1. John, 1838 1918, U.S. Roman Catholic clergyman and social reformer, born in Ireland: archbishop of St. Paul, Minn., 1888 1918. 2. Also called Emerald Isle. Latin, Hibernia. a large western island of the British …   Universalium

  • High Court (Ireland) — Not to be confused with Courts of Northern Ireland#High Court. Ireland This article is part of the series: Politics and government of the Republic of Ireland …   Wikipedia

  • Magdalenenheime — waren Einrichtungen für so genannte „gefallene“ Frauen in Irland. Diese Heime wurden in der Regel von katholischen Orden geführt und unterstanden der römisch katholischen Kirche. Die Insassen wurden meist gezwungen, ohne Lohn harte körperliche… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Magdalene Asylum — Magdalene Asylums were institutions for so called fallen women, most of them operated by different orders of the Roman Catholic Church. In most asylums, the inmates were required to undertake hard physical labour such as laundry work. In Ireland …   Wikipedia

  • Magdalenenheim — Magdalenenheime waren Einrichtungen für so genannte „gefallene Frauen“ in Irland. Diese Heime wurden in der Regel von katholischen Orden geführt und unterstanden der römisch katholischen Kirche. Die Insassen wurden meist gezwungen, ohne Lohn… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”