- Eight Deadly Words
The Eight Deadly Words are "I don't "care" what happens to these people." [cite web| url=http://www.geocities.com/Athens/4824/sf-written.htm#34F | title=The Eight Deadly Words| work=rec.arts.sf.written Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)| accessdate=2006-07-04| year=2005| first=Evelyn C.| last= Leeper] The phrase is commonly used in
science fiction fandom as a criticism of stories that fail to engage the reader through a lack of interesting or compelling characters. A person reviewing a book might for example write "...and at that point I said the Eight Deadly Words" to indicate loss of interest for this reason.The phrase was coined by
Dorothy J. Heydt in aJune 11 ,1991 ,Usenet posting to rec.arts.sf-lovers in reference toThe Copper Crown , a novel byPatricia Kennealy-Morrison ::I put it down and went to sleep. And when I woke up in the morning and picked it up again, I thought, "I don't care what happens to these people," and put it down again.cite web| url=http://groups.google.com/group/rec.arts.sf-lovers/msg/9c5e879597b7fd4d| title=de gustibus| publisher=rec.arts.sf-lovers| first=Dorothy J| last=Heydt| date=
11 June 1991 | accessdate=2006-04-29| id=message-id <1991Jun12.030517.26647@agate.berkeley.edu>]The phrase was first referred to by the term "Eight Deadly Words" by Heydt in a
September 15 ,1993 ,Usenet posting to rec.arts.sf.written in reference to aFionavar Tapestry book::The Eight Deadly Words (tm):
:"I don't _care_ *what* happens to these people!"cite web| url=http://groups.google.com/group/rec.arts.sf.written/msg/c0c86ef8c3d067df?dmode=source| title=Re: The Fionavar Tapestry vs. The Wheel of Time| publisher=rec.arts.sf.written| first=Dorothy J| last=Heydt| year=15 Sep 1993| accessdate=2006-04-10| id=message-id <277tn4$q62@agate.berkeley.edu>]
Although the term "Eight Deadly Words" is not actually
trademark ed, within two days the catchphrase was being used independently by John S. Novak. A few days later it was used in the title of a thread for the first time. In 1994 it spread beyond its original newsgroup when Heydt inadvertently crossposted it to the alt.books.deryni newsgroup. Later that year, the term takes on a life of its own, spreading independently of Heydt into other newsgroups, such as rec.arts.comics.misc.Heydt has also stated that she coined the term while reading
The Great Hunt byRobert Jordan ::It was myself who coined them, and the occasion was getting to about Chapter Two, Volume Two, of _The Wheel of Time_, and shutting the book and giving the whole set (three or four books at that time, I believe) to my niece, who had a long train trip ahead of her.cite web| url=http://groups.google.com/group/rec.arts.sf.written/msg/c67003d462c72a07?dmode=source| title=Re: Surviving the brain-eater?| publisher=rec.arts.sf.written| first=Dorothy J| last=Heydt| year=21 Nov 2003| accessdate=2006-04-29| id=message-id
] References
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.