The Holohan Murder Case

The Holohan Murder Case was a case concerned with the death of OSS major William Holohan in Italy during the Second World War.

During World War II, the U.S. Army Office of Strategic Services (OSS) dispatched teams of specially-trained soldiers to enemy-occupied territories to organize resistance movements. In Europe, one of those teams was dispatched to the Como, Italy area in September 1944. Their mission was code named Chrysler. Many of the partisan groups in Europe and Asia were overtly Communist in their allegiances. This gave some Allied planners concern since the Communists could be expected to use their military power to take control of post-war government. The uprising in Paris in August 1944 was fomented by pro-Communist police who were then pushed aside by forces loyal to Charles deGaulle. In Greece a civil war erupted between Communist and anti-Communist partisan forces.

Mission Chrysler

On September 27,1944, four soldiers, mission commander Major William V. Holohan, First Lieutenant Giannino, Second Lieutenant Aldo Icardi, and radio operator Carl G. LoDolce along with three Italian agents parachuted into northern Italy near Coiromonte, a frazione of Armeno in the province of Novara. Holohan was a 40-year-old lawyer who had a peacetime reserve commission in the Cavalry. Twenty-two-year-old Lieutenant Icardi was the only mission member able to speak the dialect of the region. Lieutenant Giannino could speak Italian and LoDolce spoke Sicilian. Holohan was entrusted with about $16,000 worth of U.S. dollars, gold Louis d'ors, Swiss francs, and Italian lire to fund mission activities. Holohan insisted that his men wear their uniforms in accordance with OSS directives, to avoid being executed as spies if captured.

The situation in northern Italy, 600 miles from the Allied armies, was particularly complex. There were four major anti-Fascist groups, Socialists, Action Party, Christian Democrat, and Communist, plus smaller groups under commanders with imprecise allegiances. Originally Mission Chrysler was to establish a show of authority and liaison in the area in anticipation of an early Axis capitulation. When this did not happen, the mission was changed to assist the partisan units with arms and supplies.

German forces came after the Chrysler men and they had several narrow escapes from anti-partisan sweeps. At one point, the German's pinpointed the OSS transmitter to within 100 yards, but partisans intercepted three Germans and a Swiss interpreter with direction finding gear. In December an independent partisan leader called Cinquanta betrayed the Chrysler men to the Germans (Cinquanta was later assassinated).

Communists

On December 2, 1944, Holohan sent Icardi to meet with the local Communist commander Vincenzo Moscatelli. This was arranged, reluctantly, by Aminta Migliari aka Giorgio who had wanted the arms drops funneled through him. Although Migliari proved to be treacherous, the OSS men had to rely on him for support. The Communists, who were about 75 percent of the partisans in the Chrysler area, were supposed to receive equal allocations of the two arms drops, but the Communists frequently raided drops intended for rival groups. Lieutenant Icardi stated in 1950 that Holohan treated the Communists equally with the other groups. Some Italians regarded him as "fervently anti-Communist." (NY Times, 10-23-1953)

On December 6, 1944, the OSS men were holed up in Villa Castelnuovo on Lake Orta when two friendly priests came to warn them to flee. As soldiers left in the darkness, gunfire broke out and Holohan, Icardi, LoDolce and Italian agents Gualtiero and Tozzini fired back. By prearrangement, the men would split up if attacked. Icardi made it to Giorgio's headquarters. When the men finally reunited, Holohan was missing. Icardi reported the incident to his headquarters.

Two weeks later, an OSS man from Milan visited the Lake Orta and investigated Holohan's disappearance. At the villa the officer found spent 9mm shell casings (used by all sides) and on the beach, one of Holohan's hand grenades.

The surviving Chrysler men continued to arrange supply drops to the partisans and Moscatelli stated later that after Holohan’s death, OSS support increased. In February 1945, Mission Chrysler was ordered to Milan, but its operations changed because of the urban environment which precluded air drops and hiding in the countryside.

Questions

After the war, Holohan's brother, Joseph R. Holahan (his spelling), a stockbroker, sought to learn more about the night at Villa Castelnuovo. He wrote to the Defense Department, to Italian police, and he interviewed Icardi, by then a lawyer in Pittsburgh. In 1947, after the OSS men returned to civilian life, Icardi was interviewed by Army investigators and he was given a polygraph examination. Icardi offered to reenter the Army in order to submit to a court martial and clear up any questions.

In January 1949, Italian Carabiniere Lieutenant Elio Albieri got interested in the case. He questioned ex partisans Tozzini and Mannini in March 1950. They told a story of Icardi becoming resentful of Holohan's refusal to support the Communists and hatching a plot to murder the major. When an attempt to poison Holohan's soup failed, a toss of a coin selected LoDolce to go to Holohan's room where LoDolce shot him twice in the head. The Italians stuffed Holohan's body into a sleeping bag and then dumped it into the lake. The men assisted the Italian police in recovering the body which was identified as Holohan's. The skull showed two bullet wounds.

On August 3, 1950, former Sergeant Carl G. LoDolce gave a statement to Army CID in Rochester, NY allegedly to the effect that he and former Lieutenant Aldo Icardi, both members of Holohan's team, had killed Holoran in a dispute over providing aid to Communist partisans. The members of the mission had drawn lots to see who would kill Holohan.

Another former O.S.S. sergeant who served on Chrysler, Arthur P. Ciaramicoli declared the allegations "silly." As for feelings towards Holohan, Ciaramicoli told a reporter, "We all didn't particularly like the major. He was older than the rest of us and was content to sit back and take things easy. He endangered our lives on several occasions by his attitude." (NY Times, 8-18-1951)

Icardi denied involvement in Holoran's death and LoDolce repudiated the press accounts of his involvement in murder taken by the CID investigator. Former partisan leader Vincenzo Moscatelli, by now Senator in Parliament told reporters that Holohan had an "anti-Communist attitude" and described Icardi as a "valiant soldier who helped greatly in the partisan struggle against the Germans." "True" magazine Rome correspondent Michael Stern published an article based on the Italian case and "Time" magazine also adopted the Italian version in its coverage. The New York Times published a lengthy statement by Icardi given to the The Pittsburgh Press.

Trial in absentia

In the fall of 1951, the Italian government charged Icardi and LoDolce with murder and tried to have them extradited to Italy. U.S. judges denied the extradition requests. Icardi and LoDolce were outside the jurisdiction of U.S. military authorities because they had been discharged, and U.S. Courts had no jurisdiction over offenses committed in Italy. The judge in Icardi’s case refused the request to extradite him because at the time of the alleged crime, the Italian government did not have control over the area of the offense. In their rulings however, the judges accepted the Italian version of events.

In 1953, the two Americans were tried for murder in absentia in Novara, Italy along with former partisans "Giorgio" Migliari, Giuseppa Mannini, and Gualtieri Tozzini. The Italians testified to helping plan the murder of Holoran who was poisoned and shot by LoDolce on Icardi's orders in order to divert more arms to Communists and to acquire between $45,000 and $150,000 (far more than the actual funds involved) that Holoran had for covert operations. They said that Holohan was "sentenced to death" as a "traitor."

Migliari testified that he and Icardi each invested $75,000 in Italian lire in a toy factory, the money coming from commissions paid by Holohan to get favorable exchange rates on the mission's funds. Some witnesses accused Icardi of living a lavish life style and that Icardi had murdered Holohan on the orders of superiors while others complimented Icardi's honesty and courage. Senator Moscatelli testified. When asked if Icardi was a Communist, the former partisan leader said, “How could he be if he is still a member of the United States Intelligence service?” (NY Times, 10-21-1953) Although Icardi and LoDolce were absent, they had a lawyer who told the court that Major Holohan had to be eliminated "as an obstacle in the fight for victory." (NY Times, 11-6-1953)

The Italians (who spent three years in jail) were acquitted by the judges who felt that the partisans acted "out of necessity" (NY Times, 8-30-1955) and were following orders. The Americans were convicted in absentia of murder. Icardi was sentenced to life imprisonment and LoDolce was sentenced to 17 years. Since neither man could be forced to go to Italy, neither served time.

A committee investigates

The U.S. Congress then entered the story after Joseph Holahan joined the staff of the House Armed Services Committee. On March 26, 1953, a two-man subcommittee including Chairman W. Sterling Cole, traveled to Pittsburgh and interviewed Icardi who denied the charges of murder. On August 29, 1955, Icardi was indicted by a federal grand jury for eight counts of perjury.

Trial opened on April 17, 1956 and the prosecution had 18 Italian witnesses ready. Icardi's defense attorney, Edward Bennett Williams, argued that Holohan was killed on the orders of Communist partisan leader Moscatelli because of Holohan's opposition to the Communists. The attack that killed Holohan was actually staged by the Moscatelli’s men. Williams got Congressman Cole to admit that he had discussed getting a perjury charge against Icardi before the interview. After Cole stepped down from the witness stand, Williams moved that the case be dismissed because there was no valid legislative purpose in the interrogations of Icardi.

On April 19, 1956, Judge Richmond B. Keech handed down a directed verdict of acquittal on the perjury charges citing the defense argument that there was no valid legislative purpose to Icardi's testimony before the subcommittee and the perjury charge could not stand. Keech had strong words for Congressman Cole's conduct. Icardi wept.

Confession

Williams later went to Italy with an FBI agent and met with Senator Moscatelli. Moscatelli was still in the Italian Parliament representing the Italian Communist Party. Moscatelli admitted that he was responsible for Holohan's death and Icardi had nothing to do with it.

Aldo Icardi practiced law in Florida until his retirement.

Sources

* “Icardi Denies He Helped Murder Maj. Holohan Behind Nazi Lines,” "The New York Times", August 16, 1951, p. 12;
* “LoDolce Disowns His ‘Confession’,” "Ibid.," August 18, 1951, p. 4;
* “Murder Charges Scorned by Icardi,” "Ibid.," August 19, 1951, p. 4;
* “Ruling on LoDolce Bars Extradition,” "Ibid.," August 12, 1952, p. 1;
* “Case Dismissed,” "Ibid.," August 17, 1952, p. E2;
* “Holohan Suspect Called U.S. Agent,” "Ibid.," October 21, 1952, p. 19;
* “Woman Says Icardi Sought Her Death,” "Ibid.," October 22, 1953, p. 16;
* “Italian Describes Icardi as Playboy,” "Ibid.," October 23, 1953, p. 9;
* “Woman Says Icardi Did Not Need Cash,” "Ibid.," October 24, 1953, 9;
* “Icardi Called Gangster,” "Ibid.," October 29, 1953, p. 3;
* “Icardi Motive Defended,” "Ibid.," November 6, 1953, p. 10;
* “The Holohan Murder,” "Ibid.," November 8, 1953, p. E2;
* “Icardi Indicted for Perjury in O.S.S. Killing of Major,” "Ibid"., August 30, 1955, p. 1;
* “Holohan Slaying Called Red Coup,” "Ibid.," August 18, 1956, p. 16;
* “U.S. Court Acquits Icardi; Defines Limits on Inquiries,” "Ibid.," April 20, 1956, p. 1;
* “Icardi and the Law,” "Ibid.," April 22, 1956, p. 192;
* “The Case of the Missing Major,” "Time", August 27, 1951;
* “The Unpunishable Crime,” "Ibid.," August 25, 1952;
* “Congress Off Limits,” "Ibid.," April 30, 1956;
* “Pathologist’s Report,” "Ibid.," November 19, 1956.