Juanita Broaddrick

Juanita Broaddrick is an American former nursing home administrator from Arkansas. She alleged in 1998 that United States President Bill Clinton had raped her two decades earlier. Clinton's attorney denied the allegations on his client's behalf.

The previous year, Broaddrick had filed a sworn affadavit with Paula Jones' lawyers denying that Clinton had ever assaulted her: "During the 1992 Presidential campaign there were unfounded rumors and stories circulated that Mr. Clinton had made unwelcome sexual advances toward me in the late seventies. ... These allegations are untrue ...."SamSloan.com; [http://www.samsloan.com/janedoe5.htm Affidavit of Juanita Broaddrick denying non-consensual sex with President Clinton] ; released Monday, March 30, 1998.]

In November 1998, Broaddrick contradicted her sworn statement in an interview with "Dateline NBC".Archive.org record from February 2006, of Capitol Hill Blue's original record; [http://web.archive.org/web/20060216043650/http://www.capitolhillblue.com/Feb1999/022599/datelinetranscript022599.htm Full Transcript of NBC Dateline report on Juanita Broaddrick] ; February 1999.] The interview, broadcast in February 1999, centered around Broaddrick's accusation that Bill Clinton had raped her on April 25, 1978 during his first campaign for the governorship of the U.S. state of Arkansas, at a time when Clinton was that state's Attorney General. In the interview, she declared that Clinton suddenly "turned me around and started kissing me, and that was a real shock. I first pushed him away. I just told him 'no.'... He tries to kiss me again. He starts biting on my lip... And then he forced me down on the bed. I just was very frightened. I tried to get away from him. I told him 'no.'... He wouldn't listen to me." In an interview for the Wall Street Journal editorial page, Broaddrick claimed that Clinton told her not to worry about pregnancy, because childhood mumps had left him sterile.Editorial Commentary, Dorothy Rabinowitz; Feb. 19, 1999; Page A18.] The alleged incident occurred two years before Chelsea Clinton was born.

She recanted her earlier sworn statement when interviewed by the FBI about the Jones case; the FBI found her account inconclusive, and the affidavit denying the allegations remains her only sworn testimony. Broaddrick later said of the affidavit, "I didn’t want to be forced to testify about one of the most horrific events in my life. I didn't want to go through it again."Archive.org record from February 2006, of Capitol Hill Blue's original record; [http://web.archive.org/web/20060216043650/http://www.capitolhillblue.com/Feb1999/022599/datelinetranscript022599.htm Full Transcript of NBC Dateline report on Juanita Broaddrick] ; February 1999.] David P. Schippers, chief investigator for the House Judiciary Committee Republicans during impeachment proceedings, said that his staffers interviewed Broaddrick more than once and "have assured me that she is the most credible witness that either one of them have ever talked to." Schippers believes she filed the affadavit because of intimidation from Clinton: "She was so terrified. And the reason she was terrified was because she saw what had happened to Kathleen Willey, Gennifer Flowers and all the rest of them."News Max, Carl Limbacher; [http://www.newsmax.com/articles/?a=2000/9/4/221955 Schippers: 'I Wanted Broaddrick to Testify'] ; Wednesday, September 6, 2000.] Although Broaddrick said no one had pressured her to file a false affidavit, she complained that she was being watched from parked cars, her home had been broken into, her pets released and her answering machine tape stolen while she and her husband were away briefly during the House impeachment probe.News Max, Carl Limbacher; [http://www.newsmax.com/articles/?a=2000/9/4/221955 Schippers: 'I Wanted Broaddrick to Testify'] ; Wednesday, September 6, 2000.]

Nonetheless, Broaddrick was never called as a witness during the impeachment proceedings.Washington Post, Howard Kurtz; [http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/clinton/stories/broaddrick022599.htm Clinton Accuser's Story Aired] ; Thursday, February 25, 1999; Page A15.] In his book, "Sellout: The Inside Story of President Clinton's Impeachment", Schippers said he wanted to call Broaddrick as a witness to discuss Clinton's intimidation, but it was too late.

In 1984, Broaddrick's nursing facility was judged the best in the state, which brought a congratulatory official letter from the governor. On the bottom was a handwritten note from Clinton: "I admire you very much." She interpreted it as a "thank you" for her silence.Archive.org record from February 2006, of Capitol Hill Blue's original record; [http://web.archive.org/web/20060216043650/http://www.capitolhillblue.com/Feb1999/022599/datelinetranscript022599.htm Full Transcript of NBC Dateline report on Juanita Broaddrick] ; February 1999.] Broaddrick said that Clinton tried to apologize to her in 1991 and said he was a changed man. "I told him to go to hell, and I walked off," she said.Washington Post, Howard Kurtz; [http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/clinton/stories/broaddrick022599.htm Clinton Accuser's Story Aired] ; Thursday, February 25, 1999; Page A15.]

Five people have stated that Broaddrick told them about a rape shortly after it allegedly occurred: two of these may have a grudge against Clinton for commuting the sentence of the man who killed their father, and a third is Broaddrick's current husband, who was involved in an extramarital affair with her at the time. Broaddrick did not tell her then-husband of the alleged assault at the time.Slate, Bruce Gottlieb; [http://slate.msn.com/id/1002027/ Is Juanita Broaddrick Telling the Truth?] , March 3, 1999.]

Broaddrick said she does not remember on what date she was allegedly raped. She did supply the name of the hotel (Camelot) and the reason she was visiting Little Rock (a nursing home seminar) when the incident allegedly occurred.Slate, Bruce Gottlieb; [http://slate.msn.com/id/1002027/ Is Juanita Broaddrick Telling the Truth?] , March 3, 1999.] NBC News found that a nursing conference was held in the Camelot Hotel on April 25, 1978.Archive.org record from February 2006, of Capitol Hill Blue's original record; [http://web.archive.org/web/20060216043650/http://www.capitolhillblue.com/Feb1999/022599/datelinetranscript022599.htm Full Transcript of NBC Dateline report on Juanita Broaddrick] ; February 1999.] The hotel was located in the state capitol where news reports indicate Clinton was that day and that he had no known official commitments that morning. The Clinton White House declined to release his official schedule for the date. Three weeks after this date, Broaddrick attended a Clinton fundraiser. According to the "The Wall Street Journal" (February 19, 1999, p. A18), "Her friend Norma Rogers, a nurse who had accompanied her on the trip," found Broaddrick distraught shortly after the time of the alleged attack.

In March 1999, a few months after the allegations publicly aired, 56% of Americans believed the allegations untrue while a third believed that Broaddrick's allegation of rape was at least probably true. Similarly, 29% felt the press should continue to cover the story, while 66% of the public felt that the media should stop pursuing the story.CNN Polling, [http://www.cnn.com/ALLPOLITICS/stories/1999/03/01/poll/ Poll: Most believe media should lay off Broaddrick allegation] , 1 March, 1999.]

According to Jack Nelson, Washington bureau chief of the "Los Angeles Times", many journalists were skeptical; "This is a story that's been knocked down and discredited so many times, I was shocked to see it in the " [Wall Street Journal| [Wall Street] Journal] " today.... Everyone's taken a slice of it, and after looking at it, everyone's knocked it down. The woman has changed her story about whether it happened. It just wasn't credible."Salon Magazine, Lisa Myers; [http://archive.salon.com/news/1999/02/cov_20news2.html THE UGLIEST STORY YET] , February 20, 1999.] Joe Conason and Gene Lyons' book "The Hunting of the President" argued that Broaddrick's claim is not credible and contains numerous inconsistencies.

Michael Isikoff's book "Uncovering Clinton" and Christopher Hitchens' book "No One Left to Lie To" argued that Broaddrick's claim is credible and shows similarities to Paula Jones' later allegation of sexual harassment. "Washington Post" columnist Richard Cohen commented: "And yet, I cannot get [Broaddrick's] accusation out of my head. On television, and in interviews with newspaper reporters, Broaddrick appeared credible."The Daily Howler; [http://www.dailyhowler.com/h030499_1.shtml Minor mishaps: And Richard makes three] , March 4 1999.]

Clinton's attorney, David Kendall, denied the allegations on Clinton's behalf. No legal action, civil or criminal, was taken against Clinton or Broaddrick based on the allegation.

Broaddrick filed a lawsuit against Clinton in the summer of 1999 to obtain documents the White House may have gathered about her, claiming its refusal to accede to her demand for such documents violated the Privacy Act of 1974. The case was dismissed in 2001. During the lawsuit, Broadrick's business was audited by the IRS which she charged was retaliation: "I do not believe this was coincidence," Broaddrick declared, "I do not think our number just came up."World Net Daily; [http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=44451 The rape of Juanita Broaddrick] ; May 26, 2005.]

References