Andrew Stewart (d. 1541)

infobox bishopbiog
name = Andrew Stewart


religion=Roman Catholic Church
See = Diocese of Caithness
Title = Bishop of Caithness
Period = 1517–1541
consecration = December 14, 1517 (papal provision)
Predecessor = Andrew Stewart
Successor =Alexander Gordon
post = Rector of Blair| ordination =
bishops = Bishop of Dunkeld (elect: 1515–1516)
date of birth = 1400s
place of birth = Probably Atholl
date of death =
place of death = Dornoch, 1541

Andrew Stewart (died 1541) was a 16th century Scottish noble and cleric. He was the legitimate [See Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 248, n. 1, for dismissal of previous speculation that he was a bastard.] son of John Stewart, 1st Earl of Atholl and Eleanor Sinclair, daughter of William Sinclair, Earl of Orkney. His paternal grandmother was Joan Beaufort, former queen-consort of Scotland (to James I). [Boardman, "Stewart, John, first earl of Atholl (1440?–1512)".] Andrew chose an ecclesiastical career, held a canonry in Dunkeld Cathedral and was rector of Blair parish church (Dunkeld diocese),Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 248.] a church under the control of the earls of Atholl. [Cowan, "Parishes of Medieval Scotland", p. 18.]

After the death in January 1515 of George Brown, Bishop of Dunkeld, a new bishop was needed for that bishopric. Queen Margaret, husband of the recently deceased James IV and mother of the young James V, backed to succeed Brown one Gavin Douglas, a poet and cleric who was Provost of St Giles church in Edinburgh. [Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 83.] He was the uncle of the queen's new husband, Archibald Douglas, 6th Earl of Angus.Bawcutt, "Douglas, Gavin (c.1476–1522)".] The queen had put him forward on January 20, 1515, just a few days after Brown's death. Douglas had lately missed out on the position of Archbishop of St Andrews, and so this was in some way intended as compensation. [Watt, "Fasti Ecclesiae", pp. 99, 297-8.] Douglas had a proctor pay 450 florins to the Papal see, and Pope Leo X confirmed his position on May 25. [Watt, "Fasti Ecclesiae", p. 99; Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 83.]

Meanwhile, Andrew Stewart's brother John Stewart, 2nd Earl of Atholl, pressured the chapter of Dunkeld Cathedral to elect Andrew to the see instead of Douglas. Alexander Myln, in his 16th century "Vitae Dunkeldensis ecclesiae episcoporum" ("Lives of the Bishops of Dunkeld"), related that after hearing news of Bishop Brown's death, Atholl visited Dunkeld and requested that his brother be made bishop. [Myln, "Vitae Dunkeldensis", pp. 70-1.] As many of the canons were either related by blood to Atholl, or else held lands under Atholl's power, the pressure was significant and Andrew Stewart was accordingly elected to the see.Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 82.] A letter was sent to John Stewart, Duke of Albany, Governor of Scotland and guardian of the young James V of Scotland; Albany was in France and refused to deal with the disposal of any bishopric until his return to the country. When Albany returned in May (still 1515), he subverted Queen Margaret, confirmed the appointment of Andrew and compelled the chapter of Dunkeld to hand over the temporalities of the see. [Watt, "Fasti Ecclesiae", p. 99; Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 82.] In July, the Queen agreed to Andrew Stewart's appointment and Albany imprisoned Douglas for breaking the laws of the kingdom, that is, on account of his purchase of the bishopric at Rome. [Bawcutt, "Douglas, Gavin (c.1476–1522)"; Watt, "Fasti Ecclesiae", p. 99; Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", pp. 82, 83.]

However, Andrew Stewart failed to secure confirmation from the Papacy. Albany gave up his support for Andrew and released Douglas from imprisonment; in September 1516, he agreed to Douglas' accession to the see of Dunkeld. Douglas was consecrated on September 21, 1516. [Watt, "Fasti Ecclesiae", p. 99.] On July 24, 1517, Albany wrote to the Pope requesting that Andrew Stewart be given the now vacant see of Caithness. The Pope agreed, and on December 14, 1517, Andrew Stewart became Bishop of Caithness. [Watt, "Fasti Ecclesiae", p. 61; Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 248.] Thereafter, the sources leave almost no information about Stewart, and his 24-year rule of the diocese of Caithness goes largely undocumented, save only the occasional appearance, such as his attendance at parliament on December 10, 1540. [Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 248, n. 1.] He died intestate some short time before August 9, 1541. [Watt, "Fasti Ecclesiae", p. 61; Dowden, "Bishops of Scotland", p. 2498.]

Notes

References

* Bawcutt, Priscilla J., "Douglas, Gavin (c.1476–1522)", in the "Oxford Dictionary of National Biography", Oxford University Press, 2004 [http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/7882 , accessed 18 Feb 2007]
* Boardman, S. I., "Stewart, John, first earl of Atholl (1440?–1512)", in the "Oxford Dictionary of National Biography", Oxford University Press, 2004 [http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/26486 , accessed 18 Feb 2007]
* Cowan, Ian B., "The Parishes of Medieval Scotland", Scottish Records Society Vol. 93, (Edinburgh, 1967)
* Dowden, John, "The Bishops of Scotland", ed. J. Maitland Thomson, (Glasgow, 1912)
* Myln, Alexander, "Vitae Dunkeldensis ecclesiae episcoporum", ed. T. Thomson, rev. edn, 1, rev. C. Innes, (Bannatyne Club, 1831)
* Watt, D.E.R., "Fasti Ecclesiae Scotinanae Medii Aevi ad annum 1638", 2nd Draft, (St Andrews, 1969)