John Gordon Purvis

John Gordon Purvis Jr. (born 1942) is an innocent man who spent nine years inprison for a murder he did not commit. [ [http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?sec=health&res=9F0CE4DF1F3EF934A25752C0A965958260] "Man Imprisoned 9 Years in Killing Is Freed as 2 Suspects Are Found." New York Times. Published: January 17, 1993. Viewed February 9, 2007.]

Early life

Johnny Purvis was born to John and Emma Jo Purvis in 1942. His father gave his life in theservice of his country on February 20, 1945 with the U.S. Marines on Iwo Jima in World War II.His mother was devastated, and it seemed to have an effect on Johnny, who had physical problemsof his own. At six years old, he would cry and become terrified to go to school and holdhis mother. At school, he always sat near the teacher, and if fights broke out betweenstudents at school he would cry or do his best to avoid them.

As he grew up, he could not keep up with his peers academically and his relationships with girls was shaky at best. A doctor diagnosed him with chronic undifferentiated schizophrenia.He would spend his time watching television or eating out with his mother and stepbrotherMike Bartlett. Occasionally, Johnny would suffer panic attacks. He was known for hisunusual behavior.

The Murder of Susan Hamwi

A lovely woman had moved out to Fort Lauderdale, Florida in July 1983 named Susan Hamwi.She was working on her divorce from her husband Paul Hamwi for his abuse and beating of her.Paul Hamwi was an ex-Vietnam veteran who was known for his drinking and obnoxiousness.Susan's friend, Karen Bebee, urged her not to involve herself with him. But Paul and Susanhad unprotected sex one night and Susan was pregnant. Paul, in marrying Susan, made hersign a pre-nuptial agreement that required him to pay her nothing upon divorce. Shortly afterthe marriage, their daughter Shane was born. Upon the divorce proceedings, the pre-nuptialagreement was declared void, since it was made under duress. Paul was then ordered to paybetween $150,000 and $180,000 to Susan to support their daughter.

Johnny met Susan, hoping to establish friendly contact. He was very unusual, but friendlywith Susan. Susan was bothered to some degree with Johnny's behavior, but not to thepoint of rejecting him altogether.

On November 1, 1983, after a phone call from a friend, Susan was not heard from again.Neighbors began to express concern. On November 8th, 1983, the body of Susan Hamwi was foundat her home, with part of a knife. She had been stabbed and strangled with a phone cord.Shane Hamwi was also found dead from neglect.

Police detectives Rick Rice and Rich Martin of the Fort Lauderdale Police Department interviewed several people. Under great pressure from the media for a suspect in this gruesome murder, they turned to Johnny Purvis, the town "weirdo". They yelled and intimidatedhim at his interrogation and his mother heard it. Johnny was very shaken by the experience,and his mother was determined that he would talk to the police no more. But the detectives,undeterred by the fact that their forensic investigations showed Johnny was not at the crimescene, were determined to make Johnny confess. They picked a time when Johnny was not with hismother and Johnny buckled under pressure and confessed to Susan's murder. Represented byattorney Richard Kirsch, at Johnny's trial the taped confession was declared inadmissible by Judge Thomas Coker. But the jurors were not convinced of Johnny's innocence and declaredhim guilty. He was sentenced to life imprisonment.

A New Investigation

Although attorney Kirsch lost appeals in the courts and Johnny spent time in prison,an Aspen, Colorado detective named Gary White put the first crack in the Hamwi murder,when a woman beaten by Robert Wayne Beckett Jr. said that she'd heard him boast thathis father, Robert Wayne Beckett Sr., had killed a girl in Florida. White rememberedthe Hamwi case and had private detective Barbara Barton assist in checking this out.

Surprisingly, Rick Rice and Rich Martin, who had helped get Johnny convicted, weren't interested in this new lead in the Hamwi case. For years, Johnny languished in prisonbefore two new detectives, Tim Bronson and Bob Williams, were assigned to the homicidesection of the Fort Lauderdale Police Department. They were looking at some old casesand were shocked when they found that detectives Rice and Martin had not investigatedthe Robert Beckett Jr. boast of his father killing a girl in Florida, and the Hamwi investigation was on again. Through the painful and sometimes unwilling cooperationof Robert Wayne Beckett Sr., Beckett admitted to the murder of Susan Hamwi and thatPaul Serio was the other murderer. The baby, Shane Hamwi, had been left neglected.He explained that Paul Hamwi had paid the two of them $14,000 to murder Susan. ["The Wrong Man: A True Story" by Kevin Davis, Avon Books, 1996]

Release

Johnny Purvis was released from custody on January 15th, 1993. But he had his problemspsychologically and had to undergo extensive psychiatric treatment after his release.He continues to live in Florida and the treatment has helped him. A lawsuit against the prosecutor for failing to disclose exculpatory information was dismissed on grounds of "prosecutorial immunity." [ [http://www.google.com/search?q=cache:IlPn5qbVV0cJ:caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl%3Fcourt%3D11th%26navby%3Dcase%26no%3D984669man+%22john+gordon+purvis%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=us] U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. LONG v SATZ. Joanne LONG, as guardian of John Gordon Purvis, incompetent, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Michael SATZ, individually and as State Attorney, for the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, in and for Broward County, Florida, Ralph Ray, Robert Carney, BarbaraBarton, Defendants-Appellees. No. 98-4669. United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit. July 22, 1999. at Findlaw. Viewed Feb. 9, 2007]

References