E. Adamson Hoebel

E. Adamson Hoebel (1906-1993) was Regents Professor Emeritus of anthropology at the University of Minnesota. He held a Ph.D. in anthropology from Columbia University, where he also attended the seminars of Karl N. Llewellyn, who taught at the Columbia Law School from 1925-1951. Llewellyn (1893–1962) was the most important figure associated with the American Legal Realism of the 1920s and 1930s, which held that the law was indeterminate on the basis of statutes and precedents alone and required study of the how disputes are resolved in practice. The ‘sociological’ wing of legal realism championed by Llewellyn held that in American law dispute resolution was strongly influenced by norms such as those in mercantile practice. [ [http://www.utexas.edu/law/faculty/bleiter/LllewellynEncyclopedia.pdf "Karl Nickerson Llewellyn (1893-1962)"] by Brian R. Leiter, 2001, in N. Smelser & P. Baltes (eds.), International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences (New York: Elsevier Science,) Karl Ulrich Meyer, editor, biographies section, pp. 8999-9001.] Llewellyn and Hoebel (1941) [ Llewellyn K., and E. A. Hoebel. 1941 The Cheyenne Way: Conflict and Case Law in Primitive Jurisprudence. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press.] went to on to develop a means of determining legal practice from ethnographic description of trouble cases, including mediation and negotiation as well as adjudication. Their “case study method” applied both to social systems with and without formal courts.

Hoebel taught anthropology for a number of years at New York University and subsequently at the University of Utah, where he was also Dean of the University College (Arts and Sciences). He served as a Fullbright Professor in anthropology at Oxford and law at Catholic University of Leuven. At the University of Minnesota he chaired the Department of Anthropology until his retirement in 1972.

Between 1933 and 1949, Hoebel studied the legal systems of the Northern Cheyenne, Northern Shoshone, Comanche, and Pueblo people, and the legal system of Pakistan in 1961. He was a close friend and colleague of Max Gluckman, founder of the Manchester School of British Social Anthropology. Gluckman, also given to a realist orientation to the study of law, used and further developed Llewellyn that Hoebel's "case study method" of analysis of instances of social interaction to infer rules and assumptions used in trouble cases, and the influence of social norms and conflicts outside the law. The behavioral "case study" approach has continued and expanded in later anthropological works such as Network Analysis and Ethnographic Problems (2005).

In 1954 Hoebel contributed his major book on legal anthropology, on broadening the legal realist tradition to include non-Western nations. In doing so, he concluded with a statement about the need for contributions from the comparative legal realism tradition if progress was to be made toward world governance. Eclipsed by the cold war, even the legal realist concepts of what constitutes law and government have failed to make an impact on Political Science and the concept of the state in the contemporary period. Hoebel's working definition of what is law [Hoebel 1954:28] is worth citing: "A social norm is legal if its neglect or infraction is regularly met, in threat or in fact, by the application of physicial force by an individual or group possessing the socially recognized privilege of so acting." Because "government without law is limited to the administration of services" [Hoebel 1954:332] , one of the implications of the legal realist tradition is that it is not necessarily in the capital city that one must look to define the government of a modern nation but to how the law "will develop its shape in the arena of action," "hammered out as specific issues catalyze action for the trouble case at hand." Hoebel's definition, unlike that of neoconservative thought and its invocation of Leo Strauss for justification of government deception, is that to be legal, law must be based on social norms, and norms on agreements within communities, rather than the dominance of the few.

References

* Hoebel, Adamson E. 1954. The Law of Primitive Man. Harvard, MA: Atheneum.
* Hoebel, Adamson E. 1978. The Cheyennes. Belmont CA:Wadsworth Group/Thomson Learning.
* [http://www.amphilsoc.org/library/mole/h/hoebel.htm E. Adamson Hoebel Papers 1925-1983]

Footnotes