Reisner Papyrus

Reisner Papyrus

The Reisner Papyrus is one of the most basic of the hieratic mathematical texts. It was found in 1904 by George Reisner. It dates to the 1800 BCE period and was translated close to its historical form of remainder arithmetic in association with the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. Gillings and other scholars accepted 100 year old views of this document, with several of the views being incomplete and misleading. Two of the documents, reported in Tables 22.2 and 22.2, a detail a division by 10 method, a method that also appears in the Rhind Mathematical Papyrus. Labor efficiencies were monitored by applying this method. For example, how deep did 10 workmen dig in one day as calculated in the Reisner Papyrus, and by Ahmes 150 years later? In addition, the methods used in the Reisner and RMP to convert vulgar fractions to unit fraction series look similar to the conversion methods used in the Egyptian Mathematical Leather Roll.

Overview

Gillings repeated a common and incomplete view of the Reisner Papyrus. He analyzed lines G10, from table 22.3B, and line 17 from Table 22.2 on page 221, in the "Mathematics in the Time of the Pharaohs", citing these Reisner Papyrus facts:

divide 39 by 10 = 4,

a poor approximation to the correct value, reported Gillings.

Gillings fairly reported that the scribe should have stated the problem and data as:

39/10 = (30 + 9)/10 = 3 + 1/2 + 1/3 + 1/15

Yet, all other the division by 10 problems and answers were correctly stated, points that Gillings did not stress. Table 22.2 data described the work done in the Eastern Chapel. Additional raw data was listed on lines G5, G6/H32, G14, G15, G16, G17/H33 and G18/H34, as follows:

12/10 = 1 + 1/5 (G5)

10/10 = 1 (G6 & H32)

8/10 = 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/20 (G14)

48/10 = 4 + 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/20 (G15)

16/10 = 1 + 1/2 + 1/10 (G16)

64/10 = 6 + 1/4 + 1/10 + 1/20 (G17 & H33)

36/10 = 3 + 1/2 + 1/10 (G18 & H34)

Chace and Shute had noted the Reisner Papyrus division by 10 method, also applied in the RMP. Chace, nor Shute, clearly cite the quotients and remainders that were used by Ahmes. Other additive scholars have also muddled the reading the first 6 problems of the Rhind Mathematical Papyrus, missing its use of quotient and remainders.

Gillings, Chace and Shute apparently had not analyzed the RMP data in a broader context, and reported its older structure, thereby missing a major fragment of Akhmim Wooden Tablet and Reisner Papyrus remainder arithmetic. That is, Gillings' citation in the Reisner and RMP documented in the "Mathematics in the Time of the Pharaohs" only scratched the surface of scribal arithmetic. Had scholars dug a little deeper, academics may have found 80 years ago other reasons for the Reisner Papyrus 39/10 error.

The Reisner Papyrus error may have been noted by Gillings as using quotients (Q) and remainders (R). Ahmes used quotients and remainders in the RMP's first six problems. Gillings may have forgotten to summarize his findings in a rigorous manner, showing that several Middle Kingdom texts had used quotients and remainders.

Seen in a broader sense the Reisner Papyrus data should be noted as:

39/10 = (Q' + R)/10 with Q' = (Q*10), Q = 3 and R = 9

such that:

39/10 = 3 + 9/10 = 3 + 1/2 + 1/3 + 1/15

with 9/10 being converted to a unit fraction series following rules set down in the AWT, and followed in RMP and other texts.

Confirmation of the scribal remainder arithmetic is found in other hieratic texts. The most important text is the Akhmim Wooden Tablet. The AWT defines scribal remainder arithmetic in term of another context, a hekat (volume unit). Oddly, Gillings did not cite AWT data in "Mathematics in the Time of the Pharaohs". Gillings and the earlier 1920's scholars had missed a major opportunity to point out a multiple use of scribal remainder arithmetic built upon quotient and remainders.

The modern looking remainder arithmetic was later found by others by taking a broader view of the 39/10 error, as corrected as the actual Eastern Chapel data reports.

Gillings and the academic community therefore had inadvertently omitted a critically important discussion of fragments of remainder airthmetic. Remainder arithmetic, as used in many ancient cultures to solve astronomy and time problems, is one of several plausible historical division methods that may have allowed a full restoration of scribal division around 1906.

In summary, the Reisner Papyri was built upon a method described in the Akhmim Wooden Tablet, and later followed by Ahmes writing the RMP. The Reisner calculations apparently follows our modern Occam's Razor rule, that the simplest method was the historical method; in this case remainder arithmetic, such that:

n/10 = Q + R/10

where Q was a quotient and R was a remainder.

The Reisner, following this Occam's Razor rule, says that 10 workmen units were used to divide raw data using a method that was defined in the text, a method that also begins the Rhind Mathematical Papyrus, as noted in its first six problems.

References

* Chace, Arnold Buffum. 1927-1929. "The Rhind Mathematical Papyrus: Free Translation and Commentary with Selected Photographs, Translations, Transliterations and Literal Translations". Classics in Mathematics Education 8. 2 vols. Oberlin: Mathematical Association of America. (Reprinted Reston: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 1979). ISBN 0-87353-133-7

* Gillings, Richard J., "Mathematics in the Time of the Pharaohs", Dover, New York, 1971, ISBN 0-480-24515-X
* Robins, R. Gay, and Charles C. D. Shute. 1987. "The Rhind Mathematical Papyrus: An Ancient Egyptian Text". London: British Museum Publications Limited. ISBN 0-7141-0944-4

See also

* Boston Museum of Fine Arts

External links

*http://mathworld.wolfram.com/AkhmimWoodenTablet.html

* cite web
authorlink = Eric W. Weisstein
title = Rhind Papyrus
publisher = MathWorld–A Wolfram Web Resource
url = http://mathworld.wolfram.com/RhindPapyrus.html

* http://egyptianmath.blogspot.com


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Reisner — is a surname of Germanic origin. *Charles Reisner (1887 1952) American actor and film director *George Andrew Reisner (1867 1942) American archaeologist *Marc Reisner American environmentalist *Reisner Papyrus related to egyptology and George… …   Wikipedia

  • Papyrus Hearst — Der Papyrus Hearst ist ein altägyptischer medizinischer Papyrus. Er enthält viele Parallelen zum Papyrus Ebers, jedoch auch Rezepte gegen neue, zum Teil unbekannte Krankheiten wie z.B. die „Asiaten Krankheit“ (Lepra oder Beulenpest) …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Reisner — Reisner,   1) [ raɪsnə], George Andrew, amerikanischer Ägyptologe, * Indianapolis (Indiana) 5. 11. 1867, ✝ Giseh 6. 6. 1942; trat besonders durch seine methodischen Grabungen in Giseh (seit 1903) und Kerma hervor. Er leitete 1907 09 die… …   Universal-Lexikon

  • Papyrus Hearst — Le papyrus Hearst est un papyrus médical datant de la XVIIIe dynastie, aux alentours des règnes de Thoutmôsis III ou Amenhotep II mais il aurait été composé plus tôt, au cours du Moyen Empire, vers 2000. Lors de sa découverte au printemps… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Reisner, George Andrew — ▪ American archaeologist born , Nov. 5, 1867, Indianapolis, Ind., U.S. died June 6, 1942, Cairo       U.S. archaeologist who directed many excavations in Egypt and Nubia (Nilotic Sudan) and discovered the tomb of Queen Hetepheres, mother of King… …   Universalium

  • Reisner Papyri —    Four papyrus rolls discovered in a tomb at Nag el Deirby George Reisnerin 1904. These date to the Middle Kingdom and the reign of Amenemhat I or Senusret I and describe administrative projects. Historical Dictionary Of Ancient Egypt by Morris… …   Ancient Egypt

  • Hearst papyrus — The Hearst Papyrus, also called the Hearst Medical Papyrus , is one of the medical papyri of ancient Egypt. It was named after the mother of press magnate William Randolph Hearst. The papyrus contains 18 pages of medical prescriptions written in… …   Wikipedia

  • George Andrew Reisner — Infobox Scientist name = George Andrew Reisner box width = image size =150px caption =George Andrew Reisner (1867 1942) birth date = November 5, 1867 birth place = Indianapolis, Indiana death date = June 6, 1942 death place = Giza, Egypt… …   Wikipedia

  • George Andrew Reisner — Pour les articles homonymes, voir Reisner. George Andrew Reisner Égyptologue Pays de naissance …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Egyptian mathematics — refers to the style and methods of mathematics performed in Ancient Egypt.IntroductionEgyptian multiplication and division employed the method of doubling and halving (respectively) a known number to approach the solution. The method of false… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”