Winograd Commission

:"For other Winograd Commissions, see Eliyahu Winograd."The Winograd Commission ( _he. ועדת וינוגרד; the commission's official name is הוועדה לבדיקת ארועי המערכה בלבנון 2006 - "The commission of inquiry into the events of military engagement in Lebanon 2006") is an Israeli government-appointed commission of inquiry, chaired by retired judge Eliyahu Winograd, which investigated and drew lessons from the Second Lebanon War. The Committee had its first plenary session on September 18, 2006 and began summoning and hearing testimonies from witnesses on November 2 of that year. On April 30, 2007 the Commission released its preliminary report, harshly criticizing key decision-makers. At the same time, it has been praised as testimony to the fortitude of Israel's democracy and ability to self-criticize, [ [http://www.idi.org.il/english/article.asp?id=07052007123937 Main Issues in the Interim Report of the Winograd Commission] , Israel Democracy Institute] [Scott MacLeod. [http://www.yallakadima.co.il/article.asp?item_id=3138 What the Winograd Report Means for America] 03.05.07] [cite news|url=http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1617645,00.html|title=Why Olmert Is Hanging On|author=Andrew Lee Butters|publisher="Time"|date=May 4, 2007] [cite news|url=http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/05/02/opinion/edisrael.php|title=A harsh, healthy verdict on Israel's war in Lebanon|publisher="The New York Times" via the "International Herald Tribune"|date=May 2, 2007] [cite news|url=http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/0,1518,480587,00.html|title='Olmert's Fight For Survival Is Hopeless'|publisher="Der Spiegel"|date=May 2, 2007] [cite news|url=http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2007/03/three_cheers_for_israeli_democ.html|author=Caroline Glick|publisher="RealClearPolitics"|title=Three Cheers for Israeli Democracy|date=March 10, 2007] [cite news|url=http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/rosnerGuest.jhtml?itemNo=859470|title=Rosner's Guest|author=Leon Botstein|publisher="Haaretz"|date=May 14, 2007] [cite news|url=http://www.guysen.com/articles.php?sid=5778|title=France, Israel: Vive La Democratie!|author=Guy Senbel|publisher="Guysen Israel News"|date=2007-05-05] impressing even Hezbollah leader Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah. [cite news|url=http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1178708583739&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FPrinter|title=Nasrallah praises Israel's investigation of war|publisher="Jerusalem Post"|date=May 12, 2007] [cite news|url=http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/855057.html|title=Nasrallah praises Winograd report; Siniora: No mention of destruction in Lebanon|publisher="Haaretz"|date=May 2, 2007] The final Winograd Commission report was announced in Binyanei HaUma in Jerusalem on January 30, 2008.

Background

The Israeli public, press, and parliament supported the war against Hezbollah as a legitimate response to an attack on sovereign Israeli territory and a long overdue reaction to rocket attacks on northern Israel, but they questioned its implementation.

Israelis have been debating the war since it was concluded. Critics note that the kidnapped soldiers were not rescued and that Hezbollah is rearming and has been strengthened politically. The government claims success in forcing Hezbollah from the border, in degrading its arms, and in pressuring the Lebanese government, aided by international forces, to assert itself in south Lebanon. Israeli officials took Hezbollah leader Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah’s admission that he would not have authorized the July 12 action if he had known how strongly Israel would react as confirmation that the group had been weakened and that Israel’s deterrence had been strengthened. [ [http://fpc.state.gov/documents/organization/84932.pdf Israel: Background and Relations with the United States] , Congressional Research Service]

During the war the Israeli government provided insufficient material support, including necessities, to the Home Front population of about one million people in northern Israel who were instructed to remain in shelters for much of the war's duration. Government support networks were not activated or were inadequately run. Much of the burden to care for vulnerable populations was left to individual volunteers and charities. The conditions of, and access to, shelters were often substandard and government assistance to northern Israelis in transportation and accommodations in central and southern Israel was highly lacking. Government inaction caused the weakest segments of Israeli society in affected areas to suffer the worst of the day-to-day privations. [ [http://www.reliefweb.int/rw/RWB.NSF/db900SID/VBOL-6SCGZE?OpenDocument&rc=3&cc=isr "Northern Israel exodus leaves old, weak and poor to face rockets"] , "OCHA", August 4, 2006] [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/765525.html "Poll: Most residents of north stayed in north during Lebanon war"] , "Haaretz", September 21, 2006] [ [http://www.forward.com/articles/the-israeli-new-orleans%E2%80%99/ "'The Israeli New Orleans': Charities, Pols Slam Failures in North"] , "The Jewish Daily Forward", September 29, 2006]

On the military front there were tactical, operative and logistic failures, including the flow of intelligence. [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/855170.html "'The intelligence didn't reach the troops'"] , "Haaretz", May 6, 2007] Many Israeli commanders and troops were ill-prepared and ill-trained to meet the combat conditions, in particular, with respect to Hezbollah's use of portable antitank weapons, such as the 9К115-2 Metis-M. Unlike in Gaza and the West Bank, troops inside armor, [ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4794829.stm "Tough lessons for Israeli armour"] , "BBC", August 15, 2006] or taking shelter in houses, became highly vulnerable to these weapons, which led to the majority of Israeli military casualties in the war. As well, with the mobilization of reserve divisions, a host of logistical failures, such as ordnance and food shortages, [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/750463.html IDF: Logistics chief didn't say looting of Lebanese shops okay] , "Haaretz", August 15, 2006] began affecting reserve soldiers.

A key strategic question relates to the controversial decision to launch full-scale warfare in response to the abduction of two individual soldiers and killing of eight soldiers in the process. [It is highly unusual —possibly unique in military history— for a nation to mobilize and engage whole divisions or brigades in response to the death, injury, or abduction of individual soldiers, as was the case with the kidnapping of Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev which led to the war, and a few months earlier, with the kidnapping of Gilad Shalit which led to the 2006 Israel-Gaza conflict.]

After the war, increasing public criticism and protest over these issues was placed on Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, especially to have him call for the establishment of a Supreme Court-appointed state commission of inquiry to look at all levels of government and the military (including the prime minister and chief of staff).

For a time it was unclear which of the three areas —cabinet, military, and civilian homefront— would be investigated by whom, and how. On August 28, Olmert announced the creation of a governmental inspection probe led by former director of Mossad Nahum Admoni; it became the prototype for the Winograd Commission. A military inspection probe, led by former Chief of Staff, Amnon Lipkin-Shahak which on August 22 ceased work after five days of operations due to increasing public dissatisfaction and calls for a state commission, was also set to be renewed. Olmert hinted that the State Comptroller would examine the civilian homefront, to the public consternation of the latter. [ [http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3297041,00.html "State Comptroller: Don't need PM's authorization to probe war"] , "Ynetnews", August 29, 2006] [ [http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1154525966957&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull "PMO 'amazed' at comptroller's public complaints"] , "Jerusalem Post", August 29, 2006] In response to these growing criticisms, Olmert chose to replace Admoni with retired judge Eliyahu Winograd as chair of the governmental inspection probe (with Olmert thereby responding to calls that any leading commission or probe needs to be headed by a retired judge); the probe itself, turned into a commission with a wider mandate, amounting to near-equal authority to a state commission. [ [http://www.haaretz.co.il/hasite/spages/761407.html "Winograd will head the inspection commission; Sheetrit: I'll ensure that the commission "will have teeth"] , "Haaretz", September 11, 2006 he icon]

Authority and operation

The commission has the same mandate as a state commission, except that its members were not appointed by the Supreme Court and that its recommendations, especially with respect to resignations, may not possess the same legal weight. [According to the government, it is to "operate autonomously and independently," has the authority to subpoena witnesses, may "recommend prosecution of any Israeli public official whom it finds was involved with willful or negligent criminal behavior," and is "to make recommendations that will resonate in the public domain in Israel." ( [http://israelbehindthenews.com/Archives/Sep-16-06.htm "Israel Forms Panel To Examine 'Ill Preparedness'] ). On September 18, Israel's Attorney General Menachem Mazuz stated that while the commission "'may make its recommendations public, it cannot recommend to the authority who appointed it [PM Ehud Olmert] to step down.'" ( [http://www.israelnationalnews.com/news.php3?id=112281 "Winograd Committee Cannot Oust PM"] ) ] During its first week, the commission somewhat controversially engaged in preliminary meetings with top decision makers (including Olmert) who were later to be summoned as witnesses. For the next several weeks, the commission studied material and worked to decide on the direction of its investigation. On November 2, it began hearing testimonies from witnesses, beginning with the head of the Israel National Emergency Economic Authority, Brigadier-General (res.) Arnon Ben-Ami, who was asked why the Authority failed to be activated during the war despite repeated calls to do so. [ [http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3322954,00.html "Winograd Commission: First day of testimonies finished"] , "Ynetnews", November 2, 2006] On November 4, it met in a closed session to hear testimonies by outgoing head of the Directorate of Military Intelligence Amos Yadlin. On November 7, the commission heard testimonies from Vice Prime Minister Shimon Peres and from Director-general of the Ministry of Defense Gabi Ashkenazi.

On February 6, 2007, the Israeli High Court of Justice ruled against Meretz MK Zehava Galon's petition. She had petitioned the court to force the commission to hold public meetings and publish minutes, even before the preliminary report was to be published. The ruling was given after the commission had completed hearing testimonies behind closed doors. The High Court decided that "the Winograd Commission had a duty to permit exposure of the content of its deliberations, and the evidence presented to the commission, as much as possible, without harming the security or other national interests of the first degree." [ [http://elyon1.court.gov.il/Files/07/580/002/n05/07002580.n05.HTM HCJ 258/07 MK Zehava Galon v. The Governmental Commission of Inquiry for the Examination of the Events of the War in Lebanon 2006 he icon] ] As a result of the ruling the commission put up a website [ [http://www.vaadatwino.co.il/ Winograd Commission website] he icon] on March 23 2007, where the testimonies are to be published (as of now only testimonies by only three witnesses are available: Shimon Peres, Major-General (Res.) Amos Malka, and Brigadier-General (Res.) Arnon Ben Ami). Also available on the website is other information regarding the commission's activity put out by the commission.

Preliminary report

On March 13, 2007, the commission announced it would publish a preliminary report in the second half of April, which included personal recommendations regarding Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, then Minister of Defense Amir Peretz, and the IDF Chief of Staff during the war, Dan Halutz.

On April 28, 2007, Israel's Channel Ten nightly news edition leaked information from the preliminary report. The leaked copy reportedly criticized Olmert for having no "organized plan" in launching the war and called his move "misguided and rash judgment". The commission also accused Olmert, who lacks significant military experience, of not consulting the military leadership enough, and authorizing operations without input from other sources. It further criticized Olmert for failing to foresee the possible outcomes of the war. On Israeli Channel 2's news, the report was quoted as saying that Olmert had "failed" in his duty during the war. Nevertheless, according to Channel Ten, the report did not go so far as to call for the Prime Minister's dismissal. [ [http://www.nytimes.com/reuters/world/international-israel-lebanon-probe.html Olmert Won't Quit Over War Report] ]

Channel 2 also reported that the preliminary report also criticizes Peretz and Halutz, saying the Minister of Defense had failed, and that Halutz possessed "over-charisma", preventing the government from asking him to present alternatives to his plans for the war. [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/853221.html Winograd committee: We won't call for resignations, let the public decide - Haaretz - Israel News ] ]

The report, covering the years leading up to the war (2000-2006) as well as the first few days of the war (July 12-July 17), was released on April 30, 2007, and contained serious criticisms of Prime Minister Olmert, Defence Minister Amir Peretz and Chief of Staff Dan Halutz. [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/853705.html Lebanon war probe accuses Olmert of 'serious failure,' blasts Halutz, Peretz] , Haaretz, 30/4/07]

Nevertheless, Peretz has tried to spin the report's findings in his favor, saying the report shows he "displayed understanding that more experienced people had not shown and that he need not resign immediately," [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/854633.html Peretz: Findings show I needn't quit] ] despite the fact that the report quite clearly found that Peretz's "serving as Minister of Defense during the war impaired Israel's ability to respond well to its challenges." [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/854051.html The main findings of the Winograd partial report on the Second Lebanon War] ]

Many public figures have since called upon Olmert and Peretz to resign. Notable among them is Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni. [ [http://haaretz.com/hasen/spages/854673.html Livni: Olmert must resign; opposes fresh elections] ] [ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6616429.stm Olmert should go, Israeli FM says] , BBC, Wednesday, 2 May 2007, 16:58 GMT] The PM has refused to resign claiming Israel needs stability at this stage, and that new elections would be disruptive. Also in criticism of Olmert, Avigdor Yitzhaki, head of the Kadima faction and coalition chairman has resigned in light of Olmert's refusal to step down. [ [http://haaretz.com/hasen/spages/855056.html Yitzhaki quits as coalition chair after ultimatum to Olmert] ] [ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6614161.stm Israel cabinet in emergency talks] , BBC, Wednesday, 2 May 2007, 11:22 GMT]

Livni's post was the topic of one of the only positive comments in the report. The commission noted that "that from the first few days of the war it prepared the diplomatic ground that led to Security Council Resolution 1701 that brought a cease-fire." [ [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/854642.html Foreign ministry lauded for diplomatic role in war] ]

On May 3,2007, three days after the release of the preliminary report, the Knesset held an extraordinary session to debate the report's findings. Opposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu called for Olmert to resign, but Kadima MPs supported the prime minister and a vote of no-confidence was not held. [ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6618193.stm Olmert survives war report debate] , BBC, Thursday, 3 May 2007, 15:57 GMT] Later that day, tens of thousands of protesters gathered at Rabin Square in Tel Aviv, calling on Olmert and his government to resign. [ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6621337.stm Israelis call on Olmert to resign] , BBC, Thursday, 3 May 2007, 20:12 GMT] [ [http://www.observer-reporter.com/OR/Story/05_04_ISRAEL_WAR_INQUIRY_10 "Protesters call on Israel's Olmert to quit over Lebanon war failures"] , "Associated Press", May 6, 2007] On May 4, an IBA poll showed that nearly 80 percent favour Olmert's resignation. [http://switch3.castup.net/cunet/gm.asp?ai=31&ar=yoman "Yoman"] , "Israel Broadcasting Authority", May 4, 2007 he icon]

Members

Commission members as of September 18, 2006, include:
*Chair: Justice (ret.) Eliyahu Winograd
*Law Professor Ruth Gavison
*Political Science Professor Yehezkel Dror
*Aluf (ret.) Menachem Einan
*Aluf (ret.) Chaim Nadel

Notes

External links

* [http://www.vaadatwino.org.il/ "Official website of the Winograd Commission"]
** [http://www.vaadatwino.org.il/pdf/%E3%E5%E7%20%F1%E5%F4%E9.pdf (Hebrew) The final Winograd Commission report]
* [http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Communiques/2006/Establishment%20of%20the%20Winograd%20Committee%2014-Sep-2006 "Establishment of the Winograd Committee"] (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs)
* [http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/winogradreport-04302007.pdf Official English summary of the Winograd's panel interim report] Press Release (via "The Wall Street Journal" [PDF] ), via [http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1177591165908&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull "The Jerusalem Post"]
* [http://www.omedia.org/Show_Article.asp?DynamicContentID=2234&MenuID=608&ThreadID=1014011 "Second Winograd War" - on the power Struggles Behind the Committee]
* [http://www.vaadatwino.org.il/pdf/press%20release%20april%2030-yd-final.pdf "Report of the Main Findings of the Winograd Commission"]
* [http://www.omedia.org/Show_Article.asp?DynamicContentID=2270&MenuID=608&ThreadID=1014011 The Winograd Report: The Political Arena]
* [http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1178198606909&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull Editor's Notes: A searing indictment, by Jerusalem Post Editor, David Horovitz]
* [http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1178708563842&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull In Washington: Winograd cracks the ice] MJ Rosenberg, "Jerusalem Post" May 9, 2007
* [http://www.pasadenastarnews.com/opinions/ci_5865826 Thomas Friedman: Hezbollah win negated by Israel's strength]
* [http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/11/world/middleeast/11mideast.html Israel’s Bombing of Civilians Extended War, Olmert Told Panel] by Steven Erlanger, "New York Times" May 11, 2007
* [http://www.stljewishlight.com/commentaries/288841994282666.php Olmert's Troubles Test Israel's Democracy]
* [http://www.fortwayne.com/mld/newssentinel/news/editorial/17180819.htm In aftermath of bungled war, Israel embraces culture of criticism] Dion Nissenbaum
* From the Israel Democracy Institute
** [http://www.idi.org.il/english/article.asp?id=26042007090945 The Winograd Commission]
** [http://www.idi.org.il/english/article.asp?id=07052007123937 Main Issues in the Interim Report of the Winograd Commission]
* [http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1178096596335&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull Lessons of Winograd] by Shlomo Avineri, "Jerusalem Post" May 2, 2007
* [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/856117.html Winograd report prompts Lebanese to question Hezbollah] by Yoav Stern, "Haaretz" May 5, 2007
* [http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3401426,00.html Minister Yishai says supported war in solidarity] Aviram Zino, "Ynetnews" 05.17.07