Lanthanide triflates

Lanthanide triflates are triflate salts of the lanthanide family with many uses in organic chemistry as Lewis acid catalysts. The catalysts act similar to aluminium chloride or ferric chloride, but are stable in water, which makes it possible to use water as solvent insted of organic solvents.

Molecular structure

Lanthanide triflates consist of a lanthanide metal ion and three triflate ions. The lanthanides, or rare earth metals, are the elements from Lanthanum to Lutetium in the periodic table. Triflate is a contraction of trifluoromethanesulfonate; its molecular formula is CF₃SO₃, and is commonly designated ‘OTf’. Triflic acid is a ‘superacid’ so its conjugate base ions are very stable. The metal triflate complex is strongly electrophilic, thus acts as a strong Lewis acid.

Lewis acid catalysis

Lewis acids are used to catalyse a wide variety of reactions. The mechanism steps are:Fact|date=January 2008
# Lewis acid forms a polar coordinate with a basic site on the reactant (such as an O or N)
# Its electrons are drawn towards the catalyst, thus activating the reactant
# The reactant is then able to be transformed by a substitution reaction or addition reaction
# The product dissociates and catalyst is regenerated

Common Lewis acids include aluminium chloride, ferric chloride and boron trifluoride. These reactions are usually carried out in organic solvents; AlCl₃, for example, reacts violently with water. Typical solvents are dichloromethane and benzene.

Example Reactions

Friedel-Crafts Reactions

Lanthanide triflates can replace conventional Lewis acids in various types of reactions. One important class is Friedel-Crafts acylations and alkylations, which are one of few ways to add C-C bonds to aromatics. The synthesized products are used in many products including pharmaceuticals and agrochemicals.

These reactions are usually carried out with AlCl₃ as the catalyst, in an organic solvent. In the acylation reaction, AlCl₃ complexes with the product. It must be added in large excess and is destroyed during product recovery, so atom efficiency is poor. The reaction is quenched with water, creating large volumes of corrosive aluminous, acidic waste- 3 mol HCl per mol AlCl₃. In one example, Clark et al. estimate 0.9kg of AlCl₃ is wasted per kilogram of dimethyl acetophenone produced. Product separation can also be difficult.cite book | author = Clark, J.; Macquarie, D. | year = 2002 | title = Handbook of Green Chemistry & Technology | publisher = Blackwell Science | location = Oxford, UK | isbn = 0632057157]

Lanthanide triflates can dramatically cut the impact of these syntheses. They are able to achieve high conversion using small quantities. These catalysts are stable in water, so avoid the need for organic solvents; some reaction rates are even enhanced by aqueous systems. They don’t complex with products, so separation is simple, and the catalyst is easily recovered- in many cases the solution is simply reused.

La(OTf)₃ catalysts can also reduce the number of processing steps and use greener reagents; Walker et al. reported successful acylation yields using carboxylic acid directly, rather than acyl chloride.Walker, M., Balshi, M., Lauster, A., & Birmingham, P. 2000, “An Environmentally Benign Process for Friedel-Crafts Acylation”, 4th Annual Green Chemistry Conference & Proceedings, National Academy of Sciences, Washington US] Their process generates only a small volume of aqueous sodium bicarbonate waste. Similar results have been cited for the direct acetylation of alcohols.cite journal | author = Barrett, A.; Braddock, D. | year = 1997 | title = Scandium(III) or Lanthanide(III) Triflates as Recyclable Catalysts for the Direct Acetylation of Alcohols with Acetic Acid | journal = Chem. Commun. | volume = 1997 | pages = 351–352 | doi = 10.1039/a606484a]

Other C-C bond-forming reactions

La(OTf)₃ catalysts have been used for many other carbon-carbon bond forming reactions, such as Diels-Alder, aldol, and allylation reactions.Engberts, J., Feringa, B., Keller, E. & Otto, S. 1996, “Lewis-acid Catalysis of Caron Carbon Bond Forming Reactions in Water”, Recuil des Travaux Chimiques des Pays-Bas 115(11-12), 457-464] Some reactions require a mixed solvent, such as aqueous formaldehyde, although Kobeyashi et al. have developed alternative surfactant-water systems.

Michael additions are another very important industrial method for creating new carbon-carbon bonds, often with particular functional groups attached. Addition reactions are inherently atom efficient, so are preferred synthesis pathways. La(OTf)₃ catalysts not only enable these reactions to be carried out in water, but can also achieve asymmetric catalysis, yielding a desired enantio-specific or diastereo-specific product.

C-N bond-forming reactions

Lewis acids are also used to catalyse many C-N bond-forming reactions. Pyridine compounds are common in biology and have many applications. Normally, pyridine is synthesized from acetaldehyde, formaldehyde and ammonia under high temperatures and pressures. Lanthanide triflates can be used to synthesize pyridine by catalysing either the condensation of aldehydes and amines, or the aza Diels-Alder reaction catalytic synthesis. Again, water can be used as a solvent, and high yields can be achieved under mild conditions. [cite journal | journal = Chemtech | year = 1999 | volume = 29 | issue = 2 | pages = 23–29 | url = http://pubs.acs.org/hotartcl/chemtech/99/feb/lanth.html | author = Wenhua Xie; Yafei Jin; Peng George Wang | title = ENABLING SCIENCE: Lanthanide triflates as unique Lewis acids]

Nitro compounds are common in pharmaceuticals, explosives, dyes, and plastics. As for carbon compounds, catalysed Michael additions and aldol reactions can be used. For aromatic nitro compounds, synthesis is via a substitution reaction. The standard synthesis is carried out in a solution of nitric acid, mixed with excess sulfuric acid to create nitronium ions. These are then substituted on to the aromatic species. Often, the para-isomer is the desired product, but standard systems have poor selectivity. As for acylation, the reaction is normally quenched with water, and creates copious acidic waste. Using a La(OTf)₃ catalyst in place of sulfuric acid reduces this waste considerably. Clark et al. report 90% conversion using just 1 mol% of ytterbium triflate in weak nitric acid, generating only a small volume of acidic waste.

La(OTf)₃ catalysts have also been used for cyanations, and three-component reactions of aldehydes, amines & nucleophiles.

Advantages

The substitution of organic solvents by water reduces the amount of wast and the metals are recoverable and hence reusable.

Generally, the benefits of these catalysts include:Fact|date=January 2008

* Selective, often producing fewer by-products than standard methods
* Asymmetric catalysts: chiral forms can be highly diastereo- and enantio-selective
* Some reactions can use greener non-chlorinated reagents, and reduce the number of synthesis steps
* Less toxic and not corrosive, so safer and easier to handle
* Mild reaction conditions are safer and reduce energy consumption.

Green catalysts

Lanthanide triflates are one of the most promising green chemistry catalysts. Unlike most conventional catalysts, these compounds are stable in water, so avoid the need for organic solvents, and can be recovered for reuse. Since leading researcher Kobayashi’s 1991 paper [cite journal
title = Asymmetric Aldol Reaction between Achiral Silyl Enol Ethers and Achiral Aldehydes by use of a Chiral Promoter System
author = Kobayashi, S.; Uchiro, H.; Fujishita, Y.; Shiina, I.; Mukaiyama, T.
journal = J. Am. Chem. Soc.
volume = 113
issue =11
pages = 4247–4252
year = 1991 | doi = 10.1021/ja00011a030] on their catalytic effect in water, the range of researched applications for La(OTf)₃ catalysts has exploded.cite journal | author = Kobayashi, S.; Manabe, K. | year = 2000 | title = Green Lewis Acid Catalysts in Organic Synthesis | journal = Pure Appl. Chem. | volume = 72 | issue = 7 | pages = 1373–1380 | doi = 10.1351/pac200072071373] The commercialisation of these techniques has the potential to significantly reduce the environmental impact of the chemical industries.

Disadvantages

The main disadvantages of these new catalysts compared with conventional ones are less industrial experience, reduced availability and increased purchase cost. As they contain rare metals and sulfonate ions, the production of these catalysts may itself be a polluting or hazardous process. For example, metal extraction usually requires large quantities of sulfuric acid. Since the catalyst is recoverable, these disadvantages would be less over time, and the cost savings from reduced waste treatment and better product separation may be substantially greater.

One vendor MSDS lists safety considerations including dermal/eye/respiratory/GI burns on contact. It also lists possible hazardous decomposition products including CO, CO₂, HF and SO_x. [Fisher Scientific 2006, Acros Organics Catalog, Fisher Scientific International] The compounds are hygroscopic, so care is required for storage and handling. However, these considerations also apply to the more common catalysts.

These possible disadvantages are difficult to quantify, as essentially all public domain publications on their use are by research chemists, and do not include Life Cycle Analysis or budgetary considerations. Future work in these areas would greatly encourage their uptake by industry.

Recent developments

Researchers are continually finding new applications where it can replace other less efficient, more toxic Lewis acids. Recently it has been tested in curing epoxies and other polymerisation reactions, and in polysaccharide synthesis. It has also been trialled in green solvents other than water, such as ionic liquids and supercritical carbon dioxide. To enhance recovery, researchers have developed La(OTf)₃ catalysts stabilised by ion exchange resin or polymer backbones, which can be separated by ultrafiltration. Solvent-free systems are also possible with solid-supported catalysts.

References