Initiative 920

Initiative 920 (I-920) was a highly controversial campaign to repeal the estate tax in the U.S. state of Washington. directs that revenues collected from the estate tax be placed into the Education Legacy Trust account, which funds financial aid for higher education. The initiative failed, with 33.54 percent voting for and 66.46 percent against. [ [http://www.metrokc.gov/elections/200611/resPage1.htm King County Election Results ] ]

upporters

The campaign to get I-920 on the ballot was primarily bankrolled by Martin Selig, a Seattle skyscraper developer, and Dennis Falk, a wealthy former Seattle police officer. Falk’s involvement has been particularly controversial. Falk leads the John Birch Society. In 1978, Falk co-chaired Save Our Moral Ethics, an unsuccessful campaign to repeal a law barring housing and employment discrimination against gays and lesbians. [ [http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/273376_estatewash09.html Repeal of estate tax has wealthy backers ] ]

Supporters of I-920 claim the estate tax is an unfair burden on small business. They claim that if small businesses leave Washington, support for local schools will be eroded. They also contend that the 2005 legislature’s decision to renew the estate tax contradicted I-402, which was passed in 1981. [ [http://www.yeson920.com/article7.asp] ]

Groups supporting I-920 include:

* Associated Builders and Contractors of Western Washington
* Association of Washington Business (AWB)
* Centralia-Chehalis Chamber of Commerce
* D.A. Burns & Sons
* Frank Gurney, Inc.
* GM Nameplate
* Greater Seattle Chamber of Commerce

Opponents

Criticism of I-920 has focused on two main points. First, critics argue that the estate tax is the most efficient way to raise revenue for education and that repealing the tax will compromise educational infrastructure, especially for the poor. Second, critics point out that the tax is graduated and therefore only impacts those most able to pay. They argue that the proponents of I-920 have used the rhetoric of small business interests to create tax breaks for the extremely wealthy. Family farms, for example, are completely exempt from the estate tax. Last year, the Washington Estate Tax affected only 250 of the wealthiest estates. [ [http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/opinion/273621_college13.html I-920 hurts higher education ] ]

Groups opposing I-920 include:

* American Federation of Teachers of Washington
* Children's Alliance
* First Place
* International Union of Operating Engineers — Local 609
* League of Education Voters
* League of Women Voters
* Lutheran Public Policy Office of Washington State
* Martin Luther King, Jr. County Labor Council, AFL-CIO
* Pierce County Human Services Coalition
* Public School Employees of Washington
* Retired Public Employees Council of Washington
* SEIU #925
* Statewide Poverty Action Network
* Tax Right
* Washington Association of Churches
* Washington Community Action Network
* Washington Education Association
* Washington State Labor Council
* Washington State NOW
* Washington State Parent Teacher Association
* Washington Tax Fairness Coalition

Results

External links

* [http://www.secstate.wa.gov/elections/initiatives/text/i920.pdf Full text of I-920]
* [http://www.ofm.wa.gov/initiatives/920.asp OFM report on potential financial impact of I-920]
* [http://www.seattleweekly.com/news/0638/selig.php Seattle Weekly on Selig and Falk]
* [http://www.yeson920.com/index.asp Pro-I-920 page]
* [http://www.noon920.org/ Anti-I-920 page]
* [http://www.nwprogressive.org/weblog/2006/04/i-920-endangers-our-future.html NPI on I-920]
* [http://www.jbs.org/ John Birch Society homepage]
* [http://www.childrenshub.org/calliance/notice-description.tcl?newsletter_id=3528360 The Childrens Alliance onf I-920]
* [http://www.washingtonvoter.org/default.asp?id=184 Information on various Initiatives from Washington Voter]
* [http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/Content?oid=40048 "The Stranger" on I-920 signature gathering]

References