- Analytic and enumerative statistical studies
In "Some Theory of Sampling" (1950, Chapter 7),
W. Edwards Demingintroduced concepts he labeled Analytic and enumerative statistical studies. In any statistical study the ultimate aim is to provide a rational basis for action. Enumerative and analytic studies differ by where the action is taken. Deming summarized the distinction between enumerative and analytic studies as follows: [Deming, W. Edwards "On probability as a basis for action" The American Statistician, volume 29, 1975]
Enumerative study: A statistical study in which action will be taken on the material in the frame being studied.
Analytic study: A statistical study in which action will be taken on the process or cause-system that produced the frame being studied. The aim being to improve practice in the future.
(In a statistical study, the frame is the set from which the
Sample (statistics)is taken.)
In other words, an enumerative study is a statistical study in which the focus is on judgment of results, and an analytic study is one in which the focus is on
improvement of the processor system which created the results being evaluated and which will continue creating results in the future. A statistical study can be enumerative or analytic, but it cannot be both.
This distinction between enumerative and analytic studies is the theory behind the
Fourteen Points for Management. Dr. Deming's philosophy is that management should be analytic instead of enumerative. In other words, management should focus on improvement of processes for the future instead of on judgment of current results.
"Use of data requires knowledge about the different sources of uncertainty.Measurement is a process. Is the system of measurement stable or unstable? Useof data requires also understanding of the distinction between enumerative studies and analytic problems."
"The interpretation of results of a test or experiment is something else. It isprediction that a specific change in a process or procedure will be a wise choice, or that no change would be better. Either way the choice is prediction. This is known as an analytic problem, or a problem of inference, prediction." [Deming, W. Edwards "The New Economics for Industry, Government, Education - 1st Edition"]
Mike Tveitehas pointed out the dangers of attempting to use an enumerative study for prediction.
* [http://homepage.mac.com/dfkerridge/.Public/DEN/Reality.pdf Statistics and Reality by David and Sarah Kerridge]
* [http://iws.ccccd.edu/rkunz/managedev/PDF/QCTC1303/FundamentalsofStatisticalStudies.pdf Fundamentals of Statistical Studies]
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.