- Fiscal Illusion
Fiscal Illusion is a
public choice theory of government expenditure first developed by the Italian economistAmilcare Puviani . Fiscal Illusion suggests that when government revenues are unobserved or not fully observed by taxpayers then the cost of government is perceived to be less expensive than it actually is. Since some or all taxpayers benefit from government expenditures from these unobserved or hidden revenues the public's demand for government expenditures increases, thus providing politicians incentive to expand the size of government.Fiscal Illusion has been used to explain the flypaper effect often seen when a higher level of government provides a grant to a lower level of government. Here, instead of reducing taxes in order to pass on the benefits of the grant to local taxpayers, the grant-receiving body increases expenditures in order to expand local services in some way. Fiscal Illusion is invoked as an explanation because the local taxpayers are under the mistaken perception that the grant is to local government and not, in fact, to them.
Another example of fiscal illusion can be seen in local property tax politics. Here renters, who pay local property taxes indirectly, may vote for an expansion of local government services. Fiscal illusion theory suggests taxpayers support this policy because its cost is masked by their rent payments.
Finally, another example of fiscal illusion may be seen in
deficit spending . CATO Institute economistWilliam Niskanen (2004), for instance, has noted that the ‘starve the beast ’ strategy popular among US conservatives wherein tax cuts now force a future reduction in federal government spending is empirically false. Instead, he has found that there is ‘a strong negative relation between the relative level of federal spending and tax revenues.’ Tax cuts and deficit spending, he argues, makes the cost of government appear to be cheaper than it otherwise would be.ources
*Puviani, Amilcare. (1897) Teoria della illusione nelle entrate publiche. Perugia
*Puviani, Amilcare, (1903) Teoria della illusione Finanziaria. Palermo.
*Mueller, Dennis C. (2003). Public Choice III. Cambridge University Press. pp. 221-222.
*Niskanen, William (2002). ‘Starve the Beast’ Does Not Work. CATO Policy Report March/April 2004.
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
