Weber v. Ontario Hydro

Weber v. Ontario Hydro

"Weber v. Ontario Hydro", [1995] 2 S.C.R. 929 is a leading decision of the Supreme Court of Canada where the Court held that a labour abitration board was a "court of competent jurisdiction" within the meaning of section 24(1) of the "Charter", and could grant declarations and damages. Consequently, the board has exclusive jurisdiction over the matter, and so employees cannot bring suits concerning matters under a collective agreement to court.

Background

Murray Weber, an employee of Ontario Hydro, took a leave of absence due a back injury. Ontario Hydro paid him sick benefits but after a time they became suspicious and hired a private investigator to spy on Weber. The investigators were able to gain access to Weber's home and found evidence showing that he was abusing the sick benefits.

In August 1989, Weber went to the union who then filed a grievance against Ontario Hydro claiming that the use of the private investigator violated the collective agreement.

While the arbitration was underway, Weber brought an action in court against Ontario Hydro for the torts of trespass, nuisance, deceit, and invasion of privacy, and for a violation of his "Charter" right to security under section 7 and privacy under section 8.

Ontario Hydro argued that the court could not hear Weber's action because the matter was in the jurisdiction of the arbitrator.

The motions judge struck down the action. He found that the action arose from the collective agreement and so the court did not have jurisdiction, moreover, it was a private dispute and so the "Charter" did not apply. The Court of Appeal upheld the decision, except held that the "Charter" claim was valid.

The question before the Court was whether the labour arbitrator had jurisdiction to grant remedies for the Weber's claims.

Reasons of the Court

Justice McLachlin, writing for the majority, held that the labour abritrartor had jurisdiction to grant the remedies and consequently, Weber could not bring an action in court.

McLachlin looked at the wording of the Ontario "Labour Relations Act" which gave the arbitrator exclusive authority to adjudicate over "all differences between the parties arising from the interpretation, application, administration or alleged violation of the agreement". She held that this meant that the abritrator had jurisdiction over the subject matter which meant that the abitrator necessarily had authority over remedies as well. Consequently, the abitrator was a "court of competent jurisdiction" and had authority over Weber's claims.

ee also

* List of Supreme Court of Canada cases (Lamer Court)

External links

*
* [http://www.opseu.org/legal/legalupdate28.htm summary of the case]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Section Twenty-four of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — provides for remedies available to those whose Charter rights are shown to be violated. Some scholars have argued that it was actually section 24 that ensured that the Charter would not have the primary flaw of the 1960 Canadian Bill of Rights :… …   Wikipedia

  • Industrial Review — ▪ 1994 Introduction       The period since 1990 was proving a difficult time for the older industrialized economies, which had suffered from prolonged recession at home, and also for the previously centrally planned economies of Eastern Europe… …   Universalium

  • Montreal Impact — This article is about the NASL senior men s team. For the MLS team, see Montreal Impact (MLS). Montreal Impact Full name Montreal Impact Football Club[ …   Wikipedia

  • List of Bilderberg attendees — is a list of prominent persons who have attended one or more conferences organized by the Bilderberg Group. The list is currently organized by category. It is not a complete list and it includes both living and deceased people. Where known, the… …   Wikipedia

  • Indianer — Sitting Bull, Häuptling und Medizinmann der Hunkpapa Lakota Sioux. Foto von David Frances Barry, 1885 …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Photovoltaics — (PV) is the field of technology and research related to the application of solar cells for energy by converting sunlight directly into electricity. Due to the growing need for solar energy, the manufacture of solar cells and photovoltaic arrays… …   Wikipedia

  • 2007 Bilderberg Meeting — The Bilderberg Group met from May 31 to June 3 in the Ritz Carlton hotel in Istanbul, Turkey. The occupation and information on nationality of the participants are given as they appeared on the delegate list. [… …   Wikipedia

  • Fibrose cystique — Mucoviscidose Mucoviscidose Autre nom Fibrose kystique du pancréas Référence MIM …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Fibrose kystique — Mucoviscidose Mucoviscidose Autre nom Fibrose kystique du pancréas Référence MIM …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Fibrose kystique du pancréas — Mucoviscidose Mucoviscidose Autre nom Fibrose kystique du pancréas Référence MIM …   Wikipédia en Français

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”