Le Paradis massacre

Infobox civilian attack
title=Le Paradis Massacre


location=Le Paradis village, commune of Lestrem, Northern France
target=2nd Battalion Royal Norfolk Regiment
date=27 May 1940
time=
timezone=
type=Mass execution of Prisoners-of-war
fatalities=97
injuries=2
perps=14th Company, 3rd SS Division "Totenkopf"
SS Hauptsturmführer Fritz Knöchlein
motive=

The Le Paradis massacre was a war crime committed by members of the 14th Company, SS Division Totenkopf, under the command of Hauptsturmführer Fritz Knöchlein. It took place on 27 May 1940, during the Battle of France, at a time when the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) was attempting to retreat through the Pas-de-Calais region during the Allied evacuation from Dunkirk.

Soldiers of the 2nd Battalion, the Royal Norfolk Regiment, had become isolated from their regiment. They occupied and defended a farmhouse against an attack by Waffen-SS forces in the village of Le Paradis. After running out of ammunition, the defenders surrendered to the German troops. The Germans led them across the road to a wall, and machine-gunned them. Ninety-seven British troops died. Two survived, with injuries, and hid until they were captured by German forces several days later.

After the war, Fritz Knöchlein was located, tried and convicted by a war crimes court, with the two survivors acting as witnesses against him. For his part in the massacre, Knöchlein was executed in 1949.

Background

The German invasion of France through the Netherlands and Belgium began just after dawn on 10 May 1940. Army Group A under the command of Colonel General Gerd von Rundstedt fought its way through southern Belgium and north-eastern France. German forces pushed the French Army and the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) to the Meuse river on 12 May, crossing it that evening. [cite web | url=http://www.calvin.edu/academic/cas/gpa/facts01.htm |title=The Battle of France |accessdate=2007-12-19 |author=German Propaganda Archive |publisher=Calvin College, cite web |url=http://www.germanwarmachine.com/campaigns/1940/battleoffrance1.htm |title=German Army Battles & Campaigns: Battle of France, 1940 |accessdate=2007-12-12 |publisher=Brown Online, Jackson, "The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940", pp. 221–556.] From there, the German forces rapidly advanced to the English Channel over the course of the next week. BEF units, including detached companies of the Royal Norfolks and Royal Scots, were ordered to try to slow the German advance in northern France to buy time to evacuate troops at Dunkirk. [Jackson, "The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940", pp. 94–97.] [Wilson, "Dunkirk: From Disaster to Deliverance", pp. 42–56.]

One of the participating German units, the 3rd SS Division Totenkopf, had been strongly indoctrinated with the Nazi Party ideology by its commander Theodor Eicke. Eicke's men had a fanatical loyalty to him and to Germany, along with an imbued hatred of Jews, Britain and the United States of America. [Mann, "SS-Totenkopf", p. 85.] The men of Totenkopf fought recklessly throughout the campaign, suffering comparatively higher death rates than other German forces. [cite web |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=QYU4QJsUWLYC&pg=PA93&lpg=PA93&dq=ss+totenkopf+france+cambrai&source=web&ots=-BuGYKl7eO&sig=78w8MoFmSWaeneAGjQmN17Nn430 |title=Soldiers of Destruction: The SS Death's Head Division, 1933-1945 |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Charles W. Sydnor |year=1977 |publisher=Princeton University Press| pages=p. 108]

The Battle of France was SS Division Totenkopf's first major engagement of World War II. The division, part of the reserves of Army Group A, was called to the front line on 17 May. The unit was engaged in "mopping up" operations against Allied forces to the north and east of Cambrai. [Sydnor, "Soldiers of Destruction", p. 93.] [cite web |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=0TrWrxxDkf8C&pg=PA39&lpg=PA39&dq=the+%22waffen+ss%22+at+war+hitler's+praetorians+france+1940&source=web&ots=A58geadDPP&sig=qXnFc2gRaXwhWEsla0vZnuj9aI4#PPA40,M1 |title=The Waffen-SS at War: Hitler's Praetorians 1925-1945 |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Tim Ripley |year=2004 |publisher=Zenith Imprint| pages=pp. 39–42] In total 16,000 prisoners had been taken by the division, but they had refused the surrender of nowrap|200 French-Moroccan troops, who were executed on the spot. [Mann, "SS-Totenkopf", p. 76.]

By the time the operation had finished in Cambrai, the first German units had reached the English Channel, but the British, under Major-General G. Le Q. Martel, counter-attacked just west of Arras, on 21 May following on from the counter attack of the day before (Battle of Arras). The Totenkopf division suffered casualties of just under 100 men in repelling the assault. [cite web |url=http://www.ibiblio.org/hyperwar/UN/UK/UK-NWE-Flanders/UK-NWE-Flanders-6.html |title=The Counter-Attack At Arras |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Major L. F. Ellis |publisher=HyperWar Project] The Totenkopf was then ordered to the town of Béthune by General Erich Hoepner and crossed the La Bassée river under British attack on 24 May. However, the men were ordered to retreat the next day on direct orders from Adolf Hitler, issued to preserve tanks for the upcoming campaign in Dunkirk and to allow the Luftwaffe to attack Allied positions in the area. [Mann, "SS-Totenkopf", p. 85.] The men thus had to make the hazardous crossing again on the night of 26 May. The SS men took Béthune after heavy house-to-house fighting with the British, who withdrew to a line between Locon and Le Paradis. [Mann, "SS-Totenkopf", pp. 74–82.]

The 2nd Battalion of the Royal Norfolks, along with the 8th Lancashire Fusiliers, were holding the Allied line at the villages of Riez du Vinage, Le Cornet Malo and Le Paradis with the battalion headquarters based at Le Paradis. The battalions had been ordered to hold out for as long as possible against the Germans to give time for the BEF to evacuate from Dunkirk. [cite web |url=http://www.norfolkbc.fsnet.co.uk/archive_collection/strips_farrow/mackillers_paradis.htm |title=Le Paradis Massacre |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Major John L. Raybould |work=Britannia and Castle |publisher=Cambridgeshire, Suffolk, Royal Norfolk, East Anglian and Royal Anglian Regimental Associations]

The SS Division Totenkopf emerged from the Bois de Paqueaut wood and attacked Le Cornet Malo at dawn on 27 May. The British troops defended stubbornly but were eventually overrun. The attack resulted in the deaths of four German officers and 150 men. Another 480 men and 18 officers were wounded. Later the same day, the German troops moved forward to attack Le Paradis. [Mann, "SS-Totenkopf", pp. 80–83.] Jackson, "The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940", pp. 285–288.] cite web |url=http://www.ritterkreuztraeger-1939-45.de/Waffen-SS/K/Knoechlein-Fritz.htm |title=Ritterkreuzträger Fritz Knöchlein |accessdate=2007-12-20 |author=Uwe Schweisfurth |publisher=Uwe Schweisfurth |language=German]

Battle of Le Paradis

After the engagement at Le Cornet Malo, C Company and HQ Company of the 2nd Royal Norfolks had fallen back to their headquarters at Cornet Farm, just outside Le Paradis. The company commanders had been informed by radio that their units were isolated and would receive no assistance. [cite web |url=http://www.stephen-stratford.co.uk/pooleys_revenge.htm |title=Private Pooley's Revenge |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Stephen Stratford |publisher=Stephen Stratford] They therefore dug in around the farmhouse, which lay on the Rue du Paradis, the boundary between the Royal Norfolk Regiment and the adjacent 1st Royal Scots. The Norfolk's last contact with Brigade Headquarters at L'Epinette was at 11:30 but despite no support and heavy opposition, the defenders held out against the 14th Company, 1st Battalion of the 2nd SS Infantry Regiment until 17:15, when they ran out of ammunition.Jackson, "The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940", pp. 288–289.] During the battle the Germans attacked the farmhouse with mortars, tanks and artillery shelling, which destroyed the building and forced the defenders to relocate to a cowshed.

The 99 surviving defenders of the 2nd Norfolks were eventually ordered by their commander Major Lisle Ryder, the brother of Robert Edward Dudley Ryder, to surrender and they left the cowshed that they had been defending under a white flag. Due to the boundary between the two British regiments being the road, Ryder's men surrendered not to the company they had been fighting, but rather to SS Hauptsturmführer Fritz Knöchlein's unit, which had been fighting the Royal Scots. [cite web |url=http://www.stephen-stratford.co.uk/pooleys_revenge.htm |title=Private Pooley's Revenge |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Stephen Stratford |publisher=Stephen Stratford] Mass graves found near Le Paradis in 2007 suggest that around 20 men of the Royal Scots who surrendered to an SS unit may also have been murdered in a separate massacre. [cite news |last=Bruce |first=Ian|title=21 Royal Scots executed by SS at Dunkirk |url=http://www.theherald.co.uk/news/news/display.var.1460869.0.21_royal_scots_executed_by_ss_at_dunkirk.php |date=11 June 2007 |accessdate=2008-02-12]

Massacre

The British captives, a majority of whom were wounded, were disarmed and marched down a road off the Rue du Paradis. While they were waiting, two machine-guns from No.4 Machine-gun Company were prepared and set up by a barn in a paddock of the farm. The British prisoners were marched to the barn, lined up alongside it and fired upon by the two German machinegunners, who continued firing until all the British had fallen. Knöchlein then armed his men with bayonets to kill any remaining survivors. Satisfied that they had killed them all, the German soldiers left to rejoin the rest of their regiment. [cite news |last=Cooper |first=D |title=Le Paradis: The murder of 97 soldiers in a French field on the 26/27th May 1940 |url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/ww2peopleswar/stories/83/a2328383.shtml |publisher=BBC |date=22 February 2004 |accessdate=2008-02-13] [Jolly, "The Vengeance of Private Pooley", pp. 104–119.] [Hürter, "Hitlers Heerführer: Die deutschen Oberbefehlshaber", p. 189.]

An account by Private Albert Pooley, one of only two survivors:

... we turned off the dusty French road, through a gateway and into a meadow beside the buildings of a farm. I saw with one of the nastiest feelings I have ever had in my life two heavy machine guns inside the meadow ... pointing at the head of our column. The guns began to spit fire ... for a few seconds the cries and shrieks of our stricken men drowned the crackling of the guns. Men fell like grass before a scythe ... I felt a searing pain and pitched forward ... my scream of pain mingled with the cries of my mates, but even before I fell into the heap of dying men, the thought stabbed my brain 'If I ever get out of here, the swine that did this will pay for it.' [Mann, "SS-Totenkopf", pp. 84–85.]

Ninety-seven British prisoners were killed and the Germans forced French civilians to bury the bodies in a shallow mass grave the next day. Despite the German efforts, Private William O'Callaghan had survived and pulled Private Albert Pooley alive from among the bodies in the field. The pair then hid in a pig-sty for three days and nights, surviving on raw potatoes and water from puddles before being discovered by the farm's owner, Madame Duquenne-Creton, and her son Victor. The French civilians risked their lives caring for the two men, who were later captured by the Wehrmacht's 251st Infantry Division. [cite web |url=http://members.iinet.net.au/~gduncan/massacres.html |title=Massacres and Atrocities of World War II: Le Paradis |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=George Duncan |publisher=George Duncan] [Jackson, "The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940", pp. 331–379.]

Aftermath

On the day after the massacre, 28 May, Gunter d'Alquen, a journalist in the Waffen-SS, arrived at the scene with Dr Thum, the SS-Totenkopf deputy legal advisor. d'Alquen made a report of what he saw:

It was possible to look into the back yard from the road...the corpses in British uniform were lying in the yard near the buildings. They were lying in such a position that one can assume they were killed by machine-gun bursts. It struck me at once that the dead soldiers were not wearing helmets, nor did they have any equipment on them...I took pictures of the dead bodies, and the whole farm. At Thum's request these were to be placed at the disposal of the division...I believe I was already sitting there in the vehicle when Thum...told me that in the field which he had returned the equipment...the shot British soldiers were lying in a heap, from which he had come to the conclusion that a summary trial had taken place. [Jackson, "The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940", pp. 301–302.]

Major Friedkerr von Riedner, who was also at the scene of the massacre on that day, reported that "These people had almost all suffered head wounds from shots that must have been fired at close range. Some had their whole skull smashed in, an injury that can almost only be caused by a blow from a gun butt or similar means." [Wilson, "Dunkirk: From Disaster to Deliverance", p. 73.]

News of the massacre spread to neighbouring German divisions, eventually reaching General Hoepner, commander of the German forces in France. He disliked the SS, especially Eicke, and was determined to have him dismissed if charges of mistreatment or murdering of prisoners could be brought. However none of these investigations were ever successful, possibly because Knöchlein stated that the British had been using dumdum bullets, thus violating the Hague Convention of 1899. Regardless, many SS officers were appalled by the massacre; some reportedly challenged Knöchlein to a duel, although none was ever fought. [cite web |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=-KEtPlNQJNgC&pg=RA1-PA76&lpg=RA1-PA76&dq=le+paradis+massacre&source=web&ots=dV4NIMNPqY&sig=uLY5aSFyv8TbUB3Hf_xS5n2LG0Y#PRA1-PA77,M1 |title=The Waffen SS |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=George H. Stein |year=1966 |publisher=Cornell University Press| pages=p. 76]

The Allies received no information about the massacre until the summer of 1943, when Pooley, who had spent the last three years in a German hospital due to the injuries he had suffered in the massacre, was declared medically unfit and repatriated. British authorities did not believe Pooley's story on his arrival; it was not thought that the German army were capable of such atrocities against British troops.cite web |url=http://www.norfolkbc.fsnet.co.uk/archive_collection/strips_farrow/mackillers_paradis.htm |title=Le Paradis Massacre |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Major John L. Raybould |work=Britannia and Castle |publisher=Cambridgeshire, Suffolk, Royal Norfolk, East Anglian and Royal Anglian Regimental Associations] Private O'Callaghan did not return to the United Kingdom until 1945 after the liberation of his prisoner-of-war camp. His confirmation of Pooley's story prompted an official investigation.

The bodies of those killed in the massacre were exhumed in 1942 by the French, but only about 50 of the 97 remains were successfully identified. The bodies were then reburied in Le Paradis churchyard, which now forms part of the Le Paradis War Cemetery administered by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission. [cite web |url=http://www.cwgc.org/search/cemetery_details.aspx?cemetery=2027400&mode=1 |title=Commonwealth War Graves Commission: Le Paradis |accessdate=2007-12-12 |publisher=Commonwealth War Graves Commission] In 1970, a memorial plaque was placed on the barn wall where the massacre took place and a large memorial was subsequently erected beside the church. [cite web |url=http://www.roll-of-honour.com/Regiments/RoyalNorfolkMassacreWordlWar2.html |title=Massacre of Royal Norfolk Soldiers At Le Paradis |accessdate=2007-12-12 |publisher=War Memorials Trust] [cite news |last=Babbington |first=Andrea|title=Wartime massacre commemorated by Dunkirk veterans |url=http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/this_britain/article275689.ece |publisher=The Independent |date=3 June 2000 |accessdate=2007-12-12 ]

Trial of Knöchlein

After the war, O'Callaghan's evidence and the discovery of the SS-run extermination camps prompted the British authorities to look into the reports. The massacre was investigated by the War Crimes Investigation Unit and after Knöchlein's company was identified as the perpetrators in 1947, he was traced and arrested in Germany.cite web |url=http://www.stephen-stratford.co.uk/pooleys_revenge.htm |title=Private Pooley's Revenge |accessdate=2007-12-12 |author=Stephen Stratford |publisher=Stephen Stratford] Knöchlein was arraigned on charges of war crimes in August 1948; to which he pleaded not guilty:

The accused Fritz Knöchlein, a German national, in the charge of the Hamburg Garrison Unit, pursuant to Regulation 4 of the Regulations for the Trial of War Criminals, is charged with committing a war crime in that he in the vicinity of Paradis, Pas-de-Calais, France, on or about 27 May 1940, in violation of the laws and usages of war, was concerned in the killing of about ninety prisoners-of-war, members of The Royal Norfolk Regiment and other British Units.

He was tried before Curiohaus war crimes court in Rotherbaum, in Court Number 5 on Monday, 11 October 1948. Knöchlein's defence hinged on the claim that he was not present at the massacre, although his lawyers did not deny that the event took place. They also claimed that the British had used dumdum bullets during the battle and misused a flag of truce; all of which were vigorously denied by the prosecution. Evidence was given by Pooley, O'Callaghan, Madame Duquenne-Creton, and a French civilian who testified to recognizing Knöchlein. [Jolly, "The Vengeance of Private Pooley", pp. 167–198.]

On the 12th day of the trial, during his summation, the Judge-Advocate said that whether the British had used illegal ammunition or abused a flag of truce was irrelevant; the German troops still had absolutely no right to execute prisoners of war without a fair and proper trial. On 25 October at 11:30, the verdict was read out by the President of the court. This asserted that the defendant, Fritz Knöchlein, had been found guilty of war crimes. His lawyer, Dr. Uhde, made the following plea to the court for clemency on account of Knöchlein's wife and family, who had attended every day of the trial.

All that is left for me to say is that some little doubt may have remained in the minds of the Court which will enable the members not to award the extreme penalty. Spare the life of the accused. He has a wife and four children who are dependent upon him for support. Consider also the fact that he is a soldier, and the Court is composed of members of the British Army. I believe I am entitled to appeal to the Court to pronounce a sentence which will enable my client to come out of prison at an early date.

Despite this plea, it was announced at 15:00 that he was to be sentenced to death by hanging; Knöchlein "turned grey" but showed no other emotion. He was hanged on 28 January 1949 in Hamburg. No other German soldiers or officers were prosecuted for their roles in the massacre.

Notes

References

;Books
*cite book |title=Hitlers Heerführer: Die deutschen Oberbefehlshaber |last=Hürter |first=Johannes |year=2006 |publisher=OldenbourgWissenschaftsverlag |isbn=3486579827
*cite book |title=The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940 |last=Jackson |first=Julian |year=2001 |publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=0192805509
*cite book |title=The Fall of France: The Nazi Invasion of 1940 |last=Jackson |first=Julian |year=2001 |publisher=Viking |isbn=0670910821
*cite book |title=The Vengeance of Private Pooley |last=Jolly |first=Cyril |year=1957 |publisher=William Heineman Ltd |isbn=095077331X
*cite book |title=SS-Totenkopf |last=Mann |first=Dr. Chris |year=2001 |publisher=MBI Publishing Company |isbn=0760310157
*cite book |title=The Waffen-SS at War: Hitler's Praetorians 1925-1945 | url=http://books.google.com/books?id=0TrWrxxDkf8C&pg=PA39&lpg=PA39&dq=the+%22waffen+ss%22+at+war+hitler's+praetorians+france+1940&source=web&ots=A58geadDPP&sig=qXnFc2gRaXwhWEsla0vZnuj9aI4#PPA40,M1 |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Ripley |first=Tim |year=2004 |publisher=Zenith Imprint |isbn=0760320683
*cite book |title=Soldiers of Destruction: The SS Death's Head Division, 1933-1945 |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=QYU4QJsUWLYC&pg=PA93&lpg=PA93&dq=ss+totenkopf+france+cambrai&source=web&ots=-BuGYKl7eO&sig=78w8MoFmSWaeneAGjQmN17Nn430 |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Sydnor |first=Charles W. |year=1977 |publisher=Princeton University Press |isbn=0691008531
*cite book |title=Dunkirk: From Disaster to Deliverance |last=Wilson |first=Patrick |year=2000 |publisher=Pen and Sword |isbn=158097046X

;Web
*cite web |url=http://www.calvin.edu/academic/cas/gpa/facts01.htm |title=The Battle of France |accessdate=2007-12-19 |author=German Propaganda Archive |publisher=Calvin College
*cite web |url=http://www.germanwarmachine.com/campaigns/1940/battleoffrance1.htm |title=German Army Battles & Campaigns: Battle of France, 1940 |accessdate=2007-12-12 |publisher=Brown Online
*cite web |url=http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2002/5/14/55627/2665 |title=1940: The Battle of France |accessdate=2007-12-19 |date=14 May 2002 |publisher=Scoop
*cite web |url=http://members.iinet.net.au/~gduncan/massacres.html |title=Massacres and Atrocities of World War II: Le Paradis |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Duncan |first=George |publisher=George Duncan
*cite web |url=http://www.ibiblio.org/hyperwar/UN/UK/UK-NWE-Flanders/UK-NWE-Flanders-6.html |title=The Counter-Attack At Arras |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Ellis | first=Major L. F. |publisher=HyperWar Project
*cite web |url=http://www.norfolkbc.fsnet.co.uk/archive_collection/strips_farrow/mackillers_paradis.htm |title=Le Paradis Massacre |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Raybould |first=Major John L. |work=Britannia and Castle |publisher=Cambridgeshire, Suffolk, Royal Norfolk, East Anglian and Royal Anglian Regimental Associations
*cite web |url=http://www.ritterkreuztraeger-1939-45.de/Waffen-SS/K/Knoechlein-Fritz.htm |title=Ritterkreuzträger Fritz Knöchlein |accessdate=2007-12-20 |last=Schweisfurth | first=Uwe |publisher=Uwe Schweisfurth |language=German
*cite web |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=-KEtPlNQJNgC&pg=RA1-PA76&lpg=RA1-PA76&dq=le+paradis+massacre&source=web&ots=dV4NIMNPqY&sig=uLY5aSFyv8TbUB3Hf_xS5n2LG0Y#PRA1-PA77,M1 |title=The Waffen SS |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Stein |first=George H. |year=1966 |publisher=Cornell University Press
*cite web |url=http://www.stephen-stratford.co.uk/pooleys_revenge.htm |title=Private Pooley's Revenge |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Stratford |first=Stephen |publisher=Stephen Stratford
*cite web |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=LSCGxAunpDsC&pg=PA24&lpg=PA24&dq=totenkopf+moroccan&source=web&ots=A-Q5aOv_JK&sig=yMznmRFbYujBBb6ysB1XUbjzuK8 |title=The Waffen-SS |accessdate=2007-12-12 |last=Williamson |first=Gordon |year=2004 |publisher=Osprey Publishing
*cite web |url=http://www.roll-of-honour.com/Regiments/RoyalNorfolkMassacreWordlWar2.html |title=Massacre of Royal Norfolk Soldiers At Le Paradis |accessdate=2007-12-12 |publisher=War Memorials Trust

;News

*cite news |last=Babbington |first=Andrea| title=Wartime massacre commemorated by Dunkirk veterans |url=http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/this_britain/article275689.ece |publisher=The Independent |date=3 June 2000 |accessdate=2007-12-12
*cite news |last=Bruce |first=Ian| title=21 Royal Scots executed by SS at Dunkirk |url=http://www.theherald.co.uk/news/news/display.var.1460869.0.21_royal_scots_executed_by_ss_at_dunkirk.php |date=11 June 2007 |accessdate=2008-02-12
*cite news |last=Cooper |first=D |title=Le Paradis: The murder of 97 soldiers in a French field on the 26/27th May 1940 |url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/ww2peopleswar/stories/83/a2328383.shtml |publisher=BBC |date=22 February 2004 |accessdate=2008-02-13