Central Virginia Community College v. Katz

Central Virginia Community College v. Katz

SCOTUSCase
Litigants=Central Virginia Community College v. Katz
ArgueDate=October 31
ArgueYear=2005
DecideDate=January 23
DecideYear=2006
FullName=Central Virginia Community College et al. v. Katz, Liquidating Supervisor for Wallace's Bookstores, Inc.
USVol=
USPage=
CitationNew=546 U.S. 356
Docket=04-0885
Citation=
Prior=
Subsequent=
Holding=A bankruptcy trustee's proceeding to set aside the debtor's preferential transfers to state agencies is not barred by sovereign immunity.
SCOTUS=2005-2006
Majority=Stevens
JoinMajority=O'Connor, Souter, Ginsburg, Breyer
Concurrence=
JoinConcurrence=
Concurrence2=
JoinConcurrence2=
Concurrence/Dissent=
JoinConcurrence/Dissent=
Dissent=Thomas
JoinDissent=Roberts, Scalia, Kennedy
Dissent2=
JoinDissent2=
LawsApplied=

"Central Virginia Community College v. Katz", 546 U.S. 356 (2006), is a United States Supreme Court case holding that the Bankruptcy Clause of the Constitution abrogates state sovereign immunity. It is significant as the only case allowing Congress to use an Article I power to authorize individuals to sue states.

Historical Context

In England, sovereign immunity referred to the concept that the king could not be sued without his consent. Beginning with "Hans v. Louisiana" (1890), a line of controversial Supreme Court cases had applied the concept of sovereign immunity to suits brought by private individuals against state governments. "See" The Eleventh Amendment. By the time "Central Virginia Community College v. Katz" came up for review, a majority of the justices on the Supreme Court had suggested Congress could never authorize individuals to sue a state pursuant to its Article I powers, including the Bankruptcy power. "Seminole Tribe v. Florida".

Facts

Wallace's Bookstores did business with Central Virginia Community College, an arm of the state. While it was insolvent, Wallace's Bookstores made certain preferential transfers of property to the state to satisfy debts. After Wallace's Bookstores filed for bankruptcy, Katz, the bankruptcy trustee, sued the state under usc|11|547 to recover those transfers. The state raised sovereign immunity as a defense.

Majority Opinion

In an opinion by Justice Stevens, the Court rejected the state's claim of sovereign immunity. The Court first noted that during the time the Articles of Confederation were in effect, states often did not recognize another state's discharge of a person's debt. This patchwork of bankruptcy laws made it difficult for people in debt to get out of debtor's prison. In light of this history, the Court interpreted Congress' power under the Bankruptcy Clause to make "uniform laws on the subject of bankruptcies" to include the power to abrogate state sovereign immunity.

The Court stated early bankruptcy legislation also supported its interpretation of the Bankruptcy Clause. It noted that in 1800, when concerns for state sovereign immunity ran fervent, Congress, with no recorded objection, gave federal courts power to release debtors from state prison through the writ of habeas corpus.

In coming to its conclusion, the Court declined to follow dicta in "Seminole Tribe v. Florida" suggesting a contrary result.

Dissent

Justice Thomas, writing for three other justices, argued the historical record indicated states did not give up their sovereign immunity under the Bankruptcy Clause. The dissenters would have followed the view that nothing in Article I abrogates state sovereign immunity.

External links

* [http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=US&navby=case&vol=000&invol=04-885 Central Virginia Community College v. Katz] - full text of opinion


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Manchester Community College — This article is about the community college in Connecticut. For the college in New Hampshire, see Manchester Community College (New Hampshire). Manchester Community College Established 1963 …   Wikipedia

  • Virginia V — Infobox nrhp | name =VIRGINIA V (steamer) nrhp type = nhl caption = location= 860 Terry Avenue North, Seattle, WA 98109 lat degrees = 47 | lat minutes = 37 | lat seconds = 41.8434| lat direction = N long degrees = 122 | long minutes = 20 | long… …   Wikipedia

  • law — law1 lawlike, adj. /law/, n. 1. the principles and regulations established in a community by some authority and applicable to its people, whether in the form of legislation or of custom and policies recognized and enforced by judicial decision. 2 …   Universalium

  • Law — /law/, n. 1. Andrew Bonar /bon euhr/, 1858 1923, English statesman, born in Canada: prime minister 1922 23. 2. John, 1671 1729, Scottish financier. 3. William, 1686 1761, English clergyman and devotional writer. * * * I Discipline and profession… …   Universalium

  • Wallace G. Wilkinson — Infobox Governor name= Wallace G. Wilkinson caption= order= 57th office= Governor of Kentucky term start= 1987 term end= 1991 lieutenant= Brereton C. Jones predecessor= Martha Layne Collins successor= Brereton C. Jones birth date= birth… …   Wikipedia

  • Bankruptcy in the United States — The United States Constitution (Article 1, Section 8, Clause 4) authorizes Congress to enact uniform Laws on the subject of Bankruptcies throughout the United States. Congress has exercised this authority several times since 1801, most recently… …   Wikipedia

  • Eleventh Amendment to the United States Constitution — The Eleventh Amendment (Amendment XI) of the United States Constitution was passed by the U.S. Congress on March 4, 1794, and was ratified on February 7, 1795. This Amendment deals with each State s sovereign immunity from being sued in federal… …   Wikipedia

  • Seminole Tribe v. Florida — SCOTUSCase Litigants=Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida ArgueDate=October 11 ArgueYear=1995 DecideDate=March 27 DecideYear=1996 FullName=Seminole Tribe of Florida, Petitioner v. State of Florida, et al. USVol=517 USPage=44 Citation=116 S. Ct.… …   Wikipedia

  • Abrogation doctrine — The Abrogation doctrine is a constitutional law doctrine expounding when and how the Congress may waive a state s sovereign immunity and subject it to lawsuits to which the state has not consented (i.e., to abrogate their immunity to such… …   Wikipedia

  • Alden v. Maine — Infobox SCOTUS case Litigants=Alden v. Maine ArgueDate=March 31 ArgueYear=1999 DecideDate=June 23 DecideYear=1999 FullName=John H. Alden, et al., Petitioner v. Maine USVol=527 USPage=706 Citation=119 S. Ct. 2240; 144 L. Ed. 2d 636; 1999 U.S.… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
… Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”