Phenomenal conservatism

Phenomenal conservatism

In epistemology, phenomenal conservatism (PC) holds that it is reasonable to assume that things are as they appear, unless there are positive grounds for doubting this. (The term derives from the Greek word "phainomenon", meaning "appearance".)

The principle was initially defended in Huemer 2001, where it was formulated as follows:

*If it seems to "S" as if "p", then "S" thereby has at least "prima facie" justification for believing that "p".

A later formulation, designed to allow the principle to encompass inferential as well as foundational justification, reads as follows.

*If it seems to "S" that "p", then, in the absence of defeaters, "S" thereby has at least some degree of justification for believing that "p".

Arguments for PC

Phenomenal Conservatism has been defended on three grounds.

#First, the principle enables one to account for the justification of most, perhaps all, of the beliefs that we commonly take as justified, including sensory observations, memory beliefs, and beliefs based on reasoning.
#Second, it is argued that alternative epistemological positions are self-defeating in the sense that, unless PC is true, few or no beliefs would be justified, including beliefs in any alternative epistemological theories. This is supported by the claims
#*that all or nearly all beliefs are causally explained by appearances, that is, one believes a proposition because it seems true to one; and
#*that a belief is justified only if it is causally explained by a factor that constitutes justification for the proposition believed.
#Third, it is argued that PC is most faithful to the motivations underlying epistemological internalism.

Criticisms of PC

Critics of Phenomenal Conservatism have argued:
*That the principle is overly liberal, making far too many beliefs count as justified. In particular, PC implies that one is justified in believing a proposition that appears true to one, even in the absence of any reason for thinking that the faculty generating the appearance is reliable.
*That the self-defeat argument unfairly begs the question against skepticism.
*That (in its original formulation) the principle makes inferential beliefs count as foundational.
*That PC enables a belief to be justified even when the relevant appearance (and so the belief) was ultimately caused by epistemically irresponsible behavior, such as wishful thinking.In addition, as a form of foundationalism, PC is open to some of the common objections to that doctrine.

Annotated bibliography

#Huemer, Michael. "Skepticism and the Veil of Perception" (Lanham, Md.: Rowman & Littlefield, 2001).
#*Source of the doctrine of Phenomenal Conservatism.
#BonJour, Laurence. "In Search of Direct Realism," "Philosophy and Phenomenological Research" 69 (2004): 349-67.
#*Criticism of Huemer 2001.
#Huemer, Michael. "Compassionate Phenomenal Conservatism," "Philosophy and Phenomenological Research", forthcoming.
#*Response to BonJour 2004, reformulation of the self-defeat argument.
#Markie, Peter. "The Mystery of Perceptual Justification," "Philosophical Studies", forthcoming.
#*Objects that PC is too liberal and enables beliefs caused by epistemically irresponsible behavior to be justified.
#Steup, Matthias. "Internalist Reliabilism," "Philosophical Issues" 14 (2004): 403-25.
#*Makes the objection that PC is too liberal.

External links

# [http://home.sprynet.com/~owl1/book1.htm Huemer's original statement of PC]
# [http://spot.colorado.edu/~tooley/S&VP.Chapter5.html Michael Tooley's discussion and criticism of PC]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Phenomenal conservatism — a philosophy that holds that it is reasonable to assume that things are as they appear, unless there are positive grounds for doubting this …   Mini philosophy glossary

  • Glossary of philosophical isms — This is a list of topics relating to philosophy that end in ism . compactTOC NOTOC A * Absolutism – the position that in a particular domain of thought, all statements in that domain are either absolutely true or absolutely false: none is true… …   Wikipedia

  • List of topics in epistemology — * A Defence of Common Sense * A priori and a posteriori (philosophy) * Adaptive representation * Aenesidemus * Aenesidemus (book) * Agrippa the Sceptic * Alison Wylie * Alvin Goldman * Analytic synthetic distinction * Androcentrism * Android… …   Wikipedia

  • Hinduism — /hin dooh iz euhm/, n. the common religion of India, based upon the religion of the original Aryan settlers as expounded and evolved in the Vedas, the Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita, etc., having an extremely diversified character with many… …   Universalium

  • literature — /lit euhr euh cheuhr, choor , li treuh /, n. 1. writings in which expression and form, in connection with ideas of permanent and universal interest, are characteristic or essential features, as poetry, novels, history, biography, and essays. 2.… …   Universalium

  • china — /chuy neuh/, n. 1. a translucent ceramic material, biscuit fired at a high temperature, its glaze fired at a low temperature. 2. any porcelain ware. 3. plates, cups, saucers, etc., collectively. 4. figurines made of porcelain or ceramic material …   Universalium

  • China — /chuy neuh/, n. 1. People s Republic of, a country in E Asia. 1,221,591,778; 3,691,502 sq. mi. (9,560,990 sq. km). Cap.: Beijing. 2. Republic of. Also called Nationalist China. a republic consisting mainly of the island of Taiwan off the SE coast …   Universalium

  • arts, East Asian — Introduction       music and visual and performing arts of China, Korea, and Japan. The literatures of these countries are covered in the articles Chinese literature, Korean literature, and Japanese literature.       Some studies of East Asia… …   Universalium

  • List of philosophy topics (I-Q) — II and thou I Ching I Ching I proposition I Thou I Thou relationshipIaIamblichus (philosopher)IbYahya Ibn Adi Yahya Ibn Adi Ibn al Arabi Muhyi al Din Ibn al Arabi Abu Bakr Ibn Bajja Abu Bakr Ibn Bājja Abu Bakr Muhammad Ibn Yahya Ibn as Say igh… …   Wikipedia

  • Hermeneutics — Gadamer and Ricoeur G.B.Madison THE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND: ROMANTIC HERMENEUTICS Although the term ‘hermeneutics’ (hermeneutica) is, in its current usage, of early modern origin,1 the practice it refers to is as old as western civilization itself …   History of philosophy

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”