Silver rule

Silver rule

Related to the ethical principle of the golden rule, the silver rule is most commonly understood to be "Do not do to others as you would not have them do to you," or similar expressions. Some such expressions, found in Hindu, Buddhist, and Muslim literature, are considered versions of the golden rule, and there is some controversy over whether the golden rule and silver rule should be considered different expressions of the same underlying idea, or whether they differ logically, ethically, or practically.

The golden rule may be said to describe or emphasize positive duties, the silver rule negative ones. As such, the silver rule may avoid some criticisms of the golden rule, which seems to suggest that we should do things to other which they don't want done to them, just because we want them done to us. The article on the golden rule has a more extensive discussion of these and objections to the golden rule. On the other hand, the silver rule can be criticized for being too easily satisfied, and hence insufficient to base morality on, if it never requires us to engage in acts of benevolence, assistance, etc.

Some authors understand the silver rule to be the shorter principle "Do no harm." In this version, it is often attributed to the Hippocratic Oath, and used in medical discussions. However, it is not found in the Hippocratic Oath, but a similar statement was made by Hippocrates in his Epidemics, Bk. I, Sect. XI. One translation reads: "Declare the past, diagnose the present, foretell the future; practice these acts. As to diseases, make a habit of two things — to help, or at least to do no harm."

The shorter expression might be interpreted as a simplification of the longer one, however the latter preserves the parallelism with the golden rule.

The Silver Rule has been championed by Gandhi and Martin Luther King alike as a way to compensate for the Golden Rule's shortcomings.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • silver rule — noun The principle that one should treat other people in the manner in which one would want to be treated by them. Confucius (551 479 BC) squarely faces the issue and gives us the first specific statement of the rule in its negative form,… …   Wiktionary

  • Silver goal — The silver goal was a method used in association football to decide the result of games in elimination matches which end in a draw after the end of regular time. A fifteen minute extra time period is played, and if either team is leading at the… …   Wikipedia

  • Rule of tincture — The first rule of heraldry is the rule of tincture: metal should not be put on metal, nor colour on colour (Humphrey Llwyd, 1568). This means that or and argent (gold and silver, which are represented by yellow and white) may not be placed on… …   Wikipedia

  • Silver Millennium — The Silver Millennium, a fictional kingdom in the Sailor Moon metaseries, lies on the moon. It provides a setting for the past lives and future selves of most of the series major characters, and functions as a major driving force behind both plot …   Wikipedia

  • Silver Fangs — articleissues unreferenced=December 2007 notable=July 2008 in universe=July 2008The Silver Fangs are a fictional tribe of Garou, or werewolves, in White Wolf s role playing game, set in the old World of Darkness setting.The Silver Fangs are the… …   Wikipedia

  • Silver Plume, Colorado — Infobox Settlement official name = Town of Silver Plume, Colorado other name = native name = nickname = settlement type = Town motto = imagesize = image caption = flag size = image seal size = image shield = shield size = image blank emblem =… …   Wikipedia

  • Silver Convention — Infobox musical artist 2 Name = Silver Convention Background = group or band Alias = Silver Bird Convention; Silver Bird Origin = Munich, Germany Genre = R B, pop, disco Years active = 1974 1979 Label = Magnet, Durium, Jupiter Past members =… …   Wikipedia

  • Silver State Classic Challenge — Start of the race The Silver State Classic Challenge is an authorized Open Road Racing event that is run on a 90 mi (140 km) stretch of State Route 318, which is closed for the occasion. The event has been run since 1988, and was the… …   Wikipedia

  • silver goal — noun the first goal scored during the first half of extra time; giving victory to the scoring side if this rule is in effect …   Wiktionary

  • silver platter doctrine — Evidence obtained illegally by state officials was formerly admissible in federal prosecutions because no federal official had participated in the violation of the defendant s rights. However, this rule no longer obtains. Elkins v. U. S., 364 U.S …   Black's law dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”