Gongsun Long

Gongsun Long

Gongsun Long (zh-tspw|t=公孫龍|s=公孙龙|p=Gōngsūn Lóng|w=Kung-sun Lung, ca. 325–250 BC [Zhou, Yunzhi, [http://www.wordpedia.com/search/Content.asp?ID=56458 "Gongsun Long"] . "Encyclopedia of China" (Philosophy Edition), 1st ed.] [Liu 2004, p. 336] ) was a member of the Logicians school of ancient Chinese philosophy. He also ran a school and enjoyed the support of rulers, and supported peaceful means of resolving disputes in contrast to the wars which were common in the period (the so-called Warring States Period). However, little is known about the particulars of his life, and furthermore many of his writings have been lost.McGreal 1995, p. 31] All of his essays, fourteen originally but only six still extant, are included in the book "Gongsun Longzi" (公孫龍子).

He is best known for a series of paradoxes in the tradition of Hui Shi, including "White horses are not horses," "When no thing is not the pointed-out, to point out is not to point out," and "There is no 1 in 2."

White Horse Dialogue

In the "White Horse Dialogue" (白馬論, "Báimǎ Lùn"), one interlocutor (sometimes called the "sophist") defends the truth of the statement "White horses are not horses," while the other interlocutor (sometimes called the "objector") disputes the truth of this statement. The argument plays upon an ambiguity in Chinese (which happens to also exist in English). The expression "X is not Y" (X非Y) can mean either
# "X is not a member (or subset) of set Y"
# "X is not identical with Y""Whales are not mammals" and "You are not a philosopher" are examples of the former use of "is not." An example of the second use of "is not" is "Jimmy Olsen is not Superman." Normally, in Chinese and English, it is clear from context which sense is intended, so we do not notice the ambiguity. So the sentence "White horses are not horses" would normally be taken to assert the obviously false claim that white horses are not part of the group of horses. However, the "sophist" in the "White Horse Dialogue" defends the statement under the interpretation, "White horses are not identical with horses." The latter statement is actually true, since (as the "sophist" in the dialogue explains) "horses" includes horses that are white, yellow, brown, etc., while "white horses" includes only white horses, and excludes the others.

This work has been viewed by some as a serious logical discourse, by others as a facetious work of sophistry, and finally by some as a combination of the two.cite journal | author=Harbsmeier, Christoph| title=Humor in Ancient Chinese Philosophy| journal=Philosophy East and West| year=1989| volume=39| issue=3| page=289-310| url=http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0031-8221%28198907%2939%3A3%3C289%3AHIACP%3E2.0.CO%3B2-B | pages=289 | doi=10.2307/1399450]

Other works

* 指物論 ("Zhǐwù Lùn")
* 通變論 ("Tōngbiàn Lùn")
* 堅白論 ("Jiānbái Lùn")
* 名實論 ("Míngshí Lùn")
* 跡府 ("Jifǔ") "Storehouse of Traces"

Notes

References

* Graham, Angus C. (1989). 'The Sharpening of Rational Debate: The Sophists.' Pp. 75-95 in Graham, "Disputers of the Tao." Chicago: Open Court Press.
* Liu, Jianguo (2004). "Distinguishing and Correcting the pre-Qin Forged Classics". Xi'an: Shaanxi People's Press. ISBN 7-224-05725-8.
* Zhou, Yunzhi, [http://www.wordpedia.com/search/Content.asp?ID=56458 "Gongsun Long"] . "Encyclopedia of China" (Philosophy Edition), 1st ed.

External links

* (In Chinese)
* [http://chinese.dsturgeon.net/text.pl?node=11553&if=en Full text of Gongsun Longzi]
* [http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/school-names/#6 Section on Gongsun Longzi in article in "Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy" on the "School of Names."]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • GONGSUN LONG — [KONG SOUEN LONG] (GONGSUN LONG 320 env. env. GONGSUN LONG 250) Dialecticien chinois, le plus grand logicien de l’époque classique, Gongsun Long a entrepris des recherches épistémologiques et métaphysiques qui sont l’aboutissement d’une longue… …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • Gongsun Long — Gongsun Longzi (chin. 公孫龍子, Gōngsūn Lóngzǐ, W. G. Kung sun Lung Tzu) ist das einzige noch vorhandene Werk eines Vertreters einer Schule, die in den Quellen aus der Han Dynastie als Míng jiā; (chin. 名家) bezeichnet wird. In der westlichen Literatur …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Gongsun Long — ▪ Chinese philosopher Wade Giles romanization  Kung sun Lung   born 325, Zhao state [now in Hebei province], China died 250 BCE, China  one of the best known representatives of the Dialecticians (Logician), a Chinese philosophical school of the… …   Universalium

  • Gongsun Longzi — (chinesisch 公孫龍子 Gōngsūn Lóngzǐ, W. G. Kung sun Lung Tzu) ist das einzige noch vorhandene Werk eines Vertreters einer Schule, die in den Quellen aus der Han Dynastie als Míng jiā; (chinesisch 名家) bezeichnet wird. In der westlichen… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Gongsun — (zh tspw|t=公孫|s=公孙|p=Gōngsūn|w=Kung sun) is one of the few Chinese compound surnames.Famous people with this surname include: * Gongsun Zan, warlord and general of the Han Dynasty * Gongsun Xu, son of Gongsun Zan * Gongsun Fan, cousin of Gongsun… …   Wikipedia

  • Gongsun Xu — Chinese t=公孫續 s=公孙续Gongsun Xu (died 199) was the son of Gongsun Zan, a warlord during the civil strife preceding the Three Kingdoms period in China.LifeAs Han s central power collapsed, Gongsun Zan and Yuan Shao fought for control of northern… …   Wikipedia

  • Gongsun Yang — Shang Yang Pour les articles homonymes, voir Shang et Yǎng (鞅). Buste de Shang Yang. Gongsun Yang ( …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Tang Long — (汤隆) is a character in the classic Chinese novel Water Margin .Tang Long stood at above seven feet, and had several spots all over his face and body, thus earning him the nickname Spotted leopard (金钱豹子). Tang Long excelled in the use of the spear …   Wikipedia

  • When a white horse is not a horse — (zh cpwl|c=白馬非馬|p= Báimǎ fēi mǎ |w= Pai ma fei ma |l=white horse not horse), also known as the White Horse Dialogue (zh cpwl|c=白馬論|p= Báimǎ Lùn |w= Pai ma Lun |l=white horse discourse), is a famous paradox in Chinese philosophy. Gongsun Long… …   Wikipedia

  • MINGJIA — [MING KIA] L’appellation de Mingjia («École des noms») fut donnée a posteriori à un mouvement de dialectique et de sophistique de la Chine classique qui, pour être mal connu et pour avoir été apparemment de peu d’ampleur, n’en a pas moins exercé… …   Encyclopédie Universelle

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”