Open access (infrastructure)

In the context of infrastructure, open access involves physical infrastructure such as railways and physical telecommunications network plant being made available to clients other than the owners, for a fee.

For example, private railways within, say, a steel works are private and not available to outsiders. In the hypothetical case of the steelworks having a port or a railway to a distant mine, outsiders might want access to save having to incur a possibly large cost of building their own facility.

Marconi and radio communication

Marconi was a pioneer of long distance radio communication, which was particularly useful for ships at sea. Marconi was very protective about its costly infrastructure and refused - except for emergencies - to allow other radio companies to share its infrastructure. Even if the message sender was royalty, as in the Deutschland incident of 1902, they continued to refuse access. Since radio communication was so new, it preceded laws, regulations and licences, which might otherwise imposed conditions to open infrastructure to other players.

Pilbara railways

In the northwest of Western Australia, two large mining companies operate their own private railway networks to bring iron ore from mines to the port. In 1999 North Limited made an application to access Rio Tinto's Pilbara system, but Rio's takeover of North Limited meant that application was never fully tested.^[1] In 2004 Fortescue Metals Group launched a bid to have the Mt Newman line owned by BHP Billiton "declared" for third party access.^[1] The owner of the line claimed that they formed an integral part of the production process, and so should not be subject to completion requirements. When these mines started in the 1960s, state laws required the miners to make their infrastructure available to other players, but no application had been made.^[2] In the same region, the Fortescue Metals Group railway has been set up for open access for a fee.

In June 2008 the Federal Government advisory body, the National Competition Council, recommended that BHP Billiton's Goldsworthy railway and Rio Tinto's Robe River and Hamersley lines should be declared open access. Treasurer Wayne Swan was given 60 days to make a final decision based on this recommendation.^[3] On October 27 the three lines were 'declared' with open access to apply from November 20, 2008. This will apply for 20 years under the National Access Regime within the Trade Practices Act 1974. The declaration does not give a right of access, but provides a third party with recourse if access terms cannot be negogiated with the infrastructure owner.^[4]

Concerns

A player seeking access to infrastructure would expect to pay several fees of a capital and operating kind. Hopefully the cost of this is less than having to built separate infrastructure. It is in the public interest that access disputes be resolved in an efficient way, so that for example, profits are maximised and therefore income tax on those profits is also maximised.

The potential for monopoly infrastructure to charge high fees and provide poor service has long been recognised. Monopolies are often inevitable because of high capital costs, with governments often imposing conditions, in exchange for approval of the project and for the granting of useful powers such as land resumption. Thus a canal might have its rates regulated, and be forbidden to operate canal boats on its own waters.

Trackage rights

Where there are many separate railways and one railway wishes to run trains off their own tracks onto the tracks of another, they may seek trackage rights from the other railway(s). This can be done by voluntary agreement, or by compulsory order of a regulator. In time of flood and accident which puts a line out of order, compulsory trackage rights may be ordered in the public interest to keep traffic flowing, assuming that alternative routes exist.

Joint Venture

One of the problems faced by Open Access is what is a fair price. Consider the Iron Ore minnow BC Iron which seeks access to the Forstescue railway. (Fortescue has declared itself to be an open access operator).

BC Iron and Fortescue agreed to set up a joint venture to operate both the BCI mine and the railway connection to the port. As the larger player, Fortescue will run the show. The joint venture gives BC Iron inside information as to how much the railway and port will cost, while Fortescue gains inside information about the mine.

Geraldton

In 2010, Mt Gibson Mining will be spending $20m to upgrade the ore unloaded at Geraldton. The facility will be open to other users who will pay a toll for such usage. ^[5]

The Oakajee port and railway network is also to be open access.

Queensland

In 2011, GVK has offer to make its proposed railway from the Galilee Basin to Abbot Point as open access to other players. ^[6]

Telecommunications

In the telecommunications industry, open access to existing infrastructure, in the form of local loop unbundling, duct sharing, utility pole sharing, and fiber unbundling, is one proposed solution to the middle mile problem.

See also

• Network Rail
• Forced-access regulation

References

1. ^ ^{a b} Mark Drummond (June 16, 2004). "Fortescue tries to prise open access to Pilbara railway line". The Sydney Morning Herald. www.smh.com.au. http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/06/15/1087244921972.html?from=moreStories. Retrieved 2008-11-10. 
2. ^ The Australian 11 June 2008, p31
3. ^ Chalpat Sonti (June 20, 2008). "Open Pilbara railways to Fortescue: NCC". The Age. business.theage.com.au. http://business.theage.com.au/business/open-pilbara-railways-to-fortescue-ncc-20080620-2txo.html. Retrieved 2008-11-10. 
4. ^ "Pilbara open access from November 20". Railway Gazette. www.railwaygazette.com. 27 Oct 2008. http://www.railwaygazette.com/news_view/article/2008/10/8971/pilbara_open_access_from_november_20.html. Retrieved 2008-11-10. ^{[dead link]}
5. ^ http://www.mtgibsoniron.com.au/uploads/24.9.2010%20-%20Govt%20Approves%20Geraldton%20Port%20Train%20Unloader%20Upgrade.pdf
6. ^ The Australian 21 September 2011 p39