Nelly Dean

For the song, see Nellie Dean.

Ellen "Nelly" Dean is a female character in Emily Brontë's novel, Wuthering Heights. She is the main narrator for the story, and gives key eyewitness accounts as to what happens between the characters. Ellen is for the most part called "Nelly" by all characters.

Story

A stranger named Lockwood visits the household of Wuthering Heights at the beginning of the story, and is overcome with shock when he believes he has seen the ghost of Catherine Earnshaw at a window in one of the chambers of the Heights. Eager to know the story of the master of the Heights, Heathcliff, Lockwood returns to Thrushcross Grange, his own temporary residence, where he asks Nelly, the housekeeper, to tell him all that she knows.

Nelly's mother was a servant at the Heights, and helped raise Hindley Earnshaw; Nelly was thus a foster sister and servant to Hindley and his sister, Catherine Earnshaw, at Wuthering Heights. Nelly is the same age as Hindley, about six years older than Cathy. When an orphan boy named Heathcliff is brought to live at the Heights, Nelly is witness to the misfortunes that he brings with him, the affection that Mr Earnshaw has for him (which leads to Hindley's bitter jealousy) and, above all, the childhood companionship between him and Catherine which eventually blossoms into a passionate love.

When Edgar Linton of Thrushcross Grange asks Catherine for her hand in marriage, Catherine confides in Nelly, explaining her distress. As a result, Nelly is the only witness to Catherine's famous "I am Heathcliff" speech, which has become iconic in literary history. Nelly's own reaction to it, though, is derisive and incredulous.

An arguably more significant event witnessed by Nelly, however, is the rapid loss of health and sanity of Hindley, which leads her to nurse the infant Hareton Earnshaw after his mother dies of consumption.

After Catherine marries and Heathcliff mysteriously disappears for three years, Nelly goes with the former to Thrushcross Grange. She is thus witness to Heathcliff's ominous return and his quest for revenge on both Hindley and the Linton family. She is also present for Catherine's maddening illness and psychological delusions, as well as Cathy's final meeting with her soul mate Heathcliff.

Catherine's death after childbirth causes Nelly to nurse another child, Catherine Linton. Nelly tenderly adores Cathy, and, fearing for her future, she and Edgar try desperately to keep the innocent yet curious girl from falling into Heathcliff's machinations. Heathcliff succeeds in spite of them, and Cathy is forced into a marriage with his weak and quickly-dying son Linton. Cathy's misery at Wuthering Heights is one of the few sequences of events that Nelly does not witness for herself: she has been ordered by Heathcliff to remain at the Grange, but, inveterate gossip that she is, she manages to hear of it from Zillah, the housekeeper at the Heights.

Nelly continues to fight to restore peace at Wuthering Heights and, at the conclusion of the novel, is asked by Heathcliff to come back to work there. She is the one who finds Heathcliff dead in his chamber, enabling the New Year's Day marriage of Cathy and Hareton. Despite Heathcliff's dreadful treatment of her erstwhile charges, Nelly is "stunned by the awful event; and my memory unavoidably recurred to former times with a sort of oppressive sadness."

Character

Nelly is an archetype of the unreliable narrator, as is Lockwood. The nesting narrative betrays the innocence of both as unbiased; the former being too close to events, whilst the latter was not involved at all. She insists that she does not love Catherine Earnshaw because of her "saucy", strong-willed manner, but cries bitterly at her death. Nelly nurses both Cathy and Hareton, although it is the former whom she truly raises and forever adores. Little is known of Nelly's life, and, although she is called "Mrs Dean" by Mr. Lockwood, it may likely be a form of a respectful address. However, it is not made clear whether Ellen is a wet nurse to the children. When seen from a Marxist point of view, Nelly takes on the role of society. Lacking to mention a husband would be indicative of the social and professional pressures on a woman who "had to mind her place"; Nelly had a job and a house to keep. Although Nelly constantly complains about the Earnshaws and Lintons, she never once ceases to pursue her wish to finally bring peace to both Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange.^{[dubious – discuss][citation needed]}

While this has been the common interpretation of Nelly, James Hafley's 1958 article, "The Villain in Wuthering Heights"^[1] rejects this view, arguing that she only seems like the moral centre of the novel because of the instability and violence of the world she describes. Looked at objectively, she is the true villain in the novel, driving the majority of the conflicts. Lockwood's faith in her story is taken as the ultimate mark of his innocence.

Nelly often hints at being in love with Hindley Earnshaw: she dislikes Frances, she cries bitterly at his death, she does not want to leave Wuthering Heights, she loves his son, Hareton, like a mother, and is shattered when he snubs her.

References

1. ^ James Hafley, "The Villain in Wuthering Heights," Nineteenth-Century Fiction, Vol. 13, No. 3. (Dec., 1958), pp. 199-200.