Market Investigations Ltd v Minister for Social Security

Market Investigations Ltd v Minister for Social Security
Court	Court of Appeal
Citation(s)	[1969] 2 QB 173
Keywords
Contract of employment

Market Investigations Ltd v Minister for Social Security [1969] 2 QB 173 is a UK labour law case concerning the scope of protection for people to employment rights. It took the view that an employment contract requires attention to a multiple list of factors.

Facts

Mrs Anne Irving from time to time did market questionnaires. There was a dispute between the business for whom she did the surveys, Market Investigations, and the Minister for Social Security over whether National Insurance contributions should have been made on her behalf. This depended on whether she was an employee.

Judgment

Cooke J held Ms Irving was an employee for the purpose of National Insurance contributions, despite ‘a limited discretion as to when she should do the work.’ Mrs Irving could control some of the way she carried out the work, but not entirely. She could not be said to be in business ‘on her own account,’ a judgment which depended on a list of factors, none of which are decisive. After quoting Lord Wright, Lord Denning and the Supreme Court of the United States, Cooke J said the authorities,

“

"suggest that the fundamental test to be applied is this: 'Is the person who has engaged himself to perform these services performing them as a person in business on his own account?'. If the answer is 'Yes', then the contract is a contract for services. If the answer is 'No', then the contract is a contract of service".

”

See also

• Contract of employment in English law
• UK labour law
• EU labour law
• US labor law
• German labour law

Notes

References

External links