Crossover effects

Crossover effects

In linguistics, crossover effects are restrictions on possible binding or coreference found between certain phrases and pronouns. Crossover effects are divided into weak crossover or strong crossover.

Weak crossover

In syntax, weak crossover (or WCO) refers to the restriction on possible binding or coreference found between certain phrases and pronouns, as the two below:

(1) ?Whoi does hisi mother love ti?
(2) ?Hisi mother loves [each boy]i.

In (1), the object wh-phrase who is said to have 'crossed over' the pronoun 'his' embedded in the subject. The same set of data found with quantifiers has often been claimed to be due to a covert movement of the quantifier phrase at a more abstract level of syntactic representation (such as Logical Form (LF)).

Strong crossover

Strong crossover (SCO) refers to the restriction on possible binding or coreference found between certain phrases and pronouns, as below:

(3) *Whoi does hei love ti?
(4) *Hei loves each boyi.

In (3), the object wh-phrase who is said to have "crossed over" the subject pronoun he; in this configuration, the individuals picked out by he cannot covary with those selected by who (that is, he cannot be bound by the quantifier associated with who). The same set of data found with quantifiers, as in (4), has often been claimed to be due to a covert movement of the quantifier phrase at a more abstract level of syntactic representation (such as Logical Form (LF)).

Crossover effects were originally discovered by Paul Postal in 1971;[1] the division into 'weak' and 'strong' is due to Tom Wasow, whose dissertation describes the fact that for many speakers, the restriction on binding is felt to be stronger in cases like (3) and (4) than in Weak Crossover configurations like (1) and (2).[2]

References

  1. ^ Postal, Paul. 1971. Crossover phenomena.
  2. ^ Wasow, Thomas. 1972. Anaphoric relations in English. MIT dissertation.