China Centenary Missionary Conference

The China Centenary Missionary Conference, held in 1907 in Shanghai, China commemorated 100 years of Protestant missionary work in China and debated future courses of action.

The Conference

The Conference celebrated the anniversary of the arrival of the first Protestant missionary to China, Robert Morrison. It was convened on April 25 and adjourned on May 8, 1907.^[1]

Attendees at the Conference totaled 1,170 persons, mostly missionaries from every province of China, but with representatives from 25 countries. About 100 missionary organizations were operating in China, although not all were present at the conference.^[2] Most attendees were British and American. Despite the fact that the subject of the conference was the promotion of Christianity in China fewer than 10 Chinese can be identified among the delegates. ^[3] Also, although missionary wives and single women outnumbered male missionaries in China, women were under-represented. Several served on a committee related to women’s work.^[4]

Congregationalist author-missionary Arthur Henderson Smith was elected co-Chairman of the Conference.

American missionary author and Congregationalist Arthur Henderson Smith and British Presbyterian John C. Gibson were elected joint Chairmen for the Conference. Eleven Committees presented resolutions on different subjects of interest to the delegates.

Debate and Decisions

The tenor of the Conference was optimistic. The martyrdom of 189 Protestant missionaries – men, women, and children -- during the Boxer Rebellion seven years before was hardly mentioned.^[5] Since the Boxers, the Chinese government had undertaken a large number of internal reforms and missionaries perceived a much greater openness by the Chinese to Western influences, including Christianity.

The missionaries celebrated their success in converting about 180,000 Chinese to Christianity during the previous 100 years. However, a negative note was interjected into the conference by J.W. Lowrie who said that “the far larger part of this century’s sowing [i.e. spreading Christianity]… has been on fallow ground,” ^[6] an acknowledgement that the missionaries had often been disappointed at the pace of their progress and their results.

A major objective of many at the Conference was to unite Protestant efforts into a single coordinated body rather the diverse and often competitive efforts of many different missionary organizations. William Scott Ament chaired the Committee of Federation and Comity which established a framework for united action. The Conference also called for an expansion of resources devoted to education and medical work – to the discomfort of evangelical missionaries who said that “education is not…a substitute for preaching.^[7] The most divisive and controversial issue at the Conference was the missionaries position regarding the privileges and exemptions from Chinese law given Chinese Christians under the ”unequal treaties”. Some missionaries wanted to forgo the protections of Chinese Christians as “a hated yoke upon the [Chinese] government” and an encouragement for unscrupulous Chinese to become Christians for personal advantage.^[8] But the majority disagreed and the resolution adopted by the Conference stated that “the time has not come when all the protection to Christian converts provided in the treaties can safely be withdrawn.”^[9]

Missionary William Scott Ament, famous for his clash with Mark Twain, headed a Committee at the Conference.

Consequences

The missionaries at the 1907 Conference “did not see any need to make fundamental adjustments or to reorient the missionary movement in China.” Events soon proved they were short-sighted. The optimism of the missionaries that Christianity would continue to progress in China was soon dashed as was the spirit in favor of “federation and comity.” The Qing dynasty fell in 1911 and it was followed by an era of chaos and warlords and the increasingly hostile identification of Christianity with Western Colonialism and imperialism. Within 10 years Protestant unity and cooperation coming out of the Conference was undermined by disagreement between fundamentalists and liberals. ^[10]

References

1. ^ The title page of the official record of the Conference states that the conference opened 5 Apr, but this is in error as the text of the report indicates. Chinese Centenary Missionary Conference Records (hereafter CCMCR). New York: American Tract Society, n.d., title page, p. ix
2. ^ MacGillivray, D. ed. A Century of Protestant Missions in China. Shanghai: American Tract Society, 1907, pp. v-vii
3. ^ Yao, Kevin Xiyi. “At the turn of the century: a study of the China Centenary Missionary Conference of 1907". International Bulletin of Missionary Research. Apr 2, 2008., http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-177816508.html, accessed 12 Apr 2011
4. ^ Thompson, Larry Clinton. William Scott Ament and the Boxer Rebellion: Heroism, Hubris, and the Ideal Missionary. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, 2009, p. 216
5. ^ Thompson, 184
6. ^ CCMCR, pp. 101-102
7. ^ CCMCR, p.380
8. ^ Yao, p. 67
9. ^ CCMCR, p. 743
10. ^ Yao, 69-70