Irish Republican Army (1922–1969)

:"This article deals with the Irish republican organisation opposed to the Anglo-Irish Treaty, styling itself "Irish Republican Army", as it existed from the time of the Treaty in 1921 to the split between the Official Irish Republican Army and the Provisional Irish Republican Army in 1969. See List of IRAs for a full list of organisations using the name."

The original Irish Republican Army fought a guerrilla war against British rule in Ireland in the Irish War of Independence 1919-1921. Following the signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty on 6 December 1921, the Irish Republican Army in the 26 counties that were to become the Irish Free State split between supporters and opponents of the Treaty. The 'Anti-Treatyites', sometimes referred to as the Irregulars, continued to use the name Irish Republican Army (IRA) or in Irish Óglaigh na hÉireann, as did the organisation in Northern Ireland which generally supported the pro-Treaty side. [The term "The Irregulars" was first coined by Piaras Béaslaí] "Óglaigh na hÉireann" was also adopted as the name of the pro-Treaty National Army and remains the official legal title of the Irish Defence Forces. ["Óglaigh na hÉireann" is the legal name of the Irish Defence Force - Section 3, Defence Forces (Temporary Provisions) Act 1923. also Section 16, Defence Act 1954.] This article deals with the anti-Treaty IRA that fought the Irish Civil War and was defeated by the Irish Free State forces and with its successors up to 1969, when the IRA split again.

The IRA split

"See also: IRA and the Anglo-Irish Treaty"

The signature of the Anglo-Irish Treaty by the Irish delegation in London caused an angry reaction among the more radical elements in Sinn Féin and in the IRA. Dáil Éireann ratified the Treaty by 64 votes to 57 after a lengthy and acrimonious debate, following which President Éamon de Valera resigned. Sinn Féin split between pro-Treaty and anti-Treaty factions, and the Army followed suit. The majority of headquarters staff, many of whom were close to Michael Collins, supported the Treaty, but opinion among Volunteers was divided. By and large, IRA units in Munster and most of Connacht were opposed to the Treaty, while those in favour predominated in the Midlands, Leinster and what was to become Northern Ireland. The pro-treaty Volunteers formed the nucleus of the new National Army.

In March 1922 anti-Treaty officers called an army convention, attended by their supporters, which reaffirmed their opposition to the Treaty. They repudiated the authority of the Dáil, claiming that its members had broken their oath to defend the Irish Republic and declared their own Army Executive to be the real government of the country until the Republic was formally established. The reasons why Volunteers chose pro and anti-treaty positions are complex. One factor was an evaluation of the military situation. Whereas Collins, Richard Mulcahy and Eoin O'Duffy felt that the IRA could not continue to fight the British successfully, anti-treaty officers such as Ernie O'Malley and Tom Barry felt that the IRA's position was stronger than it had ever been. Another factor was the role of powerful personalities, where the leader of an IRA unit — for example Sean McEoin who sided with the treaty in County Longford — took sides, the remainder of his command followed suit. The same was also true for anti-treaty leaders such as Liam Lynch in Cork.

After the civil war broke out officially in June 1922, the Free State government issued directives to newspapers that its Army was to be called "The National Army", its opponents were to be called "Irregulars" and were not to be associated with the IRA of 1919-1921. This attitude hardened as the civil war went on and especially after the killing of Michael Collins in an ambush in August 1922. Collins wrote to W. T. Cosgrave on 25 July 1922 that the anti-treaty side were "misguided, but practically all of them are sincere". However, the subsequent government attitude under Cosgrave was that the anti-Treaty side were rebels against the lawful government and were not entitled to recognition as legitimate combatants. Some of the officers of the new Irish Army led by Liam Tobin formed an association called the "Old IRA" to distinguish themselves from the anti-treaty fighters. Some pro-Treaty IRA officers like Eoin O'Duffy alleged that the "Irregulars" had not fought the British in War of Independence. O'Duffy claimed that the Kerry IRA's sole contribution in 1919-21 was, "the shooting of an unfortunate soldier on the day of the truce". In Kerry's case, this was far from true, however some areas such as Sligo and Wexford did see considerably more action in the civil war than in the War of Independence. Other IRA men such as Florence O'Donoghue, formed a group called the "neutral IRA", which tried to reconcile the two factions.

Meanwhile the IRA in Northern Ireland maintained their links with Michael Collins. The only Northern IRA leader to join the anti-treaty side was Belfast commander Joe McKelvey. In May 1922 they launched a renewed military offensive, in which they were aided covertly by both the National Army and the anti-Treaty IRA. This was interrupted by the outbreak of civil war in the new Irish Free State. Many Northern IRA men then had to flee the North to escape internment or worse at the hands of the Northern authorities. Over 500 of them ended up in the National Army during the civil war.

The IRA had been expanded hugely in 1922, from perhaps 15,000 men before the truce with the British in July 1921, to over 72,000 by November 1922. Veterans of the War of Independence derisively termed the new recuits, "truceileers". These were to divide in broadly the same ratio as the veterans, however, most of them did not take part in the civil war. At the beginning of the civil war, the Free State had about 8,000 fighters, mostly pro-treaty IRA Volunteers. The anti-treaty side could muster about 15,000 men but it could not arm them all. At the start of the war, they had just under 7,000 rifles, a few machine guns and a handful of armoured cars taken from British garrisons (who were under orders not to fire on IRA units) as they evacuated the country. The remainder of anti-Treaty IRA arms were shotguns (3,000 of which were confiscated after the civil war) and other civilian weapons.

The Civil War

:"Main article: Irish Civil War" Public support for the Treaty settlement and the new Irish Free State was reflected in the victory of the pro-Treaty side in general elections in 1922 and 1923. In April 1922, anti-Treaty forces controversially seized a number of public buildings in Dublin, most notably the Four Courts. Eventually, after two months and under British pressure, Michael Collins decided to remove them by force. Pro-Treaty forces bombarded the building, which surrendered after two days. Confused fighting raged for another five days, with anti Treaty elements of the IRA's Dublin Brigade under Oscar Traynor occupying O'Connell Street until they were dislodged by artillery fire.

In July 1922, the anti-Treaty IRA units held most of the south and west of Ireland. However the Republicans, under new Chief of Staff, Liam Lynch soon lost most of the territory they initially controlled. While the anti-Treaty side had a numerical advantage at the very start of the war, they were soon both outnumbered and outgunned. The Free State's National Army was quickly expanded to over 38,000 by the end of 1922 and to 55,000 men and 3,000 officers by the end of the war, recruiting Irish ex-servicemen from the British Army amongst others. Additionally, the British met its requests for arms, ammunition, armoured cars, artillery and aeroplanes. By August 1922, the Free State had re-taken all the major towns and territory held by republicans. The Free State's best troops were the Dublin Guard - a unit composed of former IRA men, mostly from the Dublin Brigade's active service unit who were to the forefront in the Free State's offensive of July-August 1922. They sided with the Free State primarily out of personal loyalty to Collins.

The anti-treaty IRA were not equipped or trained to fight conventional warfare. Despite some determined resistance to the Free State advance south of Limerick by late August, most of them had dispersed to fight a guerrilla campaign.

The anti-treaty guerrilla campaign was spasmodic and ineffective. Much of it was composed of the destruction of infrastructure such as the main railway bridge linking Cork with Dublin. They also burned many public buildings and "commandeered" supplies by force, alienating many civilians. Furthermore, without the public support that had existed during the War of Independence and facing an enemy who knew them and the countryside intimately, the Irregulars found that they could not sustain a guerrilla war such as that fought against Britain. Only in county Kerry was a relatively effective campaign fought, with the IRA units re-taking Kenmare and other towns from the Free State on several occasions. The IRA's relative popularity in this area had much to do with the brutality of the occupying Free State troops. Other areas of guerilla activity included county Cork, western county Mayo, county Wexford and several other localities.

Despite the limitations of the anti-Treaty IRA's campaign, they still inflicted more fatalities on Free State troops (about 800) in the nine month civil war than they had on British Crown forces, who lost about 600 killed in the almost three year long War of Independence (1919-1921). The disparity is no doubt due to the Free State troops relative paucity of training and equipment compared with British forces.

The conduct of the Civil War resulted in long-lasting bitterness on both sides. In September special emergency legislation came into effect under which military tribunals were empowered to pass death sentences. The head of the anti-Treaty forces, Liam Lynch, responded with an announcement that Free State TDs and senators who had voted for the legislation would be targeted. A number of members of the Oireachtas were attacked, TD Sean Hales was killed and the property of parliamentarians burnt. In addition IRA men around the country burned many of the stately homes of the old Protestant Anglo-Irish landed class - a policy motivated by both class antagonism and nationalist resentment against a class traditionally seen as "pro-British". The Free State Government, for its part, officially executed 77 Anti-Treaty prisoners. Government forces also carried out a number of atrocities against captured Irregulars. This was particularly pronounced in Kerry, where the fighting was most bitter. On at least three occasions in March 1923, IRA prisoners were massacred with land mines in reprisal for the killing of Free State soldiers. Ironically, the men accused of these war-crimes were mostly from the Dublin Guard, themselves IRA veterans from 1919-21. "See also: Executions during the Irish Civil War"

By 1923, the defeat of the anti-Treaty IRA seemed assured. It controlled no territory and its guerrilla campaign had little public support. The civil war petered out in mid 1923 after the death in action of IRA chief of staff Liam Lynch. Shortly afterwards, on 24 May 1923 the Irregulars received an order, issued by Frank Aiken, their chief-of-staff, to "dump arms". Eamon de Valera supported this in his speech "Legion of the Rearguard" ["Legion of the Rearguard" Proinsias Mac Aonghusa "Quotations from Eamon de Valera" ISBN 083426848 page 36; Aiken's order page 92] :

In de Valera's words, "Further sacrifice of life would now be vain and continuance of the struggle in arms unwise in the national interest and prejudical to the future of our cause. Military victory must be allowed to rest for the moment with those who have destroyed the Republic. Other means must be sought to safeguard the nation's right." ["IRA offered to decommission in 1923" by Ed Maloney, Sunday Tribune. [http://www.nuzhound.com/articles/moloney2000/mal31-12.htm] ]

By this time thousands of the republican Irregulars were already prisoners of the Free State government led by W. T. Cosgrave; many more were arrested after they dumped arms and returned to civilian life. By late 1923, over 12,000 anti-treaty IRA men were interned. The prisoners were released over the following year, with Eamon De Valera last to leave Kilmainham Gaol in 1924.

In 1924, the IRA counted 14,500 members in total, including young men aged from 19+, but with just over 5,000 weapons in its dumps. By 1926, the members had shrunk to 5,042. By 1930, the IRA possessed less than 2,000 members and only 859 rifles, indicating the decline in its military potential. The casualties of the Anti-Treaty IRA in the civil war have never been accurately counted, but are thought to have been considerably more than the 800 or so deaths suffered by the Free State Army, perhaps two or three times as numerous. Significantly however, the war had not been brought to an end by any kind of agreement between the two sides. The IRA of the post-civil war era would never accept the Free State as a legitimate Irish government and would continue to oppose its existence.

Ideology of the post-Civil War IRA

In 1926, after failing to persuade Sinn Féin to participate in the political institutions of the Free State, de Valera formed a new political party, called Fianna Fáil, and many Sinn Féin and IRA members left to support him. De Valera would in 1932 become President of the Executive Council, at the head of the first Fianna Fáil government.

The IRA considered itself to be upholding the Republic that was declared in the 1916 Proclamation, and held that the governments of the Irish Free State were illegitimate. It maintained that it remained the army of that Republic, in direct continuity with the IRA of the War of Independence period. It should be noted that there were several competing organisations on the radical republican side of Irish politics during this period. In addition to the IRA, these including the hard-line elements of anti-Treaty Sinn Féin who had not followed de Valera into constitutional politics, and the rump of the anti-Treaty members of the Second Dáil, still proclaiming themselves the only legitimate Irish parliament. For most of this period, the IRA's relations with Sinn Féin were poor (IRA members were even forbidden to join the party), despite the reconciliation attempt represented by the 1929 Comhairle na Poblachta. In December 1938, a reconciliation finally took place between the IRA and the Second Dáil.

Before the republican Fianna Fáil party took power after winning the Irish general election, 1932, many republicans viewed the Free State, with its censorship of newspapers and extensive coercive legislation, as a sham democracy, in the service of British imperialism. The IRA remained prepared to take over the country by insurrection, after which it expected to have to fight the British again. In November 1926, the IRA seized 11 Garda barracks, shooting dead two Gardaí. The Free State immediately used its Special Powers Act to intern 110 IRA men the next day. In 1927, IRA men assassinated Free State minister Kevin O'Higgins in revenge for his perceived responsibility for executions in the civil war. A total of four Gardaí were killed by the IRA in the period 1926-1936.

When de Valera's Fianna Fáil party won the 1932 election, the IRA expected the Free State party Cumann na nGaedheal not to respect the result and prepared for another civil war. However to their surprise, Cosgrave's party peacefully gave up power and instructed the police and armed forces to obey the new government.

In the first years of Fianna Fáil government 1932-34, the IRA's membership grew from a low of 1,800 to over 10,000. This can be put down to the radicalising impact of the Great Depression on the population, to which the IRA's new social radicalism (see next section) appealed. Another important factor was the formation of the Blueshirts - a quasi fascist organisation set up by Eoin O'Duffy, originally composed of veterans of the Free State Army in the Civil War. The IRA and the Blueshirts both attacked political meetings and also fought street brawls against each other. While most of the fighting was conducted with fists or boots, at least one Blueshirt and one IRA man were shot dead in these clashes. IRA leaders saw in these events the beginnings of a republican revolution and the overthrow of the Free State. They were, however to be disappointed.

Initially, De Valera's Fianna Fáil government was friendly towards the IRA, legalising the organisation and freeing all their prisoners who had been interned by Cummann na nGaedheal but by 1935 this relationship had turned to enmity on both sides. The IRA accused Fianna Fáil of "selling out" by not declaring "The Republic" and by tolerating the continued partition of Ireland. In 1936, De Valera banned the IRA after they murdered a landlord's agent Richard More O'Farrell in a land dispute and fired shots at police during a strike of Tramway workers in Dublin. However, most of the IRA's republican constituency were reconciled to the Free State by De Valera's government, which introduced a republican constitution in 1937, abolishing the Oath of Allegiance to the British monarchy and introducing an elected President as head of state. The document also included a territorial claim to Northern Ireland. By the late 1930s at the latest, most Irish people disagreed with the residual Irish Republican Army's claims that it remained the legitimate 'army of the Republic'.

In Northern Ireland, the IRA's main role was to try to defend the Catholic community during period outbreaks of sectarian rioting. For this reason, Peadar O'Donnell, a left wing IRA leader who was opposed to sectarian division, said disparagingly, "we don't have an IRA battalion in Belfast, we have a battalion of armed Catholics".

The IRA from 1926 to 1936: flirtations with socialism

From 1926 to 1936, the remainder of the IRA was led by Moss (Maurice) Twomey. The organisation was increasingly influenced by left-wing ideas, although the leadership's varying support for these seems to have owed more to pragmatism than to conviction. Many republicans argued that they had lost the civil war because they had not appealed to the social unrest in the country and had lacked any social or economic programme.

The IRA intervened in a number of strikes during this period, and IRA members campaigned against the payment of land annuities (in respect of the buying-out of landlords by the former British administration), with Peadar O'Donnell establishing the Anti-Tribute League in 1928. Many Communist Party of Ireland members were also members of the IRA at this time. Political initiatives such as Saor Éire in 1931 in 1933 were promoted by left-wing IRA members such as George Gilmore, Peadar O'Donnell and Frank Ryan. IRA members also helped establish the "Friends of Soviet Russia", from which they later expelled Communist Party members when relations between the two organisations deteriorated.

This burst of what has sometimes been termed "social republicanism" expired in the mid-1930s. In 1931 Saor Éire had quickly collapsed due to the combination of fierce reaction from the Catholic Church, deeply hostile to anything that appeared communist, and repressive legislation immediately introduced by the government. In 1934, left-wing IRA members, including Peadar O'Donnell, Frank Ryan and George Gilmore, frustrated with the failure of the IRA to achieve either "The Republic" or socialist revolution, left to set up a new party, the Republican Congress. This in turn, was ultimately a failure, partly because Twomey and other conservative elements in the IRA leadership opposed it and forced its supporters to leave the organisation. The Congress itself also split and collapsed after its first general meeting in 1935. From the debacle of the Republican Congress until it took a leftward turn again in the 1960s, the IRA would be inspired primarily by a conservative, strictly nationalist political outlook.

In 1936-37, a number of IRA men were among the Irish fighters (later to become known as the Connolly Column) who joined the largely communist and socialist International Brigades to fight for the Second Spanish Republic against the Nationalists during the Spanish Civil War. Frank Ryan was perhaps the most prominent Irish participant. (At the same time, members of the IRA's staunch enemies the Blueshirts under Eoin O'Duffy went to Spain to fight on the opposing side, with Franco's Nationalists.)

Legalisation and renewed repression: the 1930s and 1940s

In 1932 Fianna Fáil under de Valera formed its first government in the Irish Free State, and republican prisoners were released and the organisation unbanned. Confrontations between the IRA and the Blueshirts were a feature of political life in the early 1930s, with the former breaking up political meetings of Cumann na nGaedhael under the slogan "no free speech for traitors" and accusing the latter of being fascists.

In 1935, the IRA was banned once again, as were the Blueshirts. Moss Twomey was imprisoned, and was succeeded as chief of staff by Seán MacBride. De Valera's government increasingly followed a strict anti-IRA policy. In 1938, Seán Russell became chief of staff and set about preparations for a bombing campaign against Britain. In January 1939, the IRA Army Council declared war against Britain, and the Sabotage Campaign began a few days later.

On 23 December 1939, IRA members stole almost the entire reserve ammunition store of the Irish Army from the Magazine Fort in Dublin's Phoenix Park. This became known as the "Christmas Raid" in IRA folklore. The Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) found two and a half tons of the stolen ammunition inside County Armagh on 2 January 1940. The next day the Irish Minister for Justice, Gerald Boland, at an emergency session of the Dáil, introduced the Emergency Powers bill to reinstate internment, Military Tribunal, and executions for IRA members. It was rushed through and given its third reading the next day creating the Emergency Powers Act.

By 1941, the IRA numbered fewer than 1,000 members, many of whom were imprisoned. Most of its able political organisers had left in the mid to late 1930s and its "natural constituency" had been appropriated by Fianna Fáil.

The IRA during World War II

*"Main articles: IRA Abwehr World War II, Northern Campaign (IRA), and The Emergency"

During the Second World War, the IRA leadership hoped for support from Germany to strike against Britain during the war, and Seán Russell travelled to Germany in 1940 to canvass for arms. He became ill and died on board a German U-boat which was bringing him back to Ireland in August that year (See Operation Dove). Stephen Hayes, the acting Chief of Staff, prepared an invasion plan for Northern Ireland and sent it to German Intelligence in 1940, this plan was later called Plan Kathleen, but it was discovered by the Irish authorities within one month of its creation.

Gunther Schuetz, a member of the Abwehr, parachuted into Ireland and was almost immediately arrested. On 28 February 1942 he escaped. The IRA intended to send him back to Germany with a request for weapons, ammunition, explosives, radio equipment and money. The IRA Army Executive met on 20 April and sanctioned the requests. They resolved “to give military information to powers at war with England, which would not endanger civilian lives, even before any definite contacts have been established with these powers.” An IRA courier was arrested on the Dublin-Belfast train with documentation of the decisions taken, and details of the German contact. This led to the arrest of Schuetz, on 30 April, only hours before he was due to set sail. The boat was seized and the crew arrested. [J Bowyer Bell – "The Secret Army", pages 262-264; also Enno Stephan "Spies in Ireland" (ISBN 1-131-82692-2 (reprint)), pages 226, 245 and 275]

In 1942, the IRA launched an armed campaign in Northern Ireland. It has been rumoured that during the war period IRA members may have attempted to aid the German aerial bombing of industrial targets in Northern Ireland. However, information recovered from Germany after the war showed that the planning of raids such as the Belfast Blitz was based exclusively on the aerial reconnaissance of the Luftwaffe.

The IRA was severely damaged by the measures taken against it by the governments on both sides of the border during the Second World War. IRA members were interned both north and south of the border, and a number of IRA men, including the chief of staff between 1942 and 1944, Charlie Kerins, were executed for criminal offences by the Irish government during the war. Kerins had been tried and found guilty of the murder of a Garda (police officer).

The Border Campaign

*"Main article: Border Campaign (IRA)"Under the leadership of Tony Magan from 1948 on, the IRA rebuilt its organisation. In the 1950s it started planning for a renewed armed campaign, and in 1956 recent recruit Seán Cronin, who had considerable military experience, drew up a plan codenamed Operation Harvest.

The border campaign, as it became known, involved various military columns carrying out a range of military operations, from direct attacks on security installations to disruptive actions against infrastructure. Internment without trial, introduced first in Northern Ireland and then in the Republic of Ireland, curtailed IRA operations and ultimately broke morale.

Eighteen people in total were killed during the campaign, of whom seven were members of the RUC and eight were members of the IRA itself. Despite the boost to republican morale given by the massive turnout for the funeral in Limerick of IRA member Seán South, the campaign was on the whole a failure, and did not receive significant support from the populace on either side of the border. It petered out in the late 1950s, and was officially ended in February 1962.

The 1960s: Marxist tendency and the 1969 split

In the 1960s the IRA once more came under the influence of left-wing thinkers, especially those such as Desmond Greaves active in the Connolly Association in London. This move to a class-based political outlook and the consequent rejection of any stance that could be seen as sectarian — including the use of IRA arms to defend the beleaguered Catholic communities of Belfast in the Northern Ireland riots of August 1969 — was to be one of the factors in the 1969 split between the Official IRA and Provisional IRA wings of the republican movement, with the latter subscribing to a traditional republican analysis of the situation while the former embraced Marxism.

The Provisional IRA embarked on a thirty year armed campaign against the British presence in Northern Ireland that claimed 1707 lives. [University of Ulster "Conflict Archive on the Internet" (CAIN) database: http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/sutton/tables/Organisation_Responsible.html visualised 3 March 2006.] In 1997 it announced a ceasefire which effectively marked the end of its campaign. In 2005 it formally announced the end of its campaign and destroyed much of its weaponry under international supervision. The movement's political wing, Provisional Sinn Féin, is a growing electoral force in both Northern Ireland and the Republic.

The Official IRA mounted their own armed campaign in the Troubles up to 1972, when they called a ceasefire. However, their members on the ground engaged in some armed activities for the rest of the 1970s before effectively disbanding [ [http://www.cain.ulst.ac.uk/sutton/chron/1979.html CAIN website — last recorded death attributed to the 'Official' IRA.] ] . By the 1980s, they were an essentially political movement and distanced themselves from traditional republicanism, re-naming their political wing Sinn Féin the Workers Party in the Republic of Ireland in 1979 while in Northern Ireland they were known as Republican Clubs until 1981 and The Workers Party Republican Clubs until 1982 before both Northern and Southern sections became The Workers Party in 1982.

Feuds between the two IRAs in the 1970s claimed up to 20 lives on either side.

Footnotes

ources

* C Desmond Greaves "Liam Mellowes and the Irish Revolution" (Lawrence and Wishart, 1989)
* Dorothy Macardle, "The Irish Republic" (Corgi, 1968)
* Mike Millotte, "Communism in Modern Ireland: The Pursuit of the Workers' Republic since 1916" (Pluto, 1984) ISBN 074530317X
* Ulick O'Connor, "The Troubles" (Mandarin, 1989)
* Enno Stephan, "Spies in Ireland" (Macdonald & Co, 1963)
*Michael Hopkinson, "Green against Green - the Irish Civil War", Gill & MacMillan, Dublin 2004.
*Brian Hanley, "The IRA 1926-36", Four Courts Press, Dublin 2002.
*Seosamh Ó Longaigh, "Emergency Law in Independent Ireland, 1922-1948", Four Courts Press, 2006.

Further reading

* Henry Patterson, "The Politics of Illusion: Socialism and Republicanism in Modern Ireland" (Radius, 1989) ISBN 0091742595