Battle of Carillon

Infobox Military Conflict


caption="The Victory of Montcalm's Troops at Carillon" by Henry Alexander Ogden.
conflict=Battle of Carillon
partof=the French and Indian War
date=July 7 - July 8, 1758
place=Ticonderoga, present-day New York
result=Decisive French victory
combatant1=flagicon|France|restauration [George Ripley, Charles Anderson Dana, "The American Cyclopaedia", New York, 1874, p. 250, "...the standard of France was white, sprinkled with golden fleur de lis...". * [http://www.anyflag.com/history/fleur23.htm] The original Banner of France was strewn with fleurs-de-lis. * [http://digitalgallery.nypl.org/nypldigital/dgdisplaylargemeta.cfm?strucID=585779&imageID=1236061&parent_id=585395&word=&s=&notword=&d=&c=&f=&sScope=&sLevel=&sLabel=&lword=&lfield=&num=0&imgs=12&total=98&pos=1&snum=] :on the reverse of this plate it says: "Le pavillon royal était véritablement le drapeau national au dix-huitième siecle...Vue du chateau d'arrière d'un vaisseau de guerre de haut rang portant le pavillon royal (blanc, avec les armes de France)." [http://www.1911encyclopedia.org/Flag] from the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica: "The oriflamme and the Chape de St Martin were succeeded at the end of the 16th century, when Henry III., the last of the house of Valois, came to the throne, by the white standard powdered with fleurs-de-lis. This in turn gave place to the famous tricolour."] Kingdom of France
combatant2=flagicon|United Kingdom|1606 Great Britain
commander1=flagicon|France|restauration Louis-Joseph de Montcalm
flagicon|France|restaurationChevalier de Levis
commander2=flagicon|United Kingdom|1606 George Howe †
flagicon|United Kingdom|1606 James Abercrombie
strength1=3,600 regulars, militia, and natives
strength2=6,000 regulars,
10,000 militia
casualties1=104 killed
273 wounded [Chartrand, René, "Ticonderoga 1758: Montcalm's Victory Against All Odds", Osprey Publishing, Oxford and New York, 2000, ISBN 1 84176 093 5, Page 88]
Total: 377
casualties2=551 killed
1,356 wounded,
77 missing [Chartrand, "Ticonderoga 1758", Page 86]
Total: 1,984

The Battle of Carillon was fought at Fort Carillon (later known as Fort Ticonderoga), on the shore of Lake Champlain on what was then the border between the then British colony of New York, and French colony of Canada (present-day Quebec), July 7-July 8, 1758 during the French and Indian War (also called Seven Years War in Europe and War of Conquest in Quebec), and resulted in a victory of the French garrison under Louis-Joseph de Montcalm and the Chevalier de Levis, against the overwhelmingly superior numbers of the British attackers under General James Abercrombie.

Some military historians have cited the Battle of Carillon as a classic example of tactical military incompetence. Abercrombie, confident of a quick victory, ignored several viable military options such as trying to flank the breastworks, waiting for artillery reinforcements, or bypassing the fort entirely. Instead, on the urging of his engineers, he decided in favor of an unsuccessful frontal assault. Montcalm, conversely, has been praised for sound judgment, careful forethought, and a gallant effort on the defence.

Background

The fort is situated on a point of land between Lake Champlain and Lake George, a natural point of conflict between French forces moving south from Quebec and the Saint Lawrence River Valley across the lake toward the Hudson Valley, accessible near the southern reaches of the Lake. The fort is surrounded on three sides with water, and on one-half of the fourth side by a morass. The remaining portion was strongly fortified with high entrenchments, supported and flanked by three batteries, and the whole front of that part was blocked up with felled trees, with their branches turned outwards, and their points first sharpened, and then hardened by fire; forming altogether a most formidable defence. The fort controlled the southern reaches of Lake Champlain and access to the Hudson River.

Preparations, July 6

The British army numbered fully 16,000 men, making it the largest single force deployed on the North American continent up until that time. Its complement of 6,000 regular troops, including Lord John Murray's Highlanders of the 42nd Highland Regiment (1st Battalion) the 27th, 44th, 46th, and 55th regiments, and the 1st and 4th battalions of the 60th, arrived at the north end of Lake George on July 6 after two days on the water moving north from the remains of Fort William Henry (in modern Lake George Village). Abercrombie formed his men into regular marching columns. They marched to an outpost which had been easily cleared by Rogers' Rangers earlier in the day.

July 7

On July 7 Abercrombie resumed the march to the fort. Unfortunately for his army, the road was not wide enough to accommodate them, and they soon were scattered over a great distance. Rogers' Rangers and the British Light Infantry were sent ahead as a forward guard and guide, and were able to prevent any frontal attack by pushing aside any French skirmishers but unable to properly lead the now scattered British army (later both Rogers and Abercrombie would blame the other for this failure).

Lord Howe's light infantry were ordered to protect the exposed flank during the march engaged and entered into a small skirmish with a French patrol. This skirmish while tactically successful (the French were easily driven off), lead to the death of Lord Howe while chasing the retreating French.

In 1825 Major General David Stewart wrote an account of the battle [Stewart, David, "Sketches of the Character, Manners and Present State of the Highlanders of Scotland; with details of The Military Service of The Highland Regiments by Major-General David Stewart", Vol I & II, (1825), Edinburgh; as abridged by " [http://olivetreegenealogy.com/mil/frind/batt_ticond1758.shtml The Olive Tree Genealogy] "] :

The march was continued in the same order (July 7th), but the ground not having been previously examined, and the guides proving extremely ignorant, the columns came in contact, and were thrown in confusion. A detachment of the enemy, which got bewildered in the wood, fell in with the right column, at the head of which was Lord Howe. A smart skirmish ensued, in which the enemy were driven back and scattered, with considerable loss. This petty advantage was dearly purchased by the death of Lord Howe.

There is continued conjecture that Howe's death led to the disaster soon to befall the British, as he had encouraged Abercrombie to bring forward the field cannon. That evening General Abercrombie pulled his men back to the landing site due to concerns about fatigue and time. During the night of July 7 it was reported to Abercrombie that 3,000 French reinforcements were en route, and would be arriving soon.

July 8

On the morning of July 8 Abercrombie was determined to press his advantage before he lost his numerical superiority. The British forces faced a strongly fortified French position; while the fort was still under construction the French had thrown up high entrenchments, supported and flanked by three batteries. The land gave the British only one clear line of attack and that was blocked up with felled trees, with their branches, on Montcalm's instructions, turned outwards and sharpened. Abercrombie hastily moved his army into position, without giving time for the cannon to be moved up from the landing site. The battle was led by Rogers' Rangers pushing the few remaining scouts behind the entrenchments, the Rangers then moved out of the way to let the regular army through. The Highland Regiment then attacked (without direct orders), followed by the remainder of the army. The French position was such that they were able to lay down withering fire on the British forces as they advanced. Only briefly were any of the British able to mount the wall of trees erected by the French, only to be pushed back by a bayonet charge.

Abercrombie was forced to order a retreat, although the highlanders were at first unwilling to give up on the battle having suffered great losses. The highlanders were the first into the battle proper, and the last to leave. Along the way they suffered the highest rate of loss of any British unit.

From the 1825 account [ Stewart, "Sketches of the Character, Manners and Present State of the Highlanders of Scotland; with details of The Military Service of The Highland Regiments by Major-General David Stewart"] :

Next morning, (July 8th), he again advanced the attack, his operations being hastened by information obtained from the prisoners that General Levi, with 3,000 men, was advancing to succour Ticonderoga. Alarmed at the report of this unexpected reinforcements, the General determined to strike a decisive blow before a junction could be effected. When the troops marched up to the entrenchments, they were surprised to find a regularly fortified breast-work, which could not be approached without the greatest exertions, particularly as the artillery had not yet been brought up. Unexpected and disheartening as these obstructions were, the troops displayed the greatest resolution, though exposed to a most destructive fire, from an enemy well covered and enabled to take deliberate aim, with little danger to themselves. The Highlanders, impatient at being left in the rear, could not be restrained, and rushing forward from the reserve, were soon in the front, endeavouring to cut their way through the trees with their broadswords.
...
No ladders had been provided for scaling the breast-work. The soldiers were obliged to climb up on each other's shoulders, and by fixing their feet in the holes which they had made with their swords and bayonets in the face of the work, while the defenders were so well prepared that the instant a man reached the top, he was thrown down. At length, after great exertions, Captain John Campbell, with a few men, forced their way over the breast-work, but were immediately dispatched with the bayonet. The General, despairing of success, gave orders for a retreat; but, the Highlanders in particular were so obstinate, that it was not till after the third order from the General that the commanding officer, Colonel Grant, was able to prevail upon them to retreat, leaving on the field more than one-half of the men, and two-thirds of the officers, either killed or desperately wounded.

Impact on the "Black Watch"

The Black Watch was "first in the attack, and last in the retreat", and paid dearly with the loss of many lives and many severely wounded. However, due to the gallantry of the 42nd at Ticonderoga, letters of service were issued for adding a second battalion, and an order to make the regiment Royal, "as a testimony of his Majesty's satisfaction and approbation of the extraordinary courage, loyalty, and exemplary conduct of the Highland regiment."

The vacancies occasioned in the 42nd by the deaths at Ticonderoga were filled up in regular succession. The second battalion was to be formed of the three additional companies raised the preceding year, and of seven companies to be immediately recruited. One historical view was that the nation was highly satisfied with the conduct of the army; and the regret occasioned by the loss of so many valuable lives was alleviated by the hope, that an enterprise, so gallantly though unsuccessfully conducted, offered a fair presage of future success and glory.

The old Highland regiment having suffered so severely, and the second battalion being ordered on another service, (to the West Indies), they were not employed again this year.

42nd Highland Officers Killed (plus nine sergeants, and 297 soldiers): [All casualty data for 42nd Regiment from Stewart, "Sketches of the Character, Manners and Present State of the Highlanders of Scotland; with details of The Military Service of The Highland Regiments by Major-General David Stewart"]

* Major: Duncan Campbell of Inveraw.
* Captain: John Campbell.
* Lieutenants: George Farquharson; Hugh McPherson; William Baillie; and John Sutherland.
* Ensigns: Patrick Stewart, son of Bonskied; and George Rattray.

42nd Highland Officers Wounded (plus 10 sergeants, and 306 soldiers):
* Captains: Gordon Graham of Drainie; Thomas Graham of Duchray; John Campbell (of Strachur); James Stewart of Urrard; and James Murray of Strowen, son of Lord George Murray (and afterwards General).
* Lieutenants: James Grant; Robert Gray; John Campbell; :William Grant; John Graham, brother of Duchray; Alexander Campbell; Alexander Mackintosh; Archibald Campbell; David Miller (Milne?); and Patrick Balneaves, son of Edradour.
* Ensigns: John Smith; and Peter Grant.

Legacy

Prior to his death at the Battle of the Plains of Abraham, Montcalm correctly predicted that should New France ever fall, the British would in turn lose their cherished American colonies in the unrest that would follow. Curiously, one of the battles that opened the American Revolutionary War occurred on the site of Montcalm's most famous victory: on May 10, 1775, a group of colonials captured the small British garrison at Fort Ticonderoga – formerly known as "Fort Carillon".

The battle is also the site of the legend of Duncan Campbell, who was cursed to die at Ticonderoga, a name that he had not heard until the battle.

The modern Flag of Quebec is reputedly based upon a regimental banner carried by the victorious French-Canadian militia at Carillon.

Footnotes

Further reading

* Anderson, Fred, "Crucible of War: The Seven Years War and the Fate of Empire in British North America, 1754-1766", Faber and Faber Limited, London, 2000, ISBN 0-571-20565-8
* Nester, William, [http://www.sunypress.edu/details.asp?id=61555 "The Epic Battles of the Ticonderoga, 1758"] , State University of New York Press, Albany, 2008, ISBN 978-0-7914-7321-4