Taxation as theft

Taxation as theft

The identification of taxation as theft is a common anarcho-capitalist viewpoint. It suggests that government is transgressing property rights by enforcing compulsory tax collection. This turns the issue into not just an issue of practicality but morality. [http://www.fff.org/freedom/1197e.asp] Individualist anarchists, objectivists, anarcho-capitalists, and some libertarians see taxation as government aggression. The classic "How many men?" thought experiment challenges one to define the size and characteristics of a group that is ethically entitled to tax. Leo Tolstoy writes:cquote|"Every thief knows that stealing is wrong … that it is immoral," said Rogozhinsky, with his … slightly contemptuous smile.

"No, he does not know it. They say to him: Don't steal! and he knows that...the Government, with its officials, robs him continually by taxation."

"Why, this is Anarchism," Rogozhinsky said. …

Murray Rothbard argues in "The Ethics of Liberty" that since taxation is theft, tax resistance is therefore legitimate: "Just as no one is morally required to answer a robber truthfully when he asks if there are any valuables in one’s house, so no one can be morally required to answer truthfully similar questions asked by the State, e.g., when filling out income tax returns." [http://mises.org/rothbard/ethics/twentyfour.asp]

How many men?

"How many men?" is a thought experiment often used by anarcho-capitalists as a moral argument for showing that taxation is theft. [http://www.impel.com/liblib/NNLFAQ.html#7] There are many variations of it, but one begins with the example of a man stealing a car, which most people would regard as unethical. It then proceeds to make slight changes to the equation, with the identity of the aggressor gradually shifting from one man, to a gang of five men, to a gang of ten men who take a vote (allowing the victim to vote as well) on whether to steal the car before stealing it; to a gang of twenty men who not only take votes but have specialization of labor; to one hundred men who take the car and give the victim back a bicycle; to two hundred men who not only give the victim back a bicycle but buy a poor person a bicycle as well. It ultimately challenges the reader to say how big a group needs to be, and what characteristics it needs to have, before the immorality of theft become the alleged morality of taxation.

The argument may be seen as an example of the sorites paradox. In a classic example of the sorites paradox, removing one hair from a person's head does not make them bald, but by the time the last hair is removed, they have become bald.

Counter-arguments

A counter-argument is that taxation is a payment for services rendered, and that one who does not pay his taxes is cheating the government (and the taxpayers who shoulder the burden) by getting something for nothing and therefore deserves to be punished. [http://www.huppi.com/kangaroo/L-taxestheft.htm] The claim that taxation is theft presupposes the validity of the anarcho-capitalist claim that all government services including police and military services can and should be replaced by private provision.

Another justification for taxation is to remedy market failures with regard to "externalities". It is also argued that taxation is the 'ground rent' or compensation that is owed to each human being for the land and natural resources that have been deprived them by others' illicit appropriations. All property derives from these ill-gotten gains, and compensation must be paid accordingly. [http://www.philosophyetc.net/2005/06/why-taxation-is-not-theft.html] Thus, people are simply taking back what was rightly theirs by using the political system to tax others. Yet another counter-argument is that property is theft; i.e., that the use of "finders keepers" as a system for allocating unowned property is arbitrary and wrong. [http://www.faqs.org/faqs/libertarian/non-lib-faq/]

Another counter-argument is that taxation is part of a social contract. If you are free to emigrate, you are also free to decide if you want to stay and pay taxes or not. Many critics answer to that, saying they haven't signed any contract. According to proponents of the argument about the social contract, all contracts doesn't have to be signed, as for example, ordering food on a restaurant. [http://world.std.com/~mhuben/faq.html]

ee also

*Taxation as slavery
*Zero Aggression Principle

References


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Taxation as slavery — is the belief that taxation results in an unfree society in which individuals are forced to work to enrich the government and the recipients of largesse, rather than for their own benefit. Gail Buckley notes, for instance, In British eyes, the… …   Wikipedia

  • TAXATION — This article is arranged according to the following outline: historical aspects legal aspects the biblical period the talmudic period the post talmudic period in general yardsticks of tax assessment taxable property Place of Residence, Business,… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Tax — Taxation An aspect of fiscal policy …   Wikipedia

  • Non-aggression principle — Part of a series on Libertarianism …   Wikipedia

  • Grover Norquist — Grover Glenn Norquist (born October 19, 1956) is president of anti tax lobbying group Americans for Tax Reform.Early years and careerNorquist, who is of Swedish descent, grew up in Weston, Massachusetts and has a BA and MBA from Harvard… …   Wikipedia

  • Justice — is the concept of moral rightness based on ethics, rationality, law, natural law, fairness and equity. A conception of justice is one of the key features of society. Theories of justice vary greatly, but there is evidence that everyday views of… …   Wikipedia

  • For a New Liberty — Infobox Book | name = For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto image caption = LvMI online e book edition cover author = Murray N. Rothbard country = United States of America language = English genre = Political philosophy publisher = Ludwig… …   Wikipedia

  • Mullah Naqib — Naqib Born c.1950 Died October 13, 2007(2007 10 13) Kandahar Nationality Afghanistan Occupation Tribal leader …   Wikipedia

  • The Market for Liberty —   Cover of the hardback edition …   Wikipedia

  • Ian Angell — Infobox Scientist name = Ian O. Angell caption = birth date = bda|1947|07|08 birth place = death date = death place = residence = United Kingdom citizenship = United Kingdom nationality = ethnicity = fields = Information Systems workplaces =… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”