Robert Elsmere

Robert Elsmere is a novel by Mrs. Humphrey Ward published in 1888. It was immediately successful, quickly selling over a million copies and gaining the admiration of Henry James. [Ashton 72] Inspired by the religious crises of early Victorian clergymen such as her father Tom Arnold, Arthur Hugh Clough, and James Anthony Froude (particularly as expressed in the latter's novel "The Nemesis of Faith"), it is about an Oxford clergyman who begins to doubt the doctrines of the Anglican Church after encountering the writings of German rationalists like Schelling and David Strauss. Instead of succumbing to atheism or Roman Catholicism, however, Elsmere takes up a "constructive liberalism" (which Ward received from Thomas Hill Green) stressing social work amongst the poor and uneducated. Ward was inspired to write "Robert Elsmere" after hearing a sermon by John Wordsworth in which he argued that religious unsettlement, such as that experienced in England throughout the nineteenth century, leads to sin; Ward decided to respond by creating a sympathetic, loosely fictionalized account of the people involved in this unsettlement at the present, including her friends Benjamin Jowett, Mark Pattison, and her uncle Matthew Arnold. [Ashton 83-4]

The novel was the subject of a famous review by William Gladstone in which he criticized the novel's advocacy of the "dissociation of the moral judgment from a special series of religious formulae." [Ward, Qtd. in Ashton 78] In a more jocular manner, Oscar Wilde in his essay "The Decay of Lying" famously quipped that "Robert Elsmere" was "simply Arnold's "Literature and Dogma" with the literature left out." [Qtd in Ashton 73]

References

*cite book |last=Ashton |first=Rosemary |editor=Jasper and Wright |title=The Critical Spirit and the Will to Believe |date=1989 |publisher=St. Martins |location=New York |isbn= |pages= |chapter=Doubting Clerics: From James Anthony Froude to Robert Elsmere via George Eliot

Notes