Just compensation

Just compensation

Just Compensation is required to be paid by the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution (and counterpart state constitutions) when private property is taken (or in some states, damaged) for public use. For reasons of expedience, courts have been generally using fair market value as the measure of just compensation, reasoning that this is the amount that a willing seller would accept in a voluntary sales transaction and therefore it should also be payable in an involuntary one. However, the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly acknowledged that "fair market value" as defined by it falls short of what sellers would demand and receive in voluntary transactions.

Market value is the prevailing but not exclusive measure of just compensation. In unusual cases other measures of compensation can be used. United States v. Pewee Coal Co., 341 U.S. 114 (1951) (increased operational loss of a coal company during its temporary seizure by the government deemed to be the measure of compensation). Fair market value is defined by appraisers as the most probable price that would be paid by a willing but unpressured buyer to a willing but unpressured seller, both being fully informed as to the property's good and bad attributes, including its highest and best use which may not be the same as the use to which the property is currently being put.

The fair market value formulation assumes that the property has been exposed for sale in the market for a reasonable period of time, so that the owner may secure top dollar for the land. In eminent domain cases, the standard is often not the most probable price, but the highest price obtainable in a voluntary transaction. Since the condemnation deprives the owner of the opportunity to take his or her time to obtain top dollar in the market, the law provides it.

Market value does not include incidental losses (e.g., cost of moving, loss of business goodwill, etc.), but some of these losses are made compensable in part by statutes, such as the federal Uniform Relocation Assistance Act and its state counterparts. The judicial denial of compensation for business losses inflicted when a business conducted on the taken land is destroyed by the taking, has been the subject of much controversy and severe criticism by legal commentators. Nonetheless, only one state (Alaska) allows their recovery in all cases and so do a few others upon a showing that it is impossible for the affected business to relocate. Some states allow recovery of business losses by statute.

Likewise, the property owner's attorneys' and appraisers' fees are not included in just compensation (except in Florida where they are awarded in all cases under the state courts' interpretation of the Florida Constitution). In some states they are recoverable when the owner recovers compensation that exceeds the condemnor's offer or evidence by a specific amount. In California and New York an award of such fees is discretionary with the court.

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • just compensation — n: compensation for property taken under eminent domain that places a property owner in the same position as before the property is taken see also eminent domain ◇ Just compensation is usu. the fair market value of the property taken. Attorney s… …   Law dictionary

  • just compensation — Compensation which is fair to both the owner and the public when property is taken for public use through condemnation (eminent domain). Consideration is taken of such criteria as the cost of reproducing the property, its market value, and the… …   Black's law dictionary

  • just compensation — Compensation which is fair to both the owner and the public when property is taken for public use through condemnation (eminent domain). Consideration is taken of such criteria as the cost of reproducing the property, its market value, and the… …   Black's law dictionary

  • Just Compensation — Compensation provided to an owner whose private real property is seized by the government s power of eminent domain, which allows it to take such property for public use. For example, when the national highway system was being constructed in the… …   Investment dictionary

  • just compensation — noun The compensation provided for property taken via eminent domain. It is usually the fair market value of the property, but may be determined by other means. [...] ; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation …   Wiktionary

  • just compensation — A familiar term in constitutional provisions and statutes granting or regulating the exercise of the power of eminent domain in the condemnation and taking of private property. Reasonable compensation. A compensation which is just, not merely to… …   Ballentine's law dictionary

  • Compensation — • Denotes the price paid for human exertion or labour Catholic Encyclopedia. Kevin Knight. 2006. Compensation     Compensation     † …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • compensation — com·pen·sa·tion /ˌkäm pən sā shən/ n 1: the act of compensating 2 in the civil law of Louisiana: the ending of mutual obligations between two people for money or quantities of fungible things usu. by operation of law but sometimes by an agreement …   Law dictionary

  • just — adj [Latin justus lawful, merited, from jus right, law]: conforming to law or to the underlying principles of law: as a: conforming to reason or a standard of correctness just sanctions cannot be excessive in relation to the offense b: conforming …   Law dictionary

  • compensation — Indemnification; payment of damages; making amends; making whole; giving an equivalent or substitute of equal value. That which is necessary to restore an injured party to his former position. Remuneration for services rendered, whether in salary …   Black's law dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”