Carpenter v. Commissioner

Carpenter v. Commissioner

Carpenter v. Commissioner”, T.C. Memo 1966-228 (1966) was a case decided by the United States Tax Court. [Carpenter v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo 1966-228 (1966).] Carpenter v. Commissioner addressed the issue of whether a husband and wife could deduct the aggregate fair market value of the wife’s engagement ring from their income tax return, as a casualty loss under §165(a) and (c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, after the husband inadvertently dropped the ring in their garbage disposal.

Facts

The petitioners were Nancy Carpenter and William Carpenter. During 1962, Nancy owned a diamond engagement ring worth $1,010. One day, in the year 1962, Nancy placed the ring in a water-glass of ammonia for purposes of cleaning the ring. Nancy then left the glass, with the ring inside, next to her kitchen sink.

Later that day, William Carpenter was washing dishes, and William inadvertently “picked up the glass and emptied its contents down the” sink drain. William was unaware that the ring was in the glass. William proceeded to run the garbage disposal, which ultimately damaged Nancy’s ring.

The damaged ring was recovered from the garbage disposal and was taken to a jeweler for an appraisal. Immediately before the ring was dropped into the garbage disposal it had an aggregate fair market value of $1,010. The total aggregate fair market value of the ring immediately after being placed in the garbage disposal was $30. Subsequently, William purchased a ring for $169.50 and gave the ring to Nancy.

The petitioners deducted $1,010 from their income tax return as a casualty loss. [Id.]

Respondent’s Position

Nancy did not suffer a casualty loss within the meaning of section §165(a) & (c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954. The respondents took the position that by applying the principle of ejusdem generis, it cannot be said that William dropping the ring into the garbage disposal was like or similar to a “fire, storm, or shipwreck.” Therefore, the respondent claimed that this accident did not qualify as “other casualty” under §165. Furthermore, the respondent took the position that the replacement value of the ring, which William subsequently purchased for Nancy, and the salvage value of the original ring, must be offset against the gross loss suffered by Nancy. [Id.]

Issue

Inappropriate tone|date=December 2007Can the petitioners, Nancy and William Carpenter, deduct the aggregate fair market value of Nancy’s engagement ring from their income tax return as a casualty loss under §165(a) and (c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954?

The Court’s Holding

Inappropriate tone|date=December 2007Yes, the petitioners were correct in deducting the aggregate fair market value of the ring from their income tax return as a casualty loss under §165(a) and (c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954. [Id.]

The Court’s Reasoning

The court relied on the fact that William’s “testimony and demeanor” led the court to believe that William was not the type of person that deliberately would place the ring in the garbage disposal. Therefore, the court concluded that William placed the original ring in the garbage disposal accidentally. Accordingly, the court stated that the damage to the ring resulted form the “destructive force of the disposal coupled with the accident or mischance of placing it therein; that because this is so, the damage must be said to have arisen from fortuitous events over which petitioners had no control.”

Under the facts presented to the court, the court reasoned that the amount of the loss should not be reduced by the value of the second ring. The court explained that William was not an insurer of the ring, and therefore it was difficult to conclude that Nancy had any claim against William for her loss. The court further explained that William merely made another gift to Nancy, as an act of repentance or contrition, and not as a compensatory action. [Id.]

References


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Commissioner of Baseball — This article is about the MLB Commissioner. For the NPB Commissioner, see Commissioner of Baseball (NPB). Kenesaw Mountain Landis, the first Commissioner of Baseball The Commissioner of Baseball is the chief executive of Major League Baseball and …   Wikipedia

  • Delphus E. Carpenter — Member of the Colorado Senate from the 13th (Greeley) district In office 1909–1913 Personal details Born 13 May 1877(1877 05 13) Greeley, Colorado Died …   Wikipedia

  • Mary Carpenter — For the folk and country music singer, see Mary Chapin Carpenter. Mary Carpenter Portrait photograph of Mary Carpenter in later life. Born 3 April 1807(1807 04 03) Exeter …   Wikipedia

  • Daniel C. Carpenter — Born 1815 Albany, New York, United States Died November 15, 1866(1866 11 15) (aged 50) New York City, New York Cause of death Heart attack Nationality …   Wikipedia

  • Cyrus C. Carpenter — Cyrus Clay Carpenter (November 24, 1829 – May 29, 1898) was a Civil War officer, the eighth Governor of Iowa and U.S. Representative from Iowa s 9th congressional district. Contents 1 Early life 2 Early work 3 Civil War …   Wikipedia

  • Margaret Carpenter — For the XIXth century british painter, see Margaret Carpenter (painter). Margaret Carpenter Member of the North Carolina House of Representatives from the 52nd district In office 2001–2002 Preceded by Mary Ann Enloe Succeeded by …   Wikipedia

  • Casualty loss — A casualty loss is a type of tax loss that is a sudden, unexpected, or unusual event. [IRS Revenue Ruling 79 174] Damage or loss resulting from progressive deterioration of property through a steadily operating cause would not be a casualty loss …   Wikipedia

  • Pittsford (town), New York — Geobox|Settlement name = Pittsford native name = other name = other name1 = category = Town image size = image caption = flag size = symbol = symbol size = nickname = nickname1 = motto = country = United States state = New York region type =… …   Wikipedia

  • List of mayors of Oakland, California — This is the list of mayors of the city of Oakland, California, which was founded in 1852. It was incorporated as a city in 1854. Until the early twentieth century, all Oakland mayors served terms of only one or two years each. Contents 1 Terms 2… …   Wikipedia

  • Max I. Silber — Born February 15, 1911(1911 02 15) Died June 15, 2004(2004 06 15) (aged 93) …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”