Cowden v. Commissioner

Cowden v. Commissioner

Cowden v. Commissioner, 289 F.2d 20 (5th Cir. 1961), outlined the factors used to determine whether something received is a cash equivalent, in other words, whether something received is taxable when it was received or when it was assigned. The court observed two main doctrines in determining when something is taxable. The court relied on the doctrines of constructive receipt and cash equivalence while reiterating that substance rather than form should control income tax laws.

Contents

History

Background

The taxpayers made a contract for oil and gas royalty payments with "bonuses" payable in two subsequent years. They next signed these contracts over to a bank reporting the amounts received as long term capital gains. The Commissioner disagreed as to their designation making them taxable as capital gains.

Procedural History

The Commissioner found the “bonus” payments to be taxable at the time they were created and assigned to the extent of their fair market value subject to depletion, computed by applying a four percent discount.

The Tax Court found the "bonus" payments to be taxable at their full face value in the year of the agreement and at ordinary income rates (no depletion). The taxpayer appeals this judgment.

Decision

Previous case law seemed to imply that only obligations represented by negotiable instruments were cash equivalent. The court rejects this argument, that no obligation can be found to be a cash equivalent unless there is a negotiable instrument, as too unrealistic and formalistic. In addition, the court found that a promissory note is not necessarily a cash equivalent. The court then identified the following factors to consider when deciding if something is a cash equivalent:

  • unconditional promise to pay;
  • promisor is solvent when the note is delivered;
  • assignable;
  • not subject to set-off;
  • readily marketable; and
  • not too risky

When you have a negotiable instrument, you look at the above factors to determine if it is a cash equivalent. If the instrument IS a cash equivalent then it is taxable as if cash were received by the taxpayer instead of an obligation.

The court remanded the case to determine whether the “bonus” obligations were cash equivalents and therefore taxable in the year they were assigned.

Impact

See also

  • Tax accounting

Further reading

  • Donaldson, Samuel A., Federal Income Taxation of Individuals: Cases, Problems and Materials, Thomson/West, 2007, p. 364.

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Doctrine of cash equivalence — Part of a series on Taxation Taxation in the United States …   Wikipedia

  • Doctrine of Cash Equivalence — The Doctrine of Cash Equivalence states that the U.S. Federal income tax law treats certain non cash payment transactions like cash payment transactions for federal income tax purposes.1 The doctrine is used most often for deciding when cash… …   Wikipedia

  • List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 312 — This is a list of all the United States Supreme Court cases from volume 312 of the United States Reports :* Sibbach v. Wilson Co. , ussc|312|1|1941 * Gorin v. United States , ussc|312|19|1941 * United States v. Cowden Mfg. Co. , ussc|312|34|1941… …   Wikipedia

  • Directors from the Commonwealth Secretariat — Directors from the Commonwealth SecretariatAmitav BanerjiDirector and Head, Office of the Secretary GeneralAmitav Banerji has been Director and Head of the Secretary General’s Office since June 2000. In that capacity he offers policy advice to… …   Wikipedia

  • Dalkeith —    DALKEITH, a market town, burgh of barony, and parish, in the county of Edinburgh; containing, with the villages of Lugton and Whitehill, 5830 inhabitants, of whom 4831 are in the town, 6 miles (S. E. by S.) from Edinburgh. This place, at a… …   A Topographical dictionary of Scotland

  • Local Initiatives Support Corporation — Infobox company company name = Local Initiatives Support Corporation (LISC) company company type = Non Profit company mission = Local Initiatives Support Corporation (LISC) is dedicated to helping nonprofit community development organizations… …   Wikipedia

  • Consol Energy Center — CONSOL Energy Center …   Wikipedia

  • Montcalm County, Michigan — Location in the state of Michigan …   Wikipedia

  • Mount Albert Grammar School — Location Alberton Avenue, Mt Albert, Auckland, New Zealand Coordinates …   Wikipedia

  • Thomas of Bradwardine — • Theologian known as the Doctor Profundus Catholic Encyclopedia. Kevin Knight. 2006. Thomas of Bradwardine     Thomas of Bradwardine      …   Catholic encyclopedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”