Alexander Blane

Alexander Blane [There does not seem to have been a standard spelling, and ‘Blane’, ‘Blaine’ and ‘Blain’ are all found. Lyons (1960) and O'Brien (1957) have Blane. Walker (1978) has Blaine. The Times usually has Blane but sometimes Blaine. The Freeman’s Journal (13 January 1899) actually has Blane and Blaine on the same page (p.6). Blane is used here because it occurs most often and is the version given in the 1911 Census return.] (c.1850 – ?) was an Irish nationalist politician and MP in the House of Commons of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland and as member of the Irish Parliamentary Party for South Armagh, 1885-92. He was a supporter of Charles Stewart Parnell during the Split in the Irish Parliamentary Party, and later a pioneering Socialist. In 1876 he was appointed agent to the Catholic Registration Association, an organization dedicated to maximising the Catholic vote. He was also president of the Prisoners’ Aid Society. [The Times, 1/12/1885 and 5 July 1892]

Early life

Blane was the son of Alexander Blane of Armagh and Sydney and of Bridget, daughter of a Mr Timon of Armagh. He was born about 1850 [The Times stated on 1 December 1885, that Blane was then ‘about 30 years old’, but Blane himself gave his age as 61 in the Census of 1911, indicating a birth date about 1850.] and was a native of the city of Armagh. Blane was educated by the Christian Brothers at Greenpark. He became a master tailor.

Political career

In 1881 Blane was asked by the Land League at Armagh to stand for parliament for the county if there was an election, without result.

Tim Healy claimed in his 1928 memoirs to have helped nominate Blane as a Irish Parliamentary Party candidate in 1885::"During the General Election, the late Alex Blane, a tailor, was returned for S. Armagh as a member of the Irish Party. At Parnell's urging I went to the Convention there, which was to choose the candidate. He wanted to keep out a man named Dempsey, although Dempsey had been his nominee for Co. Derry in 1882. Meanwhile, he was supposed to have become a Davittite. An anti-Davitt prejudice swayed the minds of James O'Kelly and T. P. O'Connor, who had become the inspirers of Parnell in such affairs. Their nominee was Ivor McGuinness, of Poyntz Pass. Objections were raised against him, and I avoided putting the issue as long as I could as the Armagh priests favoured Dempsey. For this the late Canon Quinn, P.P., described me as the "most tyrannical chairman he ever knew." His attack was just, but he knew nothing of my "sailing orders." Parnell's dislike of Dempsey had been fanned, on anti-Davitt grounds, and I dared not allow him to be accepted as a candidate, if a substitute could be found.

:In my perplexity, after some hours' contention, I turned to Father McElvogue, C.C., and asked, "Have you no local man on whom you could unite?" He replied, "Did you see a chap on a ladder in his shirt-sleeves putting up the decorations as you came in? " "Yes," said I. "Well, that fellow is good at registration and election work. His name is Alex Blane. He is a tailor, and his father was a Protestant." [ [http://www.chaptersofdublin.com/books/THealy/healy18.htm Healy's memoirs online chapter 18] ]

Subsequently, in November 1885 he was returned unopposed as Nationalist MP for South Armagh, and was again unopposed in 1886. He helped organise the Plan of Campaign, aimed at agricultural rent reductions, in Gweedore, Co. Donegal, together with the local priest, Father James McFadden, and the two of them were put on trial at Dunfanaghy in January 1888 as a result. Blane was sentenced under the Irish Coercion Act to four months imprisonment, increased on appeal in April 1888 to six months. The Chief Secretary for Ireland, Arthur Balfour, was challenged in the House of Commons when he said that the sentence had been reduced. He responded ‘The original sentence, I believe, was four months with hard labour, and the new sentence was 6 months, without hard labour, I believe, and I say that is not an increase of the sentence, but it is a matter of taste’. Blane’s health suffered from his imprisonment and he was released three weeks early as a result.

In 1888 the Irish-American Catholic journalist WH Hurlbert investigated the situation in Gweedore in some detail. [ [http://www.gutenberg.org/files/14510/14510-h/14510-h.htm Hurlbert W., "Ireland under Coercion" 1888 pp.66-121 online.] ]

IPP split in 1890

When the Irish Parliamentary Party split in December 1890 over the Parnell’s leadership, Blane supported Parnell. At the general election of 1892, Blane stood as a Parnellite both in his own seat of South Armagh, and in North Westmeath. South Armagh was a three-way fight, with Parnellite, Anti-Parnellite and Unionist candidates. Blane received only 59 votes, just over 1 per cent of the votes cast. This electoral performance was not uniquely bad; all four Parnellite candidates in the province of Ulster at this election performed almost equally poorly, the best score being 123 votes at Mid Tyrone. North Westmeath was a straight fight between Parnellite and Anti-Parnellite, but Blane lost heavily here also, with under 12 per cent of the vote.

Blane was unusual in being a working-class member of the Irish Parliamentary Party, and seems to have encountered some prejudice as a result. Parnell is reported to have said, on encountering him for the first time, ‘Who is that convict-looking fellow?’. [Lyons (1977), p.343.] O'Brien [1957, pp.325-6] said Blane was ‘reputed to be one of the simpler members of the party’, adding that in the debates in Committee Room 15 of the House of Commons leading to the Split he ‘achieved the "tour de force" of defending Parnell….from an extremist Catholic and patriotic point of view…..This defence (was) exhilarating in its combination of classicism and audacity….’.

Later life

Blane did not stand for Parliament again. However he became active in working class politics. On 7 June 1896 he chaired an open-air meeting on the steps of the Custom House in Dublin which launched the Irish Socialist Republican Party, although he declined to join it himself. [Lane (1997), p.218.] The first elections for Dublin Corporation under the Local Government (Ireland) Act 1898, held on 17 January 1899, involved a huge extension of the municipal franchise, from 7,954 to 38,769 in the constabulary borough, and opened up new possibilities for working class politics. Blane stood as a labour candidate in Trinity ward but although several labour candidates were successful in other wards, he missed election by 55 votes. The 1911 Census, released on the web in December 2007, shows him living, unmarried, as a lodger at 3.2 Burgh Quay in Dublin, and gives his profession as tailor. [To date it has not proved possible to find an obituary and it is therefore not known what he did in later life or when he died.]

Footnotes

ources

Fintan Lane, "The Origins of Modern Irish Socialism, 1881-1896", Cork University Press, 1997

F. S. L. Lyons, "Charles Stewart Parnell", London, Collins, 1977

"Freeman's Journal", 18 January 1899

Conor Cruise O'Brien, "Parnell and His Party 1880-90", Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1957

"The Times" (London), 18 November 1881; 1 December 1885; 3, 27 & 30 January, 1 February, 20 & 28 April, 15 May, 22 August, 25 September 1888; 5 July 1892; 16 January 1899

Brian M. Walker (ed.), "Parliamentary Election Results in Ireland, 1801-1922", Dublin, Royal Irish Academy, 1978