Great Stirrup Controversy
- Great Stirrup Controversy
The Great Stirrup Controversy, or the Stirrup Thesis, is the theory that feudalism in Europe was largely the result of the introduction of the stirrup to cavalry.
The idea, first proposed by Lynn White Jr. in 1962, contends that as mounted warfare became easier and more effective for Frankish cavalry, they replaced infantry as the most powerful force on the battlefield, and thus aristocracy with wealth enough to own a horse became the dominant force on the battlefield, and thus were in a position to offer protection to horseless peasants.
It is agreed that cavalry replaced infantry in Carolingian France as the preferred mode of combat around the same time that feudalism emerged in that area, but whether this shift to cavalry was caused by the introduction of the stirrup is a contentious issue among historians. It has been asserted that armored cavalry were used successfully without stirrups before their introduction, and that the transition to cavalry was not a result of new technologies.
External links
* [http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/med/sloan.html John Sloan, "The stirrup controversy"]
* [http://scholar.chem.nyu.edu/tekpages/texts/strpcont.html Medieval Technology Pages:Paul J. Gans, The great stirrup controversy"]
Wikimedia Foundation.
2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Stirrup — For the bone, see stapes. For other uses of the word stirrup, see Stirrup (disambiguation). The stirrup is a ring with a flat bottom fixed on a leather strap, usually hung from each side of a saddle by an adjustable strap to create a footrest for … Wikipedia
Horses in the Middle Ages — This 15th century depiction of Charlemagne and Pope Adrian I shows a well bred medieval horse … Wikipedia
Military history of China before 1911 — Chinese military before 1911 Participant in wars involving China Active 2200 BCE – 1911 CE Leaders Chinese Emperor Area of operations China, Southeast Asia, Central Asia, and … Wikipedia
Grande controverse de l'étrier — La Grande controverse de l étrier est une controverse issue de la thèse de l étrier, théorie selon laquelle la féodalité en Europe est en grande partie le résultat de l introduction de l étrier pour la cavalerie[1]. L idée, initialement proposée… … Wikipédia en Français
Lance — For other uses, see Lance (disambiguation). Norman cavalry attacks the Anglo Saxon shield wall at the Battle of Hastings as depicted in the Bayeux Tapestry. The lances are held with one handed over the head grip. A Lance is a pole weapon or spear … Wikipedia
Wargames Research Group — The Wargames Research Group (WRG) is a British publisher of rules and reference material for miniature wargaming. Founded in 1969 they were the premier publisher of tabletop rules during the seventies and eighties, publishing rules for periods… … Wikipedia
Saddle — A saddle is a supportive structure for a rider or other load, fastened to an animal s back by a girth. The most common type is the equestrian saddle designed for a horse, but specialized saddles have been created for camels and other creatures.… … Wikipedia
pre-Columbian civilizations — Introduction the aboriginal American Indian (Mesoamerican Indian) cultures that evolved in Meso America (part of Mexico and Central America) and the Andean region (western South America) prior to Spanish exploration and conquest in the 16th … Universalium
History of the Cincinnati Reds — The following is the history of the Cincinnati Reds of Major League Baseball. Originally named the Cincinnati Red Stockings, the name was shortened to the Cincinnati Reds in the 1890s.The original Red Stockings The original Cincinnati Red… … Wikipedia
History of pottery in the Southern Levant — The history of pottery in the Southern Levant describes the discovery and cultural development of pottery in the archaeological area of the Southern Levant, which includes the modern day polities of Israel, Jordan, and the Palestinian Authority… … Wikipedia
